Miami Heat Star Named One of NBA's Most Overrated Players

Tyler Herro has blossomed into a star, but is he overrated?

Published on Feb. 18, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Tyler Herro, a seven-year member of the Miami Heat, has been named one of the NBA's most overrated players by Bleacher Report's Greg Swartz. While Herro is a potent scorer, his one-dimensional nature and inconsistent availability have led to questions about whether he is truly a max-caliber player.

Why it matters

Herro's perceived overrated status could impact his future with the Heat, as well as the team's overall performance and direction. The debate around Herro's true value as a player is significant given his high-profile role on a contending team.

The details

Swartz cited Herro's inability to stay healthy, having reached 70 games in a season just once in his seven-year career, as a key factor in his overrated status. He also noted that the Heat looked better without Herro during their 2023 playoff run, when he broke his hand in Game 1.

  • Tyler Herro has been a member of the Miami Heat for seven years.
  • Herro broke his hand in Game 1 of the 2023 playoffs.

The players

Tyler Herro

A seven-year member of the Miami Heat who has blossomed into a star, but has been labeled as one of the NBA's most overrated players.

Greg Swartz

A writer for Bleacher Report who recently included Herro in a list of the NBA's most overrated players.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Is it possible to be an All-Star and Sixth Man of the Year before turning 26 and still be overrated? In Tyler Herro's case, yes. … Herro isn't a max-caliber player or anywhere close to it. Miami made it to the Finals in 2023 after Herro broke his hand in Game 1 of the playoffs. The team looked far better without him, which should have been a sign.”

— Greg Swartz, Bleacher Report Writer (Bleacher Report)

“Having reached 70 games in a season once in his seven-year career (including just 11 so far this season), Herro has become overrated.”

— Greg Swartz, Bleacher Report Writer (Bleacher Report)

The takeaway

The debate around Tyler Herro's true value as a player is significant, as his perceived overrated status could impact his future with the Miami Heat and the team's overall performance and direction. This story highlights the ongoing discussion around player evaluation and the challenges of maintaining consistent production and availability in the NBA.