Marshals Episode 3 Recap: The Mudsucker Proxy

Can Kayce Dutton ever really use his US Marshals gig to move on if Marshals itself always has half an eye on his past?

Mar. 16, 2026 at 1:00am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

In Episode 3 of the TV series Marshals, the US Marshals team led by Kayce Dutton is called in to conduct crowd control at a protest on the Broken Rock reservation. The protest is the result of a dispute between the reservation and local mining interests, with Kayce's past at the Yellowstone ranch further complicating the situation. The episode explores how Kayce's past continues to impact his present, even as he tries to embrace his new role as a US Marshal.

Why it matters

The episode highlights the challenges Kayce faces in trying to move on from his past and embrace his new role, as the show itself seems unable to fully separate from the Dutton family history explored in the Yellowstone series. This raises questions about whether Kayce can ever truly leave his past behind.

The details

The episode sees the Marshals team called in to mitigate a dispute between the Broken Rock people and local mining interests. Thomas Rainwater has diverted truck traffic onto a road controlled by the reservation, leading to a protest that the Marshals are tasked with controlling. Kayce is confronted by Randall Clegg, whose family has deep roots in the area and blames Kayce for empowering Rainwater. The Cleggs end up shooting up the protest, leading to a pursuit and Kayce taking out one of Randall's sons.

  • The events of the episode take place in the present day.

The players

Kayce Dutton

A former US Marine who now works as a US Marshal, with a complicated past tied to the Dutton family and Yellowstone ranch.

Thomas Rainwater

The chairman of the Broken Rock reservation, who is engaged in a dispute with local mining interests.

Randall Clegg

A local resident with deep roots in the area, who blames Kayce Dutton for empowering Rainwater and disrupting his family's business.

Pete Calvin

Kayce's team leader at the US Marshals, who is struggling with his own past issues.

Miles Kittle

A newer member of the Marshals team, whom Kayce is mentoring.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Rainwater forgot the rez's place on the totem pole in these parts.”

— Randall Clegg (decider.com)

“You caused this, Dutton.”

— Randall Clegg (decider.com)

What’s next

The episode ends with someone leaving a threatening message for Kayce on his doorstep, suggesting that the conflict with the Clegg family is far from over.

The takeaway

The episode highlights the ongoing struggle for Kayce Dutton to separate his past from his present, as the Marshals series continues to draw heavily on the Dutton family history explored in Yellowstone. This raises questions about whether Kayce can ever truly move on and embrace his new role as a US Marshal.