Justice Barrett Calls for Tolerance, Pluralism in Remarks

Trump-appointed Supreme Court justice appears to criticize administration's rhetoric and policies.

Mar. 13, 2026 at 12:06pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Justice Amy Coney Barrett, a Trump appointee to the Supreme Court, spoke out in favor of religious freedom, tolerance, and pluralism during a public event, seemingly contradicting recent statements and actions by President Trump and his allies.

Why it matters

Barrett's comments are seen as a rebuke of the Trump administration's rhetoric and policies, particularly around issues of religion, immigration, and foreign policy. As a conservative justice appointed by Trump, her remarks are notable and could signal a growing divide between the administration and some members of the judiciary.

The details

During a Supreme Court Fellows Program Annual Lecture at the Library of Congress, Barrett told Judge Robert Dow Jr. that 'freedom of speech and freedom of religion commit us to pluralism' and 'they commit us to tolerance.' This appeared to contradict recent statements by Trump and his allies, such as Sen. Tommy Tuberville and Rep. Andy Ogles, who have made anti-Muslim comments. Former U.S. Attorney Joyce Vance noted that Barrett's words 'are easier to say than live by today' as the president has taken a confrontational approach to Iran.

  • On March 12, 2026, Justice Barrett spoke at the Supreme Court Fellows Program Annual Lecture.

The players

Justice Amy Coney Barrett

A conservative justice appointed to the Supreme Court by President Trump in 2020.

Judge Robert Dow Jr.

The judge with whom Barrett participated in the Supreme Court Fellows Program Annual Lecture.

President Donald Trump

The president whose rhetoric and policies on religion, immigration, and foreign policy appear to be at odds with Barrett's comments on tolerance and pluralism.

Sen. Tommy Tuberville

A Republican senator who has made anti-Muslim comments that contradict Barrett's call for tolerance.

Rep. Andy Ogles

A Republican congressman who has made anti-Muslim comments that contradict Barrett's call for tolerance.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Freedom of speech and freedom of religion commit us to pluralism. They commit us to tolerance. They commit us to having to respect and allow to be heard even those viewpoints that we might disagree with.”

— Justice Amy Coney Barrett, Supreme Court Justice (rawstory.com)

“Words like these are easier to say than live by today. Justice Barrett is correct that these rights make the country more open, more accepting, more diverse, and much more rich and interesting. But we live in an era when they are undeniably being constricted, as we discussed last night.”

— Joyce Vance, Former U.S. Attorney (rawstory.com)

What’s next

It remains to be seen whether Justice Barrett's remarks will lead to any further public statements or actions from her or the Supreme Court regarding the administration's policies and rhetoric.

The takeaway

Justice Barrett's comments on tolerance and pluralism, coming from a conservative Trump appointee, suggest a potential divide between the judiciary and the administration on issues of civil liberties and religious freedom. This could have significant implications for the future direction of the country.