Family, Police Seek Answers in Decades-Old Missing Woman Case in New Haven

Evelyn Frisco disappeared in 2004, and her brother John continues to search for answers.

Published on Feb. 9, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

The New Haven Police Department is still investigating the case of Evelyn Frisco, a woman who went missing over 20 years ago in 2004. Her brother, John Frisco, has been searching for answers ever since, unsure if she is alive or if the worst has happened. Evelyn's case remains open and on the wall of the police department's Missing Person Unit.

Why it matters

This long-running missing persons case highlights the anguish and uncertainty that families face when a loved one disappears without a trace. The Frisco family's continued efforts to find answers and bring Evelyn home underscore the importance of keeping these cold cases active and the need for the public's assistance in providing any information that could help solve the mystery.

The details

Evelyn Frisco went missing from New Haven, Connecticut, in 2004. Her brother, John Frisco, has been searching for her ever since, unsure if she is alive or if the worst has happened. The New Haven Police Department's Missing Person Unit continues to investigate the case, and Evelyn's file remains on the wall, a constant reminder of the unanswered questions surrounding her disappearance.

  • Evelyn Frisco went missing in 2004.

The players

Evelyn Frisco

A woman who went missing from New Haven, Connecticut, in 2004.

John Frisco

Evelyn Frisco's brother, who has been searching for answers about her disappearance for over 20 years.

New Haven Police Department

The police department that continues to investigate Evelyn Frisco's disappearance and keep her case open in the Missing Person Unit.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“It's tough, because you don't know what happened. You're hoping she's alive, you're hoping that, praying. Then other times, you think the worst.”

— John Frisco, Evelyn Frisco's brother

The takeaway

This long-running missing persons case highlights the ongoing struggle for closure and justice that families face when a loved one disappears without a trace. The Frisco family's perseverance in keeping Evelyn's case active serves as a reminder of the importance of community support and law enforcement efforts in solving these types of cases, no matter how much time has passed.