Arkansas Man Accused of Killing Daughter's Alleged Abuser Wins GOP Sheriff Nomination

Aaron Spencer defeated incumbent Lonoke County Sheriff John Staley in the Republican primary while awaiting trial for murder.

Published on Mar. 4, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

An Arkansas man accused of killing his daughter's alleged sexual abuser has won the Republican nomination for Lonoke County Sheriff. Aaron Spencer defeated incumbent Sheriff John Staley in the primary election, despite being out on bond and awaiting trial for the 2024 murder of Michael Fosler. Spencer maintains he acted to protect his then-13-year-old daughter from Fosler, who was out on bond for numerous sexual offenses against her.

Why it matters

This case highlights the complex intersection of vigilantism, criminal justice, and electoral politics in rural America. Spencer's victory raises questions about public attitudes toward violence committed in the name of protecting children, as well as the ability of accused criminals to run for and win elected office.

The details

On the night of the October 2024 shooting, Spencer woke up to find his daughter missing from her bedroom. He found her in the passenger seat of a vehicle Fosler was driving, and after an altercation, Spencer called 911 to report he had shot the man. Spencer's attorneys do not deny that he killed Fosler, but maintain he acted within the law to protect his child from a predator. Spencer is out on bond while awaiting trial, which was originally scheduled to start in January but was delayed after the presiding judge was removed from the case.

  • In October 2024, Spencer shot and killed Michael Fosler, who was out on bond after being charged with numerous sexual offenses against Spencer's then-13-year-old daughter.
  • The original trial date was scheduled for January 2026 but was delayed after the presiding judge was removed from the case.
  • On March 3, 2026, Spencer won the Republican nomination for Lonoke County Sheriff, defeating incumbent John Staley.

The players

Aaron Spencer

An Arkansas man accused of killing his daughter's alleged sexual abuser, Michael Fosler. Spencer won the Republican nomination for Lonoke County Sheriff while awaiting trial for Fosler's murder.

Michael Fosler

A 67-year-old man who was out on bond after being charged with numerous sexual offenses against Spencer's then-13-year-old daughter. Spencer is accused of killing Fosler in October 2024.

John Staley

The incumbent Lonoke County Sheriff, whose department arrested Spencer in 2024. Staley was defeated by Spencer in the Republican primary election.

Brian Mitchell Sr.

The Democratic candidate who will face Spencer in the November general election for Lonoke County Sheriff.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Congratulations to Mr. Spencer. Tonight the voters made their decision in the Republican Primary, and I respect the decision.”

— John Staley, Lonoke County Sheriff (Facebook)

What’s next

A new trial date has not been set for Spencer's murder case. If elected, Spencer would not be able to serve as Lonoke County Sheriff if he is convicted of killing Michael Fosler.

The takeaway

This case highlights the complex and controversial intersection of vigilantism, criminal justice, and electoral politics in rural America. Spencer's victory raises questions about public attitudes toward violence committed in the name of protecting children, as well as the ability of accused criminals to run for and win elected office.