White Sox Fans Rage Over Missed Chance to Sign Lucas Giolito

Struggling pitching staff and bullpen woes have fans questioning team's offseason decisions.

Apr. 2, 2026 at 7:00pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A cubist, geometric painting depicting a baseball pitcher in motion, with the player's form broken down into overlapping planes of navy, green, and orange hues, conveying the fractured nature of the White Sox's pitching staff.Fans' frustration over the White Sox's pitching woes boils over as the team's rotation struggles to find stability early in the season.Chicago Today

The Chicago White Sox have stumbled out of the gate in the 2026 MLB season, posting a 1-5 record with a league-worst 8.63 team ERA. Fans are voicing frustration over the team's failure to address glaring pitching needs in the offseason, particularly by not signing free agent Lucas Giolito, who remains unsigned despite an effective 2025 campaign.

Why it matters

The White Sox's pitching woes have put immense pressure on the bullpen and exposed the team's lack of rotation depth. Fans argue the front office ignored clear warning signs and missed an opportunity to bolster the staff with a proven veteran arm like Giolito, who could have provided stability and innings-eating ability.

The details

Through the first six games, White Sox starters have struggled to go deep into games, with only two pitchers - Davis Martin and Erick Fedde - making it through five innings in their first outings. The ineffective starting rotation has forced the bullpen to shoulder a heavy workload early, leading to poor results across the pitching staff. Fans believe signing Giolito, who is still a free agent, could have provided a much-needed boost, but the team opted for internal development over adding proven talent.

  • The White Sox are 1-5 to start the 2026 MLB season.
  • On April 1, 2026, the White Sox were shut out 10-0 by the Marlins.

The players

Lucas Giolito

A free agent starting pitcher who had an effective 2025 season but remains unsigned, despite fans' calls for the White Sox to add him to their struggling rotation.

Shane Smith

The White Sox's Opening Day starter, who has failed to pitch five innings in his first two starts.

Sean Burke

A White Sox starting pitcher who did not make it through five innings in his first outing.

Anthony Kay

A White Sox starting pitcher who did not make it through five innings in his first outing.

Davis Martin

A White Sox starting pitcher who made it through five innings in his first start.

Erick Fedde

A White Sox starting pitcher who made it through five innings in his first start.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Lucas Giolito is still a free agent by the way. He costs money though and it would mean the White Sox would have a MLB caliber pitcher in their rotation. Can't have that.”

— Mike, White Sox Fan

What’s next

The White Sox have a long stretch of games coming up, and their inability to get length from their starting pitchers could continue to put strain on the bullpen. Adding a veteran arm like Lucas Giolito at this point may be difficult, as he would need time to build up and get into game shape.

The takeaway

The White Sox's early-season struggles have exposed the team's lack of rotation depth and the consequences of not addressing clear pitching needs in the offseason. Fans are rightfully frustrated that the team did not pursue a proven veteran like Lucas Giolito, who could have provided stability and innings-eating ability to a staff that has already shown signs of crumbling.