FAA Inspector Sues United After Lifetime Ban for Reporting Safety Concerns

Paul Asmus claims the airline tried to "build a case of character assassination" against him after he raised issues on a 2022 flight.

Feb. 4, 2026 at 3:31pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

An FAA safety inspector named Paul Asmus is suing United Airlines, accusing the company of removing him from a flight and instituting a lifetime travel ban after he allegedly observed and reported safety violations during a May 2022 flight. Asmus claims he was off-duty but still had an obligation to report the issues, including a torn seat-back pocket and a passenger standing in the aisle during pushback. United allegedly accused Asmus of being "combative" and trying to get a free seat upgrade, leading to his removal from the flight. Asmus is now suing United for defamation, interference, and other claims, seeking $12.75 million in damages.

Why it matters

This case highlights the tension between airline safety protocols and passenger rights, as well as the potential consequences for FAA inspectors who report safety concerns, even when off-duty. It raises questions about how airlines handle safety complaints from passengers and whether there are adequate protections for whistleblowers in the aviation industry.

The details

According to the complaint, Asmus was an off-duty FAA safety inspector when he boarded United flight 1684 in May 2022. He claims he noticed a torn seat-back pocket, which he says violated FAA rules, and also saw a passenger standing in the aisle during pushback, another alleged violation. Asmus says he took photos to document the issues and report them, as he was required to do. However, a flight attendant accused him of photographing the crew and being "combative", leading the captain to demand Asmus show his phone. Asmus complied, but the plane still returned to the gate and he was deplaned. United then allegedly built a case against Asmus, banning him from travel and filing a complaint with the FAA, which initiated an enforcement action. An administrative law judge later dismissed the FAA charges, finding United's claims "not credible". But United has refused to lift Asmus' travel ban.

  • On May 12, 2022, Asmus boarded United flight 1684 at San Francisco International Airport.
  • On June 27, 2025, an administrative law judge dismissed the FAA charges against Asmus.

The players

Paul Asmus

A California resident and FAA safety inspector who is suing United Airlines after he was removed from a flight and banned from travel for life for reporting alleged safety violations.

United Airlines

The Chicago-based airline that Asmus is suing, accusing them of "character assassination" and refusing to lift his lifetime travel ban despite an administrative judge dismissing the FAA's case against him.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What’s next

An initial case management conference between Asmus and United Airlines has been scheduled for May 5.

The takeaway

This case highlights the importance of protecting whistleblowers in the aviation industry, as well as the need for airlines to take passenger safety concerns seriously instead of retaliating against those who report them. It raises broader questions about accountability and transparency in the industry.