Prosecutors Still Trying to Convict 62-Year-Old Woman for Wearing Penis Costume to Protest

Fairhope, Alabama officials refuse to drop charges despite national backlash over arrest of grandmother at 'No Kings' demonstration

Apr. 8, 2026 at 7:59pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A vibrant, fragmented painting of an inflatable penis costume in patriotic colors, conveying the clash between free expression and government crackdown on dissent.A fractured, avant-garde painting captures the chaotic confrontation between a grandmother's inflatable protest and the heavy-handed response of local authorities.Fairhope Today

A 62-year-old woman named Renea Gamble was arrested at an anti-Trump protest in Fairhope, Alabama for wearing an inflatable penis costume. Despite widespread criticism and a viral video of the arrest, local prosecutors are still pursuing criminal charges against Gamble, claiming her costume violated 'community standards'.

Why it matters

The case highlights the tension between law enforcement's desire to maintain 'order' and citizens' constitutional rights to free speech and expression, even if the speech is unconventional or controversial. The arrest has drawn national attention and criticism, putting Fairhope officials in an uncomfortable spotlight.

The details

In the video of the incident, police are seen struggling to remove Gamble from her inflatable costume and stuff her into a police car. Officers also charged Gamble with giving a false name after she sarcastically responded 'Auntie Fa' when asked for her identity. Prosecutors are still pursuing criminal charges against Gamble despite widespread criticism that the arrest violated her First Amendment rights.

  • The incident occurred at a 'No Kings' protest in Fairhope, Alabama on April 8, 2026.

The players

Renea Gamble

A 62-year-old woman arrested for wearing an inflatable penis costume to an anti-Trump protest in Fairhope, Alabama.

Corporal Andrew Babb

A Fairhope police officer who arrested Gamble and insisted her costume violated 'community standards'.

Sherry Sullivan

The mayor of Fairhope, Alabama who claimed Gamble's costume was an 'obscene display' that would 'not be tolerated'.

Jack Burrell

The Fairhope City Council president who said Gamble's costume 'violated community standards'.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Every easily-offended, would-be censor has the same go-to for complaining about stuff they don't like: 'how would I explain that to my children?' I don't know, man. They're your kids. Take any approach you want, including ignoring the question. It's not on the rest of the world to make sure you never have to have an uncomfortable conversation with your kids.”

— Liliana Segura, Writer

“People who view dissent as a threat, if not inherently unlawful, cannot ever hope to win. Acts like this only embolden those already involved in dissent and attract others to join the cause. They may have the power, but the people have the inflatable genitals and the will to use them.”

— Renea Gamble

What’s next

The case against Renea Gamble is ongoing, with local prosecutors still pursuing criminal charges despite the national backlash. Gamble's attorney, David Gespass, has vowed to continue fighting the charges, which he says clearly violate Gamble's constitutional rights.

The takeaway

This case underscores the tension between law enforcement's desire to maintain 'order' and citizens' right to free speech, even when that speech is unconventional or controversial. It serves as a cautionary tale for officials who seek to criminalize dissent and expressive protest, as their actions often only embolden the very people they are trying to silence.