Boulder's 'Sandwich Lady Face-Off' Finale Brings Community Together

Annual grilled cheese and tomato soup competition supports local nonprofits with live music and celebration

Apr. 6, 2026 at 5:04pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A vibrant, high-contrast silkscreen print featuring multiple images of a grilled cheese sandwich and a bowl of tomato soup, rendered in a bold, pop art style with bright neon colors and heavy black outlines.The Sandwich Lady Face-Off finale party celebrates the friendly rivalry between two beloved Boulder sandwich shop owners while supporting local charities.Boulder Today

The highly anticipated finale of the Second Annual Sandwich Lady Face-Off Competition is set to bring the Boulder community together for an afternoon of flavor, fun, and philanthropy. The event celebrates the friendly rivalry between two beloved local sandwich shop owners, Marcy Miller of Organic Sandwich Company and Lindsay Shaw of Lindsay's Boulder Deli at Haagen Dazs, as they compete for bragging rights and to support local nonprofits CASA, Voices for Children, and Blue Sky Bridge.

Why it matters

The Sandwich Lady Face-Off has become a beloved annual tradition that brings the Boulder community together around great food, local businesses, and charitable causes. The competition highlights the creativity and community spirit of these two sandwich shop owners, reinforcing Boulder's reputation as a hub for artisanal food and small business innovation.

The details

The final showdown will feature each contender's best grilled cheese and tomato soup creations, with a distinguished panel of local food and community leaders serving as judges. The closing party promises a lively atmosphere, with live performances from popular University of Colorado bands Sniff and Katire. Attendees can enjoy the music, sample the delicious offerings, and take part in the excitement as the final judging unfolds.

  • The Second Annual Sandwich Lady Face-Off Competition finale is set for Sunday, April 12, 2026.
  • Judging will take place at 1:00 PM.

The players

Marcy Miller

Owner of Organic Sandwich Company and one of the two 'Sandwich Ladies' competing in the event.

Lindsay Shaw

Owner of Lindsay's Boulder Deli at Haagen Dazs and the other 'Sandwich Lady' competing in the event.

John Lehndorff

Renowned local food critic who will be on the judging panel.

Peter Waters

Owner of Ruthie's Grilled Cheese and a member of the judging panel.

Terri Takata-Smith

Representative from the Downtown Boulder Partnership and a member of the judging panel.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“This event is about more than just incredible food—it's about community, creativity, and supporting causes that matter.”

— Marcy Miller, Owner, Organic Sandwich Company

“We're thrilled to bring everyone back together to celebrate the culmination of this year's competition.”

— Lindsay Shaw, Owner, Lindsay's Boulder Deli at Haagen Dazs

What’s next

The judges will announce the winner of the Second Annual Sandwich Lady Face-Off Competition during the finale event on April 12, 2026.

The takeaway

The Sandwich Lady Face-Off has become a beloved annual tradition that brings the Boulder community together around great food, local businesses, and charitable causes. The competition highlights the creativity and community spirit of these two sandwich shop owners, reinforcing Boulder's reputation as a hub for artisanal food and small business innovation.