Marlins Ace Alcantara Frustrated After Early Removal in Ninth Inning

Marlins manager Clayton McCullough pulled Alcantara with two outs left in a shutout, leading to a late-inning collapse.

Apr. 8, 2026 at 4:29am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A fragmented, geometric painting depicting the motion of a baseball pitcher and the tense moment of a manager emerging from the dugout, the figures and field broken down into sharp, overlapping planes of color.A cubist interpretation of the high-stakes drama as a star pitcher is pulled from a dominant outing, leaving his manager and team to face the consequences.Today in Miami

Miami Marlins ace Sandy Alcantara was cruising through 8 1/3 scoreless innings on Tuesday against the Cincinnati Reds when manager Clayton McCullough pulled him after he gave up a double and a walk. The move backfired as the Marlins' bullpen blew the lead, and they eventually lost in extra innings. Alcantara expressed frustration at not being consulted before being removed from the game, saying he felt he deserved the chance to finish it.

Why it matters

Alcantara is the Marlins' ace and one of the best pitchers in baseball, having won the 2022 NL Cy Young Award. His strong start to the 2026 season has been a bright spot for the struggling Marlins, and the decision to pull him late in a dominant outing has drawn the ire of both fans and the pitcher himself.

The details

With the Marlins leading 2-0 in the top of the ninth inning, Alcantara gave up a double and a walk with one out. Marlins manager Clayton McCullough then emerged from the dugout and signaled to the bullpen for a pitching change, much to the dismay of the home crowd who loudly booed the decision. The move backfired as the Marlins' reliever Anthony Bender allowed the tying runs to score, leading to the club's eventual loss in extra innings.

  • On Tuesday, April 8, 2026, Alcantara was pulled from the game in the ninth inning.

The players

Sandy Alcantara

The Miami Marlins' ace pitcher who won the 2022 NL Cy Young Award. He was dominant through 8 1/3 innings before being pulled by the manager.

Clayton McCullough

The manager of the Miami Marlins who made the decision to pull Alcantara in the ninth inning despite his dominant outing.

Anthony Bender

The Marlins relief pitcher who allowed the tying runs to score after Alcantara was pulled, leading to the team's eventual loss.

Matt McClain

The Cincinnati Reds player who hit a double off Alcantara in the ninth inning, prompting the Marlins manager to pull the ace.

Elly De La Cruz

The Cincinnati Reds shortstop who walked after McClain's double, putting the tying runs on base and leading to Alcantara's removal.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“I feel like I deserve to be asked how I feel before getting taken out of the game. This an area where I get to 95 pitches and a righty on deck, it is what it is. Just got to get ready for my next outing.”

— Sandy Alcantara

“Really from pitch one, it was probably the best combination of stuff and execution with how he rolled through much of that game. He really threw the ball great, and as we got there in the ninth, they got a couple guys on. Fourth time some of those guys are coming up. [Thought] that Bender was the best person to win the game for us. Sandy had certainly done above and beyond, threw great.”

— Clayton McCullough, Marlins Manager

“No, he certainly did not. I made that decision. And it did not work out, obviously. Sure he felt he had plenty left to go and finish that game out. Didn't give him that opportunity.”

— Clayton McCullough, Marlins Manager

What’s next

The Marlins will look to bounce back in their next game against the Reds, with Alcantara expected to make his next start as scheduled.

The takeaway

This incident highlights the delicate balance between a manager's strategic decisions and a star player's desire to finish what he started. While McCullough's move backfired, it also underscores the high expectations Alcantara has set for himself and the Marlins as he continues his return to Cy Young form.