Tensions Flare Over Coconut Creek Park Use Between City and Youth Soccer Club

Dispute over field scheduling at Gerber Park leads to heated emails and calls for public forum on park use policies.

Published on Feb. 23, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A recent dispute over the use of fields at George S. Gerber Memorial Park in Coconut Creek, Florida has escalated, with emails between city parks and recreation staff and officials from the All Play Soccer Club reaching the city commission. The incident began when a city recreation programmer asked soccer players to leave the field so she could set up for an adult flag football game, leading to a confrontation with the soccer club's director. The tensions appear to be part of ongoing issues over how the city's parks and ball fields are allocated and used, which the city commission has now decided to address through a public forum.

Why it matters

The dispute highlights the challenges cities face in balancing the needs and demands of different community groups when it comes to the use of public parks and recreational facilities. As more organized youth sports programs compete for limited field space, tensions can arise, requiring cities to re-evaluate their park use policies and find ways to accommodate diverse interests.

The details

The incident on February 11th began when Katrice Eason, a senior recreation programmer for Coconut Creek, asked soccer players and parents to leave the field at Gerber Park so she could set up for an adult flag football championship game. This led to a confrontation with Michael Guardino, the director of the All Play Soccer Club, who accused Eason of calling him defamatory names and yelling at him. Eason disputed this account, saying Guardino approached her in an aggressive manner. The dispute appears to be part of ongoing tensions between the city and the soccer club over how park facilities are allocated and used, which had been discussed at a previous parks and recreation workshop.

  • The incident occurred on February 11, 2026.
  • The city commission discussed the email exchange the following night on February 12, 2026.

The players

Katrice Eason

A senior recreation programmer for the city of Coconut Creek.

Michael Guardino

The director of the All Play Soccer Club, a youth soccer organization that uses the fields at Gerber Park.

Tina Nuzzi

An official with the All Play Soccer Club who emailed city leaders about the incident.

Sheila Rose

The city manager of Coconut Creek.

John Brodie

A city commissioner in Coconut Creek who called for a public forum to discuss ongoing issues with park use.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“We had a very uncomfortable and honestly disturbing incident at the field tonight during our permitted field.”

— Tina Nuzzi, Soccer club official

“You will regret this. I can't wait to make some phone calls to Sheila Rose and the commission about you.”

— Michael Guardino, Soccer club director

“There's a problem, and it's been going on for two and a half years. This is not a new problem we ran into last night. This is a continuing problem, and if it was resolved two years ago, we wouldn't be in the boat we're in right now.”

— John Brodie, City Commissioner

What’s next

The city commission has decided to hold a public forum to allow community members to discuss ongoing issues related to the use of Coconut Creek's parks and recreational facilities.

The takeaway

This dispute highlights the challenges cities face in balancing the needs of different community groups when it comes to the use of public parks. As demand for limited field space increases, cities must re-evaluate their park use policies to find equitable solutions that accommodate diverse interests and avoid escalating tensions.