Cubs Weigh Hoerner Trade Amid Roster Depth

Versatile second baseman draws interest, but Cubs seek to balance present and future needs.

Published on Feb. 27, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

The Chicago Cubs are navigating a complex situation with second baseman Nico Hoerner, fielding trade inquiries while publicly expressing a desire to retain him. This dynamic highlights a growing trend in MLB as teams balance present-day competitiveness with future roster flexibility.

Why it matters

Hoerner's value extends beyond his on-field production, with teammate Dansby Swanson emphasizing his positive impact on team chemistry. This underscores the increasing importance teams place on players who contribute to clubhouse culture, a factor often difficult to quantify but highly valued by management.

The details

The New York Yankees have emerged as a potential trade partner, with a proposed deal involving prospects Henry Lalane and Kyle Carr. This scenario reflects a broader league trend of teams with established major league rosters targeting controllable, high-floor players to fill specific needs. In return, the Cubs are seeking to replenish their farm system with pitching depth, a recognized area of need.

  • The Cubs have publicly acknowledged trade interest in Hoerner, despite previously expressing a desire to retain him.

The players

Nico Hoerner

A versatile second baseman for the Chicago Cubs who has drawn trade interest from other teams.

Dansby Swanson

A key member of the Cubs who has publicly championed Hoerner, emphasizing his value both on and off the field.

Alex Bregman

A player recently acquired by the Cubs, contributing to the team's depth at second base and the complexity of the Hoerner situation.

Matt Shaw

A Cubs prospect who is developing as a future second baseman, further complicating the team's decision-making around Hoerner.

Henry Lalane

A Yankees prospect who has been proposed in a potential trade deal for Hoerner.

Kyle Carr

Another Yankees prospect who has been proposed in a potential trade deal for Hoerner.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Nico Hoerner is irreplaceable and brings a similar competitive spirit to Alex Bregman.”

— Dansby Swanson, Cubs Player

What’s next

The Cubs will need to weigh the trade value of Hoerner against their desire to retain him, with the potential Yankees deal serving as a benchmark. The team's focus on replenishing their pitching pipeline will be a key factor in their decision-making process.

The takeaway

The Hoerner situation highlights the delicate balance teams must strike between present-day competitiveness and long-term roster flexibility. As the league trends towards versatile, high-impact players, the Cubs must carefully consider Hoerner's value both on and off the field as they navigate this complex decision.