Carrot Top's Bizarre DVD Commentary for "The Rules of Attraction" Now Online

A peculiar piece of internet archaeology surfaces, highlighting the strange world of DVD bonus features.

Mar. 22, 2026 at 4:21am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A DVD commentary track for the 2002 film "The Rules of Attraction" featuring comedian Carrot Top has surfaced online, sparking discussion about the often overlooked world of DVD bonus content. The involvement of Carrot Top, known for his prop comedy, was reportedly a deliberate attempt at subversive humor by the film's director, Roger Avary. The commentary is described as a barrage of observations on the actresses' attractiveness, homophobic jokes, and bewildered complaints about the characters' access to sex.

Why it matters

The Carrot Top commentary highlights the fascinating and often unexpected collaborations that could arise in the world of DVD bonus features during the format's heyday in the early 2000s. These commentaries offered fans a deeper connection to films and a glimpse into the personalities of those involved in the creative process. While physical media sales have declined with the rise of streaming, the tradition of director's commentary has evolved, with more structured and interactive experiences emerging.

The details

The Rules of Attraction, based on Bret Easton Ellis's 1987 novel, follows the intertwined lives of college students navigating love, sex, and apathy. The film stars James Van Der Beek, Shannyn Sossamon, and Ian Somerhalder. Accounts suggest that director Roger Avary's intention with the Carrot Top commentary was to prank audiences who had mistakenly perceived the film as a typical teen sex comedy. Bret Easton Ellis himself offered a more pointed explanation, stating that his own commentary track was unusable due to intoxication, and Carrot Top was chosen as a deliberate insult.

  • The Rules of Attraction was released in 2002.

The players

Roger Avary

The director of The Rules of Attraction, who reportedly intended the Carrot Top commentary as a prank or insult.

Bret Easton Ellis

The author of the novel The Rules of Attraction, which the film is based on. He claimed that his own commentary track was unusable due to intoxication, leading to the Carrot Top commentary.

Carrot Top

A prop comic who recorded the bizarre DVD commentary track for The Rules of Attraction.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Bret Easton Ellis himself offered a more pointed explanation: his own commentary track was unusable due to intoxication, and Carrot Top was chosen as a deliberate insult.”

— Bret Easton Ellis

The takeaway

The Carrot Top commentary for The Rules of Attraction serves as a reminder that even the most seemingly insignificant bonus features can grow into cultural artifacts, sparking conversation and offering a unique window into the world of filmmaking. It highlights the unexpected collaborations and subversive humor that could arise in the world of DVD bonus content during the format's heyday.