Woman Awarded $14M After Eating Ice Cream Laced with Metal

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A Florida jury recently awarded Brandy Buckley $14 million in damages after she suffered severe injuries from consuming butter pecan ice cream laced with metal nails and shards at a Bruster's Ice Cream shop in 2018. The incident has sparked renewed focus on food safety protocols and the potential for devastating consequences when those protocols fail.

Why it matters

This case underscores the prevalence and cost of foodborne illnesses and injuries in the U.S., which the CDC estimates cause 48 million illnesses, 128,000 hospitalizations, and 3,000 deaths each year. Beyond the human toll, these incidents carry significant economic burdens, including medical expenses, lost wages, and legal fees. The Buckley case also highlights the potential for substantial legal repercussions when companies are found negligent in ensuring food safety.

The details

Buckley unknowingly swallowed the foreign objects while enjoying ice cream with her son. An X-ray confirmed the presence of a nail in her system. The lawsuit detailed severe and permanent injuries to her head, neck, limbs, and nervous system, as well as significant scarring. Perhaps most tragically, the injuries have left Buckley unable to have children, a loss that factored heavily into the jury's decision. The complaint in the case specifically pointed to Bruster's on-site ice cream making process as a potential point of failure, raising questions about the adequacy of quality control measures in similar manufacturing environments.

• In 2018, Brandy Buckley consumed the contaminated ice cream at a Bruster's Ice Cream shop in Palm Bay, Florida.
• In 2026, a Florida jury awarded Buckley $14 million in damages.

What they’re saying

What’s next

The food industry is increasingly turning to advanced technologies like X-ray and metal detection systems, blockchain traceability, and AI-powered quality control to enhance food safety and prevent future incidents.