Olivia Dean Wins Best New Artist at Grammys

Controversial decision sparks debate over talent versus popularity

Published on Feb. 9, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Olivia Dean's win for Best New Artist at the recent Grammy Awards has caused significant backlash online, with many arguing that TikTok star Addison Rae should have won instead. However, the author argues that Dean's victory was well-deserved, citing her strong vocals, live performance abilities, and overall musicality - qualities that the author believes matter more than just hype and internet fame.

Why it matters

This debate highlights the ongoing tensions in the music industry between recognizing pure artistic talent versus rewarding commercial success and online popularity. It also speaks to the challenges women face in the industry, where they are often pitted against each other rather than celebrated for their individual strengths.

The details

The article was written by a student writer for the Her Campus at DCU chapter and does not reflect the views of the broader Her Campus publication. The author acknowledges not being a diehard fan of either Olivia Dean or Addison Rae, but argues that Dean's win was justified based on her vocal abilities, songwriting skills, and strong live performances - qualities that the author believes should be prioritized over factors like TikTok virality and carefully curated internet personas.

  • The 2026 Grammy Awards ceremony took place on February 9, 2026.

The players

Olivia Dean

The winner of the Best New Artist Grammy award, recognized for her strong vocals, songwriting abilities, and live performance skills.

Addison Rae

A TikTok star who was widely expected to win the Best New Artist Grammy, but ultimately lost to Olivia Dean.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Olivia Dean didn't win because of hype, TikTok virality, or a perfectly curated internet persona. She won because her voice is strong, controlled, emotional, and incredible live. In an industry where live performance is increasingly optional, that matters. Songwriting matters. Musicality matters. And Olivia Dean has all three.”

— The author (hercampus.com)

“Being iconic doesn't automatically equal being the strongest vocalist or musician in the room. Let's be honest: live vocals have never been her strongest suit, and that's a valid thing to acknowledge without discrediting her success entirely.”

— The author (hercampus.com)

What’s next

The article does not mention any specific next steps or future newsworthy events related to this story.

The takeaway

This debate over the Best New Artist Grammy highlights the ongoing tensions in the music industry between recognizing pure artistic talent versus rewarding commercial success and online popularity. It also speaks to the challenges women face in the industry, where they are often pitted against each other rather than celebrated for their individual strengths.