Rare 19th-century artifact stolen from Breckenridge museum

Suspect took $100 from donation jar and a brass incense burner cover used in Masonic ceremonies

Apr. 8, 2026 at 2:55pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Police are investigating a break-in at the Edwin Carter Museum in Breckenridge, Colorado, where a thief stole $100 in cash and a one-of-a-kind 19th-century artifact - a brass incense burner cover used in Masonic lodge ceremonies during the late 1800s. The total value of the stolen items is estimated between $400 and $500, but officials say the true loss is the irreplaceable historical significance of the artifact.

Why it matters

The Edwin Carter Museum has operated for over 100 years and has never experienced an incident like this before. The stolen artifact is a unique piece of history that cannot be replaced, representing a significant loss for the museum and the local community.

The details

The suspect forced open a back door and took money from a donation bin along with the brass incense burner cover. The museum's executive director, Larissa O'Neil, emphasized that everything in the museum is one-of-a-kind and a piece of history, and when something is taken, the museum loses a little bit of that history.

  • The break-in and theft occurred on April 1, 2026.

The players

Edwin Carter Museum

A museum in Breckenridge, Colorado that has operated for over 100 years since it was founded by Edwin Carter in 1875.

Larissa O'Neil

The executive director of the Breck History organization, which oversees the Edwin Carter Museum.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“It's part of our museum collection. It has intrinsic value to this space. It's part of what makes the Carter Museum what it is.”

— Larissa O'Neil, Executive Director, Breck History

“We've never had an incident like this. We can't run down to Target. We can't order something off of Amazon. Everything in this museum is one of a kind and everything here is a piece of history, and when something is taken, we lose a little bit of that history.”

— Larissa O'Neil, Executive Director, Breck History

What’s next

Police are investigating the break-in and theft, but no suspects have been identified yet. The museum is working to increase security measures to prevent similar incidents in the future.

The takeaway

This theft highlights the vulnerability of historical museums and the irreplaceable value of their collections. It underscores the importance of robust security measures and community support to protect these invaluable cultural assets for future generations.