Two Arrested in Florida Keys After Separate Violent Incidents

A woman was knocked unconscious in a Stock Island assault, while a man terrorized Marathon businesses before being apprehended.

Published on Feb. 14, 2026

Monroe County deputies arrested two men, Jeanty Falando Altenor and Jajuan Antonio Josey, in separate incidents on Thursday in the Florida Keys. Altenor is accused of assaulting a 62-year-old woman in Stock Island, while Josey allegedly threatened and confronted employees at several Marathon businesses. Both men remain in custody as the investigations continue.

Why it matters

The incidents highlight ongoing public safety concerns in the Florida Keys, where law enforcement has grappled with a range of violent crimes and property offenses in recent years. The arrests also raise questions about the effectiveness of the criminal justice system in dealing with repeat offenders.

The details

In the Stock Island case, deputies say Altenor allegedly punched and kicked a 62-year-old woman until she lost consciousness when she tried to break up a fight. Neighbors intervened to stop the attack. Altenor has a prior arrest for assaulting a woman holding an infant. In Marathon, Josey is accused of trespassing, making threats, and grabbing a store owner, prompting multiple 911 calls from frightened employees. No injuries were reported in the Marathon incidents.

  • Deputies were called to the Stock Island home around 9:52 p.m. on Thursday.
  • The Marathon incidents unfolded during the midday hours on Thursday.

The players

Jeanty Falando Altenor

A 36-year-old man arrested in the Stock Island assault. He has a prior arrest for assaulting a woman holding an infant.

Jajuan Antonio Josey

A 30-year-old man arrested for the incidents at several Marathon businesses.

62-year-old woman

The victim of the alleged assault by Altenor in Stock Island, who was treated at a local hospital.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What’s next

Prosecutors are now reviewing the deputies' reports before deciding on formal charges. Both men are expected to appear in county court.

The takeaway

These incidents underscore the ongoing challenges facing law enforcement in the Florida Keys, where violent crimes and property offenses continue to be a concern for residents and businesses. The arrests highlight the need for a comprehensive approach to public safety that addresses repeat offenders and fosters stronger community engagement.