Warren Lupel, attorney who fought wrongful conviction, dies at 83

Lupel represented Gary Dotson, a Chicago-area man who was wrongfully convicted of rape and kidnapping in 1979.

Published on Mar. 1, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Attorney Warren Lupel, who represented Gary Dotson in his fight to overturn a wrongful rape and kidnapping conviction, has died at the age of 83. Lupel spent much of his career representing judges and lawyers facing potential discipline, but took on Dotson's high-profile case due to a personal connection. Dotson was eventually exonerated and pardoned after the woman who accused him recanted her testimony and DNA evidence proved his innocence.

Why it matters

Lupel's work on the Dotson case made him a prominent figure nationally, highlighting issues around wrongful convictions and the challenges of overturning them, even in the face of recanted testimony and new evidence. His career as a 'lawyer's lawyer' also underscored the importance of legal professionals advocating for their peers facing potential discipline.

The details

Lupel was not a criminal defense lawyer, but spent much of his career representing judges and other lawyers before Illinois' Attorney Registration and Disciplinary Commission. He took on Dotson's case in 1985 after Dotson's accuser recanted her testimony, leading to Dotson's release from prison. Lupel continued working to get Dotson's conviction overturned until 1986, and Dotson was finally exonerated and pardoned in 2002.

  • Dotson was convicted of rape and kidnapping in 1979.
  • In 1985, Dotson's accuser recanted her testimony, leading to his release from prison.
  • Lupel withdrew as Dotson's attorney in 1986.
  • Dotson's conviction was overturned in 1989.
  • Dotson received a full pardon from Governor George Ryan in 2002.

The players

Warren Lupel

A longtime Evanston resident who spent much of his career representing judges and lawyers facing potential discipline, but took on the high-profile case of Gary Dotson, a Chicago-area man who was wrongfully convicted of rape and kidnapping.

Gary Dotson

A Chicago-area man who was convicted of rape and kidnapping in 1979, but was eventually exonerated and pardoned after the woman who accused him recanted her testimony and DNA evidence proved his innocence.

Cathleen Crowell Webb

The woman who accused Gary Dotson of rape and kidnapping in 1979, but later recanted her testimony, admitting she had made up the story.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“He was always for representing the underdog. When I say underdog, I mean he represented a lot of lawyers and judges who at one time or another might have been castigated for a mistake or whatever, but he never felt that a person who makes a mistake, that that's his signature in life.”

— Joel Kruger, Law school classmate (Chicago Tribune)

“He always put other people first and thought about other people. He helped anybody when anybody had a problem with a client or a friend or a friend of a friend. The first thought of somebody would be to call Warren and that was the case for me, too.”

— Michael Weininger, Former law partner (Chicago Tribune)

What’s next

A memorial service and celebration of life for Warren Lupel will be held on Sunday at 2 p.m. at Weinstein & Piser Funeral Home in Wilmette.

The takeaway

Lupel's work on the Dotson case highlighted the challenges of overturning wrongful convictions, even in the face of recanted testimony and new evidence. His career as a 'lawyer's lawyer' also underscored the importance of legal professionals advocating for their peers facing potential discipline.