Bay Area Holocaust Survivor's Story Told in Moving Drama 'The Optimist'

Directed by Oakland-born Finn Taylor, the film stars Stephen Lang as Herbert Heller, a Holocaust survivor who recounts his experiences in Nazi concentration camps.

Published on Mar. 10, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

The film 'The Optimist' tells the story of Herbert Heller, a Bay Area Holocaust survivor who moved to the region after World War II and owned a children's furniture and toy store in San Rafael for over 50 years. The movie, written and directed by East Bay filmmaker Finn Taylor, focuses on Heller in his 70s as he reflects back on his experiences and shares his story with a teenage girl named Abby, played by Elsie Fisher. The film shifts between Heller's harrowing memories of being imprisoned in Terezin and Auschwitz-Birkenau and his connection with Abby, who is dealing with her own personal crisis.

Why it matters

The film provides a unique perspective on the Holocaust experience by exploring how one survivor, despite the trauma he endured, was able to maintain an optimistic outlook on life. It also examines the power of storytelling and intergenerational connections to help process and make meaning of difficult pasts.

The details

Heller, played by Stephen Lang, was raised in an upper-middle class Jewish family in Prague before the Nazis stripped them of their possessions and sent them to concentration camps. The film depicts Heller's time in Terezin, where he met the Polish composer Victor Ullmann, and the horrors he faced in Auschwitz-Birkenau, including an encounter with the notorious Dr. Josef Mengele. As an older man, Heller forms an unlikely bond with a troubled teenage girl named Abby, played by Elsie Fisher, as he recounts his experiences to her.

  • The film is set in the early 1970s, when Heller was in his 70s and reflecting back on his Holocaust experiences.
  • Heller owned and operated a children's furniture and toy store in San Rafael for over 50 years after World War II.

The players

Herbert Heller

A Bay Area Holocaust survivor who moved to the region after World War II and owned a children's furniture and toy store in San Rafael for over 50 years.

Finn Taylor

The writer and director of 'The Optimist,' an Oakland-born filmmaker known for movies like 'Cherish,' 'Dream with the Fishes,' and 'The Darwin Awards.'

Elsie Fisher

The actress who plays Abby, a troubled teenage girl who forms a connection with Heller as he recounts his Holocaust experiences.

Stephen Lang

The actor who portrays the older Herbert Heller in the film.

Luke David Blumm

The actor who plays the younger Herbert Heller in the film's flashback sequences.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“The Optimist' could be described as a Holocaust drama, but it approaches that history in an unexpected way.”

— Mick LaSalle, Film Critic (sfchronicle.com)

“It requires that Taylor shift back and forth from Herbert's story, of being a teenager in Auschwitz, to Abby's story of being a teenager in Marin County. Obviously, this narrative strategy could have gone very wrong. It might have seemed to trivialize Herbert's experience, or Herbert's experience might have blown Abby's off the screen so as to render Taylor's approach counter-productive and ridiculous.”

— Mick LaSalle, Film Critic (sfchronicle.com)

“'The Optimist' doesn't go so far as to say that Herbert's personality traits enabled him to survive a death camp — his father, beautifully played by Slavko Sobin, was also an optimist, but he gradually began to just seem delusional. Still, it's certain that the teenage Herbert (played by Luke David Blumm) had a mental resiliency and a physical constitution that helped his chances.”

— Mick LaSalle, Film Critic (sfchronicle.com)

What’s next

The film 'The Optimist' is set to be released in theaters on Wednesday, March 11, 2026.

The takeaway

Through the powerful story of Holocaust survivor Herbert Heller, 'The Optimist' explores how the human spirit can endure even the most horrific of circumstances. The film's unique narrative structure and the performances of its lead actors create a moving and thought-provoking exploration of trauma, resilience, and the transformative power of storytelling.