Idaho Mandates Moment of Silence in Classrooms Statewide

Teachers and unions criticize new law as government overreach and ineffective

Mar. 27, 2026 at 2:40am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

The Idaho legislature has passed a new law requiring all public school classrooms to start the day with a mandatory 60-second moment of silence. Teachers and union leaders have criticized the law, saying it is an example of government overreach that will be difficult to implement and enforce, and will not have any meaningful impact on students.

Why it matters

The new law has sparked concerns about government interference in classroom instruction and the ability of teachers to manage their classrooms effectively. It also raises questions about enforcement and potential disciplinary actions against students who do not comply.

The details

The one-page law prohibits teachers from providing any instruction on the purpose of the minute of silence beyond what is stated in the law. Teachers will simply have to tell students 'Because we said so, you're going to be quiet for a minute.' There are concerns about how this will be implemented, as teachers are expected to teach 'bell to bell' and the moment of silence could disrupt schedules. Union leaders also worry about potential disciplinary actions against students who do not comply.

  • The law was signed by Gov. Brad Little on March 25, 2026.
  • The moment of silence requirement will begin in the next school year.

The players

Brian Coffey

President of the Nampa Education Association.

Shelly Johnson

President of the West Ada Education Association.

Rep. Bruce Skaug

Republican representative from Nampa who sponsored the bill.

Sen. Tammy Nichols

Republican senator from Middleton who sponsored the bill.

Jess Watrous

President of the Idaho Falls Education Association.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“No serious person in education thinks a moment of silence is going to achieve anything.”

— Brian Coffey, President of the Nampa Education Association

“So we just have to tell them, 'Because we said so, you're going to be quiet for a minute.'”

— Shelly Johnson, President of the West Ada Education Association

“This isn't a sneaky way to get prayer into school.”

— Rep. Bruce Skaug

“Instead of focusing on meaningful and impactful changes that would benefit every student in our state, such as better funding and support for students, our legislature chose to prioritize what many see as a nonissue.”

— Jess Watrous, President of the Idaho Falls Education Association

What’s next

The Idaho legislature is also considering a bill that would allow the state attorney general to take legal action against public officials and entities that do not comply with state laws, which could impact enforcement of the moment of silence requirement.

The takeaway

The new moment of silence law in Idaho highlights the ongoing tension between state legislators and local education leaders over control and priorities in public schools. While proponents argue the law is neutral, teachers and unions view it as government overreach that will be difficult to implement effectively.