Sarasota Theater Review: 'Birthday Candles' a Delightful Theatrical Masterpiece

Florida Studio Theatre's production of the play 'Birthday Candles' by Noah Haidle is a poignant, magical realist exploration of one woman's life over a century.

Apr. 6, 2026 at 9:18pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

An extreme close-up photograph of a birthday cake with lit candles, the flames casting a warm, glowing light on the rich, textured frosting, capturing the luxurious, tactile qualities of the cake in a high-contrast, glamorous aesthetic.The simple act of baking a birthday cake becomes a profound ritual in this heartwarming theatrical production.Sarasota Today

FST's Main stage theater production of 'Birthday Candles' by Noah Haidle is a delicious blend of magical realism and intergenerational wisdom, following the life of Ernestine Ashworth from age 17 to 107 as she bakes her way through love, loss, and the pursuit of purpose. Premiering at the Detroit Public Theatre and later gracing Broadway, this theatrical masterpiece hits the sweet spot of delightfully delightful, much like cake itself.

Why it matters

The play's ability to shift perspectives, from feeling invincible to being invisible, is a powerful theme that resonates deeply. Through the simple act of baking a birthday cake, the narrative reveals that these measured moments and rituals imbue our lives with genuine significance, contrasting with the notion that life is consumed by mundane routines.

The details

Actress Rachel Moulton's immersive portrayal of Ernestine transports the audience to a reflective state, where the essence of life is pondered upon. The cast showcases a remarkable cycle of life, with Susan Haefner deftly transitioning from Ernestine's Mother to her daughter to her grand-daughter, beautifully capturing the essence of the circle of life theme. Rob Brogan's portrayal of the nerdy yet swooning Kenneth adds a refreshing comedic touch to every scene.

  • BIRTHDAY CANDLES premiered at the Detroit Public Theatre.
  • The play later graced Broadway with Debra Messing's star power in 2022.
  • BIRTHDAY CANDLES is playing through May 17th at Florida Studio Theatre.

The players

Noah Haidle

The playwright who authored BIRTHDAY CANDLES.

Rachel Moulton

The actress who portrays the lead character, Ernestine Ashworth, in the Florida Studio Theatre production.

Susan Haefner

The actress who portrays Ernestine's Mother, daughter, and grand-daughter, showcasing the cycle of life in the play.

Rob Brogan

The actor who portrays the character of Kenneth, adding a refreshing comedic touch to the production.

Florida Studio Theatre

The regional theater in Sarasota, Florida that is hosting the production of BIRTHDAY CANDLES.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What’s next

Tickets for both matinee and evening performances of BIRTHDAY CANDLES at Florida Studio Theatre are still available, but are selling fast. Theatergoers are encouraged to purchase their tickets soon before they sell out.

The takeaway

BIRTHDAY CANDLES is a theatrical masterpiece that beautifully captures the essence of life through the simple act of baking a birthday cake. The play's ability to shift perspectives and explore the significance of life's measured moments resonates deeply, leaving audiences moved and reflective.