The Rookie's Harrowing 'Day of Death' Episode Continues to Impact Lucy Years Later

The tense Season 2 episode put Lucy Chen through a near-death experience that still haunts her in later seasons.

Published on Feb. 24, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

The Rookie's Season 2 episode "Day of Death" was a thrilling and suspenseful installment that put Lucy Chen (Melissa O'Neil) through a harrowing ordeal when she was kidnapped and nearly murdered by a deranged serial killer. The trauma of this event continued to impact Lucy throughout the rest of the series, as she struggled with the memories and PTSD from her captivity. Years later, Lucy's experience helped her counsel another victim of a similar crime, showing how the episode had a lasting effect on the character.

Why it matters

"Day of Death" was a pivotal episode that completely changed the trajectory of The Rookie, deepening the show's exploration of its characters' emotional journeys and the lasting impact of trauma. Lucy's kidnapping and near-death experience was a visceral, high-stakes moment that raised the stakes for the series and foreshadowed the eventual romance between Lucy and her training officer, Tim Bradford (Eric Winter). The episode's lasting influence on Lucy's character development over the following seasons demonstrates the show's commitment to realistic, long-term storytelling.

The details

In the episode, Lucy's date with Caleb Wright (Michael Cassidy) is revealed to be a ruse, as Caleb is a protégé of a brutal serial killer. Caleb drugs and kidnaps Lucy, tattooing her "day of death" on her abdomen before burying her alive. Lucy's colleagues at the Mid-Wilshire Division must race against the clock to find her before she suffocates. Despite her valiant efforts to escape, Lucy is eventually recaptured and forced into a barrel that Caleb buries. Tim Bradford, who has grown close to Lucy, is the one who ultimately finds and revives her, signaling the start of their eventual romantic relationship.

  • The events of "Day of Death" take place at the end of The Rookie Season 2.
  • Years later, in The Rookie Season 8, Lucy recalls her kidnapping experience while counseling another victim of a similar crime.

The players

Lucy Chen

A police officer at the Mid-Wilshire Division who was kidnapped and nearly murdered by a serial killer's protégé in the harrowing Season 2 episode "Day of Death". The trauma of this event continues to impact her in later seasons.

Tim Bradford

Lucy's training officer, who grows increasingly close to her and is desperate to rescue her during the events of "Day of Death". Tim's actions in this episode foreshadow the eventual romantic relationship between the two characters.

Caleb Wright

A protégé of a brutal serial killer who kidnaps and nearly murders Lucy in the "Day of Death" episode.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“It's not for me, silly. It's for you. To force you to face the truth of your death. It's the gift of something we rarely get in life. Clarity.”

— Caleb Wright (Collider)

“You can choose to see that tattoo as your greatest failure. But I see it as proof that you're a survivor. It wasn't your day of death, Officer Chen. It was the first day of the rest of your life. And no one can take that away from you.”

— Tim Bradford, Police Officer (Collider)

What’s next

The Rookie continues to explore the lasting impact of Lucy's trauma in future seasons, as she helps other victims of similar crimes and continues to grapple with her own experience.

The takeaway

"Day of Death" was a pivotal episode of The Rookie that raised the stakes for the series and had a profound impact on the show's characters, particularly Lucy Chen. The episode's lasting influence on Lucy's journey demonstrates the series' commitment to realistic, long-term storytelling and the exploration of trauma and its aftermath.