Federal Judge Orders Border Agents to Document Stops in California

Ruling finds agents violated previous order on warrantless arrests in the region.

Apr. 2, 2026 at 1:54am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A federal judge in California has ordered U.S. Customs and Border Protection agents to thoroughly document their reasons for making any future stops within her judicial district, finding that the agency had violated a previous order restricting warrantless immigration arrests based on racial profiling. The judge's ruling applies to a vast region spanning 34 counties and around 8 million people in California's Eastern District.

Why it matters

This ruling is the latest development in an ongoing legal battle over the Border Patrol's use of warrantless arrests, which immigration advocates have long argued violates civil liberties and unfairly targets minority communities. The judge's order aims to increase transparency and accountability around the agency's enforcement practices in the region.

The details

In her ruling, Judge Jennifer L. Thurston found that Border Patrol agents had violated her previous order restricting warrantless immigration arrests in Kern County, California. The judge said agents appeared to have made arrests without establishing that the individuals posed a flight risk or danger, as required by law. To enforce her order, Thurston is now requiring agents across the Eastern District of California to document in detail the reasons for each stop, including demonstrating reasonable suspicion that the person was not a U.S. citizen.

  • On Wednesday, April 1, 2026, Judge Thurston issued the new order.
  • Last year, Judge Thurston had previously restricted the Border Patrol from conducting random immigration sweeps in Kern County.

The players

Judge Jennifer L. Thurston

A federal judge in the Eastern District of California who has ruled against the Border Patrol's use of warrantless arrests based on racial profiling.

U.S. Customs and Border Protection

The federal law enforcement agency that has been ordered to thoroughly document its stops and arrests within Judge Thurston's judicial district.

Farmworkers' Labor Union

The labor union that brought the lawsuit that led to Judge Thurston's latest ruling against the Border Patrol's enforcement practices.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Congress requires agents to consider whether, when making warrantless arrests, the noncitizen poses a flight risk or a danger to community if released. Rather than abide by Congress's mandate, agents arrested everyone who could not establish citizenship.”

— Judge Jennifer L. Thurston, Federal Judge

What’s next

Judge Thurston's order will remain in effect until the court determines that the Border Patrol has demonstrated it is in full compliance with the requirements.

The takeaway

This ruling underscores the ongoing legal battles over the Border Patrol's enforcement tactics and the need for greater transparency and accountability around warrantless arrests that disproportionately impact immigrant communities. The judge's order aims to curb racial profiling and ensure the agency follows legal requirements for detentions.