Rancho Santa Fe Seniors Complex Wins Key Nod, Neighbors Fume

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

The Rancho Santa Fe Art Jury has unanimously approved the design for the proposed 148-unit Silvergate senior living development, moving the hotly debated project closer to reality. However, the project still faces reviews from the Rancho Santa Fe Association and the County of San Diego, as well as opposition from a neighborhood group called Protect the Covenant, who argue the project's scale and amenities clash with the Covenant's low-density, semi-rural character.

Why it matters

The Silvergate project has divided the Rancho Santa Fe community, with supporters arguing it will allow longtime residents to age in place, while opponents fear it will set a precedent for higher-density development and bring traffic, fire, and flood risks to the area. The outcome of this dispute could have significant implications for the future development and character of the Rancho Santa Fe Covenant.

The details

The Art Jury's approval is just one step in the process, as the Silvergate proposal still needs plan review by the Rancho Santa Fe Association and a major use permit from the County of San Diego. Opponents have urged the Association to treat any substantive changes as a formal covenant amendment requiring a vote of the membership, a strategy that could stretch out the timeline for any building permits.

• The Art Jury voted unanimously this week to approve the design for the proposed Silvergate community.
• The San Dieguito Community Planning Group has been tracking the project and expects the developer to return with revised plans, leaving formal county review still pending.

What’s next

The Silvergate proposal still faces plan review by the Rancho Santa Fe Association and must secure a major use permit from the County of San Diego before any construction can begin.