Judges Condemn Birmingham Crimes as 'The Worst'

Disturbing cases are nothing new to Birmingham's courts, but some stand out as exceptionally cruel or persistent.

Apr. 11, 2026 at 4:53am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

When judges in Birmingham's crown court, accustomed to dealing with serious criminal cases, describe something as 'the worst', it's a high bar. Yet even within that context, there are moments when the scale, cruelty or persistence of offending prompts the strongest possible judicial language, reserved for crimes that stand out as exceptional. These include a pastor's decades-long sexual abuse of children, a 'rancid' illegal puppy farm, a violent city-center brawl, and the extreme abuse and exploitation of a former University of Birmingham researcher.

Why it matters

Birmingham's courts regularly handle disturbing criminal cases, so when judges use the strongest possible language to condemn certain crimes as 'the worst', it underscores how egregious and alarming the behavior was. These cases highlight the need for vigilance against sustained abuse, extreme violence, and shocking neglect within the community.

The details

In one case, Birmingham pastor Michael Oluronbi was sentenced for abusing victims over two decades, exploiting his position of trust to manipulate and control children and adults. The judge described it as 'one of the worst cases of sexual abuse of multiple children to come before the courts.' Authorities also uncovered a 'rancid' illegal puppy farm where dozens of dogs were found living in filthy, ammonia-filled conditions, which officials called the 'worst case of animal neglect' they had encountered. A major city-center brawl was condemned by a judge as 'one of the worst' incidents of violent disorder seen in the city, involving a large group attack with victims punched, kicked and stamped on. And former University of Birmingham researcher Matthew Falder, branded one of Britain's most prolific paedophiles, was described as engaging in extreme abuse and exploitation.

  • The pastor abuse case occurred over two decades.
  • The puppy farm was uncovered in the Midlands region recently.
  • The violent disorder incident happened in Birmingham's city center.
  • The exploitation case involving Matthew Falder took place over an extended period.

The players

Michael Oluronbi

A Birmingham pastor who abused victims over two decades, exploiting his position of trust.

Matthew Falder

A former University of Birmingham researcher branded one of Britain's most prolific paedophiles for his extreme abuse and exploitation.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“One of the worst cases of sexual abuse of multiple children to come before the courts.”

— Judge

“The worst case of animal neglect we have encountered.”

— Authorities

“One of the worst incidents of violent disorder seen in the city.”

— Judge Dean Kershaw

The takeaway

These disturbing cases in Birmingham highlight the need for continued vigilance against sustained abuse, extreme violence, and shocking neglect within the community. When judges use the strongest possible language to condemn certain crimes as 'the worst', it underscores the severity of the behavior and the importance of addressing these issues head-on.