Musician Billie Eilish Criticized for 'Stolen Land' Remark

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A commentary piece criticizes musician Billie Eilish for her remarks at the recent Grammy Awards ceremony, where she stated 'No one is illegal on stolen land.' The author, Arthur Saginian, argues that Eilish's statement displays ignorance, as the land was not stolen but rather won through a series of battles and wars over hundreds of years, as has happened across human history globally.

Why it matters

Eilish's comments touch on sensitive political and historical issues around land ownership and indigenous rights, which can be polarizing topics. The author's strong rebuke of Eilish's perspective reflects ongoing debates about how to interpret and teach history, especially when public figures weigh in.

The details

In the commentary, Saginian criticizes Eilish for being homeschooled until age 15 and quitting school to pursue her music career, suggesting this has led to her 'relative ignorance.' He argues that the land in question was not stolen, but rather won through a series of battles and wars over hundreds of years, a common occurrence throughout human history globally.

• The commentary was published on March 29, 2026.
• Eilish's remarks were made during the recent Grammy Awards ceremony.

What they’re saying