Hawaii GOP Struggles with Infighting and MAGA Rhetoric

The state Republican party faces challenges in building a viable political opposition amid leadership turmoil.

Feb. 1, 2026 at 4:31am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

The Hawaii Republican Party has been plagued by infighting, resignations, and a focus on religious and conservative issues rather than local concerns. The party has seen some gains in recent elections, but struggles to build a cohesive and effective political opposition to the ruling Democrats.

Why it matters

A healthy two-party system is important for democracy, providing checks and balances on the ruling party. The Hawaii GOP's internal divisions and ideological focus have prevented it from becoming a viable alternative for voters frustrated with the ruling Democrats.

The details

The article details the recent turnover in the Hawaii GOP leadership, with the chair position changing hands multiple times due to resignations and infighting. The party's website emphasizes religious and conservative values over local issues, alienating more moderate voters. Despite some gains in the state legislature, the party remains divided and ineffective.

  • In May 2026, Arthur Hannemann defeated Tamara McKay to become the new state GOP chair.
  • In November 2026, Hannemann resigned after only six months due to "personal travel needs and unexpected challenges within our party".
  • Shirlene Ostrov, who headed the Donald Trump campaign in Hawaii, was elected to replace Hannemann as the new state GOP chair.

The players

Arthur Hannemann

The former chair of the Hawaii Republican Party who resigned after only six months in the position.

Tamara McKay

The former chair of the Hawaii Republican Party who was defeated by Hannemann in May 2026.

Shirlene Ostrov

The current chair of the Hawaii Republican Party, who previously headed the Donald Trump campaign in Hawaii and served as state party chair before.

Danny de Gracia

An ally of Shirlene Ostrov who promised a move away from the party's "crippling discord" in an essay in Honolulu Civil Beat.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“We acknowledge our past shortcomings, failures and oversights because our focus is on being better today, for the sake of tomorrow's successes. Change starts with us, and a Hawai'i Republican Party that is courageous enough to break from the past will be relevant for all Hawaii in the future.”

— Danny de Gracia

The takeaway

The Hawaii Republican Party faces significant challenges in building a viable political opposition to the ruling Democrats, as it grapples with internal divisions, leadership turnover, and a focus on religious and conservative issues rather than local concerns. Overcoming these obstacles will require mature and focused leadership that can unite the party and appeal to a broader range of voters.