9 Current MLB Catchers Began Careers with Yankees

The Yankees have produced a surprising number of current big-league backstops.

Apr. 9, 2026 at 2:39am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A cubist-style painting depicting a baseball catcher's gear and equipment broken down into sharp, overlapping geometric shapes in a color palette of navy, green, and orange, conceptually representing the Yankees' ability to develop catchers.The Yankees' knack for producing top-tier catching talent is reflected in the fractured, geometric deconstruction of the tools of the trade.Today in Miami

According to a recent report, there are nine current MLB catchers who originally came up through the New York Yankees' minor league system. This includes both players still with the Yankees as well as those who have gone on to play for other teams like the Red Sox, Mets, Marlins, Rangers, and Brewers.

Why it matters

The Yankees have long been known as a premier franchise that develops top talent, but the sheer number of current MLB catchers who got their start in the Yankees organization is quite remarkable. It speaks to the team's ability to identify and cultivate catching talent, which is a valuable skill given the importance of the position.

The details

The nine current MLB catchers who began their careers with the Yankees are: Ben Rice, Austin Wells, and JC Escarra (still with the Yankees), Carlos Narvaez (Red Sox), Luis Torrens (Mets), Agustin Ramirez (Marlins), Kyle Higashioka (Rangers), Ben Rotvedt (Mets), and Gary Sanchez (Brewers). Sanchez, in particular, was an early-career star with the Yankees before his production tailed off.

  • The report was published on April 9, 2026.

The players

Ben Rice

A current Yankees player who normally plays first base but came up through the team's minor league system as a catcher.

Austin Wells

A current Yankees catcher who was developed in the team's farm system.

JC Escarra

A current Yankees catcher who is another product of the team's minor league pipeline.

Carlos Narvaez

A catcher currently playing for the rival Boston Red Sox who started his career with the Yankees.

Gary Sanchez

A former Yankees catcher who was an early-career star with the team before his production declined. He now plays for the Milwaukee Brewers.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

The takeaway

The Yankees' ability to develop catching talent is quite remarkable, with nearly a third of the current MLB starting catchers having come up through their minor league system. This speaks to the team's scouting and player development prowess, which has allowed them to maintain a steady pipeline of talent at a key position.