Guthrie Abduction May Have Been Burglary Gone Bad, Says Ex-FBI Agent

Former FBI agent Jonathan Gilliam believes Nancy Guthrie was caught up in a burglary that went wrong.

Published on Feb. 23, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Former FBI Special Agent Jonathan Gilliam believes the disappearance of 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie from her Tucson, Arizona home may have been the result of a burglary gone bad. Gilliam bases his theory on surveillance video showing a masked suspect outside Guthrie's home early on February 1st, suggesting the burglar entered the residence, disturbed Guthrie, and then panicked, staying in the home for around 40 minutes before fleeing.

Why it matters

Gilliam's theory provides a potential explanation for Guthrie's disappearance, which has been a mystery since she vanished from her home. If true, it would indicate the incident was not a premeditated abduction, but rather a burglary that escalated tragically. This could have implications for the ongoing investigation and any potential suspects.

The details

According to Gilliam, the surveillance footage shows the masked suspect wearing a holster and carrying a full backpack, suggesting he may have been planning to steal items from Guthrie's home. Gilliam believes the suspect likely reacted violently when Guthrie woke up, either injuring or potentially killing her, and then spent around 40 minutes in the home trying to decide what to do before fleeing. Gilliam notes that if this was a planned abduction, the suspect likely would have left the home more quickly.

  • The surveillance video shows the masked suspect outside Guthrie's home early on February 1st, around 3 a.m.
  • Gilliam believes the suspect spent around 40 minutes inside the home before fleeing.

The players

Jonathan Gilliam

A former FBI Special Agent, Navy SEAL, and federal air marshal who has provided his theory on the Guthrie disappearance case.

Nancy Guthrie

An 84-year-old woman who disappeared from her home in Tucson, Arizona on February 1st.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“She woke up, and (the suspect) reacted, either injuring her, or potentially killing her, and then sat in there for 40 minutes trying to figure out what to do.”

— Jonathan Gilliam, Former FBI Special Agent (NewsNation)

“Somebody who's panicked would stay in the house for a while.”

— Jonathan Gilliam, Former FBI Special Agent (NewsNation)

The takeaway

Gilliam's theory provides a disturbing but plausible explanation for Guthrie's disappearance, suggesting it may have been the result of a burglary gone wrong rather than a premeditated abduction. This could have significant implications for the ongoing investigation and any potential suspects, though Gilliam acknowledges his theory is just one of many possibilities.