Toronto Blue Jays Criticized for Celebrating ALCS Banner

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

The Toronto Blue Jays held a banner ceremony before their 2026 season opener to celebrate their 2025 American League championship, but the move was heavily criticized by opposing fans who felt it was 'embarrassing' for the team to honor a runner-up finish. While the home crowd at Rogers Centre cheered, many fans on social media mocked the Blue Jays for 'hanging second place banners' and questioned why they would hold such an elaborate ceremony for not winning the World Series.

Why it matters

The backlash against the Blue Jays' banner ceremony highlights the intense pressure and expectations on professional sports teams, especially those that come close to winning a championship but ultimately fall short. The criticism also speaks to the evolving nature of how fans view and judge a team's success, with some arguing that only a World Series title is worthy of major celebrations.

The details

Prior to their 2026 season opener against the Oakland Athletics, the Blue Jays held a ceremony to unveil their 2025 American League championship banner, honoring the team's deep playoff run the previous year. Star players like Vladimir Guerrero Jr. took part in the ceremony, thanking the fans for their support. However, the move was widely mocked on social media, with fans calling it 'embarrassing' for the team to celebrate a runner-up finish. Some Blue Jays fans even agreed, arguing the team should have kept the banner unveiling low-key, similar to how the Edmonton Oilers handled their own recent Stanley Cup Final appearance.

• The Blue Jays held the banner ceremony on March 28, 2026, before their season opener against the Athletics.

What’s next

The Blue Jays will look to build on their 2025 success as they open the 2026 season, with their new pitcher Dylan Cease set to make his debut on March 29.