Jessica Pegula 'Dumps' Tommy Paul, Plays Matchmaker With Madison Keys

The World No. 5 explained her decision to stop teaming up with the World No. 23 after a tough loss at the Eisenhower Cup.

Mar. 18, 2026 at 7:03am

After losing their first-round match at the Eisenhower Cup, Jessica Pegula made it clear that she is done teaming up with Tommy Paul. The World No. 5 explained that Paul was 'distraught' before the match after losing multiple tiebreak tournaments in the first round. This prompted a fun conversation between the American stars on social media, with Pegula suggesting that Paul should team up with Madison Keys instead.

Why it matters

The playful banter between the top American players showcases the close friendship and bond they share off the court, despite the competitive nature of their sport. This story also highlights the challenges professional athletes face in maintaining consistent performance and the impact it can have on their partnerships.

The details

Pegula and Paul entered the Eisenhower Cup together against a star-studded lineup, with Taylor Fritz and Elena Rybakina being the defending champions. Pegula had been in good form, following her semifinal runs at seven consecutive tournaments, which included a WTA 1000 title. However, Paul had been struggling in recent tournaments, despite some strong results earlier in the year. Coming off a tough loss in a $1 million exhibition tiebreak tournament, Paul was 'distraught' before the match, which ultimately led to their first-round defeat.

  • On March 18, 2026, the Players Box Podcast shared a clip of Pegula's comments on their Instagram account.
  • The first-round match at the Eisenhower Cup took place prior to the podcast clip being shared.

The players

Jessica Pegula

The World No. 5 tennis player, who has been in good form, reaching the semifinals of seven consecutive tournaments, including a WTA 1000 title.

Tommy Paul

The World No. 23 tennis player, who has been struggling in recent tournaments despite some strong results earlier in the year, including a semifinal finish at the Adelaide International and a runner-up finish at Delray Beach.

Madison Keys

An American tennis player who is a close friend of Pegula and Paul, and has been suggested by Pegula as a potential new doubles partner for Paul.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Sorry @tommypaull I think you should go back with @madisonkeys.”

— Jessica Pegula

“@tommypaull sorry @jpegula dumped you but maybe we can win it all next year? Or at least a match.”

— Madison Keys

What’s next

The judge in the case will decide on Tuesday whether or not to allow Walker Reed Quinn out on bail.

The takeaway

This case highlights growing concerns in the community about repeat offenders released on bail, raising questions about bail reform, public safety on SF streets, and if any special laws to govern autonomous vehicles in residential and commercial areas.