New Bill Aims to Strengthen Privacy Protections for Journalists

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A new bill introduced by Sen. Ron Wyden and Rep. Becca Balint seeks to strengthen the Privacy Protection Act of 1980, a federal law that prohibits the government from using search warrants to raid newsrooms or seize journalists' equipment in most cases. The bill would require the government to explicitly disclose and prove any exceptions to the law when seeking search warrants, and would also ensure that evidence obtained in violation of the act cannot be used in official proceedings.

Why it matters

The Privacy Protection Act has repeatedly failed to protect journalists, with law enforcement officers obtaining search warrants against reporters without informing courts about the law. This new legislation aims to close these loopholes and ensure the act effectively prohibits search warrants targeting journalists, which is crucial for maintaining a free press.

The details

The Privacy Protection Updates Act would provide more teeth to the Privacy Protection Act of 1980, which was designed to prevent the government from raiding newsrooms or seizing journalists' materials. However, in recent years there have been multiple cases where authorities obtained search warrants against reporters without informing the courts about the act. This includes incidents involving the Washington Post, the Marion County Record, and independent journalists like Bryan Carmody and Tim Burke. The new bill would require the government to explicitly disclose and prove any exceptions to the law when seeking search warrants, and would also ensure that evidence obtained in violation of the act cannot be used in official proceedings.

• In 2023, police in Marion County, Kansas, raided the Marion County Record newsroom and the home of co-owners Eric and Joan Meyers without alerting the judge to the Privacy Protection Act.
• In 2019, San Francisco police searched journalist Bryan Carmody's home, office, and phone records without telling judges about the Privacy Protection Act or that Carmody was a journalist.
• In 2023, the FBI raided the home office of journalist Tim Burke as part of a criminal investigation, but did not inform the court that the Privacy Protection Act arguably applied to the search.

What they’re saying

What’s next

The Privacy Protection Updates Act has been introduced in Congress and will now go through the legislative process. If passed, the new law would require the government to disclose the Privacy Protection Act when seeking search warrants against journalists and would impose stronger penalties for violations.