NFL Insider Questions Lions' Commitment to Jared Goff

Analysts say Detroit must decide if Goff can lead them to a Super Bowl berth.

Apr. 18, 2026 at 8:37pm by

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A cubist, geometric painting depicting a Detroit Lions football game, with the players and field broken down into sharp, overlapping planes of blue, silver, and orange, conveying the fractured nature of the team's pursuit of a Super Bowl appearance.The Lions' quest for a Super Bowl berth remains elusive, as their high-priced QB faces growing scrutiny from fans and analysts.San Francisco Today

NFL insiders are accusing the Detroit Lions and their fans of avoiding an uncomfortable conversation about quarterback Jared Goff's ability to lead the team to a Super Bowl. Despite Goff's lucrative contract extension, analysts point to his struggles in late-game situations and the team's failure to reach the Super Bowl as reasons for concern.

Why it matters

The Lions have made a major financial commitment to Goff, but some analysts believe the team may need to consider making a change at quarterback if he cannot deliver a Super Bowl appearance. This debate highlights the pressure on high-paid QBs to produce results and the difficult decisions teams face when evaluating their long-term options under center.

The details

The Lions signed Goff to a four-year, $212 million contract extension in 2024, making him one of the NFL's highest-paid quarterbacks. However, analysts point to his 67.1 passer rating in the fourth quarter of one-score games last season, which was the third-lowest mark among 24 qualifying QBs. The Lions also struggled to mount fourth-quarter comebacks and went just 3-5 in one-score games. NFL insiders like Brad Gagnon and Mike Florio believe the Lions and their fans must have an 'uncomfortable' conversation about whether Goff can truly lead the team to a Super Bowl berth.

  • The Lions reached the NFC Championship game two seasons ago but collapsed in the second half.
  • Last season, the Lions went 9-8 and missed the playoffs after a 15-2 campaign the year prior.

The players

Jared Goff

The Lions' starting quarterback who was acquired in a 2021 trade with the Los Angeles Rams and signed a lucrative contract extension in 2024.

Brad Holmes

The Detroit Lions' general manager who orchestrated the trade for Goff and signed him to the extension.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“With zero playoff wins in the last two seasons, it's fair to wonder if something is missing here, and if big changes are necessary despite all of that talent.”

— Brad Gagnon, NFL Insider, Bleacher Report

“When you are knocking softly on the door every year, there is a fatigue that sets in. At some point, the fanbase will say, 'If we're ever going to get the thing we're trying to get, we have to upgrade — someway, somehow.' And no quarterback is immune from that. At some point, you've got to deliver.”

— Mike Florio, NFL Insider

What’s next

The Lions will need to evaluate Goff's performance and decide if he is the long-term answer at quarterback or if they need to explore other options to reach the Super Bowl.

The takeaway

The debate over Jared Goff's future in Detroit highlights the pressure on high-priced quarterbacks to deliver results. While the Lions have invested heavily in Goff, some analysts believe the team and its fans may need to have a difficult conversation about whether he can truly lead them to a Super Bowl appearance.