Napa Valley Winemaker Pleads Guilty to $2.5M Grape Scam

Jeffry Hill admits to falsely marketing wine as premium Napa Valley products for years

Published on Mar. 2, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A Napa Valley winemaker named Jeffry Hill has pleaded guilty to a massive fraud scheme involving the sale of $2.5 million in falsely-marketed wine. Hill, who owned Hill Wine Company, admitted to sourcing cheaper wine and grapes from other producers and then falsely claiming they were products of his own vineyard in order to charge premium prices, despite the lower quality. The crime dates back to 2013 and involved Hill altering shipping labels, falsifying documents, and instructing growers to lie about selling him the fruit.

Why it matters

This case highlights the ongoing problem of wine fraud and mislabeling in the premium wine industry, which can cost consumers millions of dollars. It also raises questions about oversight and accountability in the Napa Valley wine region, which is known for its high-end products. The case follows a previous conviction of Hill in 2015 for stealing grapes from a competitor, underscoring the need for stronger regulations and enforcement to protect the integrity of the wine industry.

The details

Prosecutors say Hill's yearslong operation involved sourcing wine and grapes from cheaper producers, then falsely claiming they were products of his own Napa Valley estate. This deception allowed him to charge premium prices for his bottles, despite the lower quality. Hill altered shipping labels, falsified documents, and instructed growers to lie about selling him the fruit in order to pull off the scam.

  • The crime dates back to 2013, when Hill was sourcing grapes from other vineyards and falsely claiming they came from his Napa Valley estate.
  • In 2015, Hill spent four months in jail for stealing grapes from a competitor, which set the stage for the wine mislabeling case.
  • Last January, Hill pleaded guilty to the $2.5 million grape scam.

The players

Jeffry Hill

The owner of Hill Wine Company who pleaded guilty to a massive fraud scheme involving the sale of $2.5 million in falsely-marketed wine.

Hill Wine Company

The Napa Valley winery owned by Jeffry Hill that was at the center of the $2.5 million grape scam.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“I thought I was in control. I lost sight of my values”

— Jeffry Hill (The Mercury News)

“In that blind pursuit, I destroyed not just my future but harmed those who trusted me.”

— Jeffry Hill (The Mercury News)

What’s next

Hill will likely owe at least $500,000 in restitution to victims of his scam, though the final amount has not yet been determined. Since getting sober in 2014, Hill has worked to repair his image through various philanthropic efforts.

The takeaway

This case highlights the ongoing problem of wine fraud and mislabeling in the premium wine industry, which can cost consumers millions of dollars. It also raises questions about oversight and accountability in the Napa Valley wine region, and the need for stronger regulations and enforcement to protect the integrity of the wine industry.