Maple Leafs Captain Auston Matthews Faces Backlash After White House Visit

Toronto columnist criticizes Matthews for embracing Trump despite strained US-Canada relations

Apr. 11, 2026 at 1:42pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

The USA Men's Hockey Team's visit to the White House following their gold medal win has sparked controversy, particularly in Canada where Maple Leafs captain Auston Matthews is facing criticism for openly embracing President Donald Trump. Toronto Star columnist Damien Cox penned a scathing piece arguing that Matthews, as the captain of the beloved Maple Leafs, should have declined the invitation due to the strained political relationship between the US and Canada.

Why it matters

The incident highlights the delicate balance between sports and politics, especially when international relations are already tense. Matthews' decision to prioritize his American pride over his role as the Maple Leafs captain has not sat well with many Canadian fans, who feel he should have been more cognizant of his responsibilities as the captain of an iconic Canadian franchise.

The details

Cox's column criticizes Matthews for his participation in the White House event, noting that many athletes and teams have previously rejected similar invitations from the Trump administration, including the entire U.S. women's hockey team. The columnist also emphasizes Matthews' role as the captain of English Canada's most renowned NHL franchise and his apparent lack of understanding of the responsibilities that come with it. Cox suggests that this incident could mark the end of the Auston Matthews era in Toronto, claiming that his decision to prioritize his American pride over his role as the Maple Leafs captain may not sit well with fans.

  • The USA Men's Hockey Team visited the White House and attended the State of the Union in April 2026.

The players

Auston Matthews

The captain of the Toronto Maple Leafs, a Canadian professional ice hockey team. Matthews is of Mexican heritage and is considered the face of the beloved Maple Leafs franchise.

Damien Cox

A longtime sportswriter for the Toronto Star who penned a scathing column criticizing Auston Matthews for his participation in the White House event.

Donald Trump

The former president of the United States, whose administration has been vocal about belittling Canada and even suggesting they become the 51st state, causing a significant dip in relations between the two countries.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Matthews, the face of Canada's beloved Maple Leafs, openly embraced Donald Trump, despite the strained political relationship between the USA and Canada.”

— Damien Cox, Toronto Star Columnist

“This incident highlights the delicate balance between sports and politics, especially when international relations are already tense.”

— Damien Cox, Toronto Star Columnist

What’s next

The upcoming game in Toronto will be a crucial moment for Matthews and the Maple Leafs fans. Will they echo Cox's sentiments and give Matthews a cold reception? The controversy is sure to spark passionate discussions among fans and commentators alike.

The takeaway

This incident raises questions about the responsibilities of athletes, especially those who represent iconic franchises, and how they should navigate the complex intersection of sports and politics. While Matthews has the right to celebrate his achievements, many Canadians feel he should have been more mindful of the political implications of his actions.