UFL Outpaces NFL in Replay Transparency

New football league offers viewers a behind-the-scenes look at officiating decisions.

Apr. 6, 2026 at 1:34am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

The newly formed United Football League (UFL), a merger of the XFL and USFL, has demonstrated a level of transparency around replay reviews that the NFL has yet to match. During a crucial late-game drive, UFL officials walked viewers through their decision-making process, providing valuable insight that the NFL has historically lacked.

Why it matters

As sports betting continues to grow and fans demand more transparency from leagues, the NFL's opaque approach to replay reviews has drawn criticism. The UFL's willingness to lift the curtain on officiating could set a new standard that the NFL may need to adopt to maintain fan engagement and trust.

The details

In a close game between the Houston Gamblers and Birmingham Stallions, officials conducted three replay reviews on a critical late-game drive. The UFL's head of officiating, Mike Pereira, clearly explained the reasoning behind each decision to the television audience, a level of transparency the NFL has been reluctant to provide. Additionally, the UFL offered a detailed look at a fourth-down conversion that mirrored a controversial playoff play involving the Denver Broncos and Buffalo Bills, giving viewers valuable context around the officials' thought process.

  • On Sunday night, April 6, 2026, during a UFL regular season game.

The players

Mike Pereira

The head of officiating for the United Football League.

Kevin Sumlin

The head coach of the Houston Gamblers.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Imagine if the NFL had provided that same level of transparency during January's divisional matchup.”

— Jobe Morrison, Author

What’s next

The NFL will likely continue to monitor the UFL's approach to replay reviews and transparency, and may consider adopting similar practices in the future to address fan concerns about the league's officiating.

The takeaway

The UFL's commitment to providing viewers with a behind-the-scenes look at officiating decisions sets a new standard for transparency in professional football. As the NFL faces increasing pressure to modernize its approach, the upstart league's example could serve as a blueprint for how to build fan trust and engagement around the game's most controversial calls.