Almost Every Mormon Wives Star Saw Whitney Leavitt's Broadway Debut

Fingers crossed this doesn't become another CMAs Instagram debacle.

Feb. 3, 2026 at 7:23pm

Whitney Leavitt, the star of the reality TV show "Secret Lives of Mormon Wives", made her Broadway debut as Roxie Hart in the musical "Chicago" on Monday night. Many of her co-stars from the show came out to support her, including Jen Affleck, who had previously feuded with Leavitt during their time on "Dancing With the Stars". The performance seems to have been well-received, though some fans are already drawing comparisons to the drama that surrounded Leavitt's time on "Dancing With the Stars".

Why it matters

Leavitt's Broadway debut is a significant milestone in her career, but the potential for drama and fan discourse around her performance is high given her past reality TV experiences. The reaction from her co-stars and fans will be closely watched to see if this is a triumphant moment or another source of controversy.

The details

Leavitt, who is no longer going by her real name onstage, received positive reviews for her performance as Roxie Hart in the long-running Broadway musical "Chicago". Clips of her performance were posted by the show's official social media accounts, and her fans praised her singing and dancing abilities. However, some fans drew comparisons to the criticism Leavitt faced during her time on "Dancing With the Stars", where some accused her of receiving preferential treatment.

  • Whitney Leavitt made her Broadway debut as Roxie Hart in "Chicago" on Monday, February 3, 2026.

The players

Whitney Leavitt

The star of the reality TV show "Secret Lives of Mormon Wives" who made her Broadway debut as Roxie Hart in "Chicago".

Jen Affleck

A co-star of Leavitt's on "Secret Lives of Mormon Wives" who had previously feuded with Leavitt during their time on "Dancing With the Stars".

Demi Engemann

A close friend of Leavitt's who is not part of the "MomTok" social media group but still supported Leavitt's Broadway debut.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

The takeaway

Leavitt's Broadway debut is a significant career milestone, but the potential for drama and fan discourse around her performance is high given her past reality TV experiences. The reaction from her co-stars and fans will be closely watched to see if this is a triumphant moment or another source of controversy.