A leisurely read

The Best Turkey Fryer for 2023

Enjoy a delicious fried turkey this Thanksgiving with any of these amazing turkey fryers.

The Best Turkey Fryer for 2022

Frying turkeys has become increasingly popular. It is a fast way to get delicious, moist turkey on Thanksgiving. However, too many people try to fry their turkeys in dangerous ways. You don’t have to resort to a dunk and run this year. We took it upon ourselves to find the best turkey fryers available.

We reviewed over twenty turkey fryers to find the best ones to enjoy a delicious fried turkey this season.

How We Picked

  • Size + Shape

    The size and shape of the fryer impact how much turkey you can fry in one go. The shape and size of the turkey fryer you choose determine how heavy a bird you usually fry.

  • Type of Material

    Different materials conduct heat differently. Also, different materials have different durability and longevity. The best turkey fryers should be constructed of sturdy material that can withstand intense heat, thorough cleaning, and heavy objects.

  • Powerful Heat

    The power of the heat in the turkey fryer impacts how long the turkey takes to cook. It also determines how big the bird you are frying can be.

  • Price

    With all other considerations in mind, the turkey fryer should have a matching price. High-quality features can cost more, but more is needed to break the bank. Cheaper components should equal an affordable fryer.

Our Top Picks

Best Pick

Bayou Classic 1118 32-qt Turkey Fryer

Bayou Classic 1118 32-qt Turkey Fryer

With powerful heating.

A versatile, stainless-steel outdoor turkey fryer

Buy Now

The Bayou Classic 1118 32-qt Turkey Fryer is a sturdy, well-built outdoor turkey fryer. Although it does not come with a burner, it comes with every other tool you need to fry a turkey. The pot and all the other tools are made of high-quality stainless steel, making them durable. It holds and distributes heat well, providing robust and consistent heating the entire time you fry your turkey.

Runner Up

CreoleFeast TFS3010 Propane Turkey Fryer

CreoleFeast TFS3010 Propane Turkey Fryer

Affordable and efficient.

A well-equipped propane deep fryer that can handle medium-sized birds.

Buy Now for $129.99

This is an affordable propane turkey fryer. It can easily handle small and mid-sized turkeys and comes with various tools, including a perforated steamer basket, a temperature thermometer, a marinade injector, and a burner stand. It is ideal for outdoor parties, although it is hard to clean indoors.

Most Cost-Effective

Masterbuilt MB20012420 Electric Fryer

Masterbuilt MB20012420 Electric Fryer

So easy to use.

A heavy-duty but affordable aluminum electric fryer.

Buy Now for $129.99

The perfect indoor turkey fryer, the Masterbuilt MB20012420 Electric Fryer, is made of aluminum and can fry up to a 20-pound turkey. It is easy to use and boasts a draining valve and a detachable lid. It is pretty big and takes up a significant amount of counter space, but it is well worth it at a price.

Everything We Recommend

Best Pick

Bayou Classic 1118 32-qt Turkey Fryer

Bayou Classic 1118 32-qt Turkey Fryer

With powerful heating.

Buy Now

Runner Up

CreoleFeast TFS3010 Propane Turkey Fryer

CreoleFeast TFS3010 Propane Turkey Fryer

Affordable and efficient.

$129.99

Buy Now

Most Cost-Effective

Masterbuilt MB20012420 Electric Fryer

Masterbuilt MB20012420 Electric Fryer

So easy to use.

$129.99

Buy Now

Who This Is For

If you have ever tried to fry a turkey on a cooking pot or metal bucket in your backyard, this list is for you. People who have wanted to serve fried turkey for holidays will also love this list. We compiled a list of the best turkey fryers to ensure you have a perfectly fried turkey without a trip to the hospital.

Propane Burner vs Electric
Propane turkey fryers are cheaper to run and have higher degrees of temperature control. They are also dependable as they work during power outages and storms. However, propane does not produce as much heat. This means that the heating power of propane turkey fryers is lower than that of electric ones.

Additionally, propane can be quite dangerous in the house, especially with young children and pets.

Electric turkey fryers are safer to use as they have a more controlled power source. They have higher heating powers and can heat faster than propane fryers. The biggest disadvantage of an electric turkey fryer is that you can’t use it during a power outage.

Are Turkey Fryers Safe To Use?
Turley fryers are very safe to use if you carefully follow the usage instructions. This is one of those kitchen appliances you cannot afford to misuse. You must read the instructions for every turkey fryer you buy. After reading and re-reading them, ensure you follow the instructions to the letter. This will help guarantee your safety.

It is important to note that there is a heightened risk associated with frying turkeys as opposed to baking or grilling them. While turkey fryers can eliminate most risks, they are not 100% safe. Usually, unless used haphazardly, turkey fryers remain safe until they get too old.

But the risks associated with hot oil, gas, and electrical gadgets also apply to turkey fryers.

Why You Should Trust Us

We have all struggled to fry a turkey on one Thanksgiving or another. And because we know the hustle of frying a turkey without a turkey fryer, we took it upon ourselves to find some good ones. There is no need to spend money on a turkey fryer if it dies after a few uses. Our team was committed to reviewing almost thirty turkey fryers until we found some worth the money. 

How We Picked

Here is how we reviewed all our turkey fryer options to find the best four:

Shape
Shape influences not only aesthetics but also how the turkey fits into the fryer. We were not hell-bent on one shape, but we did try to find turkey fryers with varying shapes.

Size
Size isn’t everything, but it does matter. We were looking for turkey fryers of various sizes because we understand not everyone is frying a large bird. Bigger fryers often mean you can fry both big and small turkeys. However, they are usually more expensive.

We wanted to also recommend smaller fryers that fit smaller homes.

Powerful heat
No one wants to stand and watch a turkey fryer for hours on end. A turkey fryer with powerful heat will allow you to fry even big turkeys faster. Also, it is less likely to overheat if you don’t have to run it for hours on end.

Overall sturdy build
Turkeys are quite heavy. Having a sturdy turkey fryer ensures it doesn’t topple over when the bird is placed inside. The sturdier the build, the heavier the turkey, and the longer it could comfortably be fried without keeling over. The heavier the turkey, the higher it was on our list.

Type of material
Durable and hot-oil-friendly materials topped our list. No one wants to spend money on a turkey fryer for it to be useless in five years. We were looking for turkey fryers made of durable and long-lasting material that could withstand several hundred deep frying sessions.

Easy to assemble
Having a turkey fryer with too many working parts can be disheartening. However, some quality turkey fryers do require a few steps to assemble. We were looking for turkey fryers that were easy to assemble, either due to fewer assembly parts or easy-to-follow directions.

Easy to use and clean
We looked for fryers that were easy to clean and use and lacked complex instructions. We know that a complex turkey fryer will sit at the back of your kitchen drawers for years. We wanted to recommend fryers that encouraged their use and didn’t make cleaning a headache.

Price
While the best things usually cost a lot of money. We did not want you to break the bank to afford a turkey fryer. We wanted turkey fryers that fit various budgets and were worth the purchase. Our focus was on how each fryer met our previous evaluation criteria and whether or not it was worth the price.

Our Picks For You

Best Pick - Bayou Classic 1118 32-qt Turkey Fryer

Best Pick

Bayou Classic 1118 32-qt Turkey Fryer

Bayou Classic 1118 32-qt Turkey Fryer

With powerful heating.

A versatile, stainless-steel outdoor turkey fryer

Buy Now

Who It's For

If you already have a propane or gas source and are simply looking for a fryer, the Bayou Classic 1118 32-qt Turkey Fryer is perfect. It is a large, stainless steel fryer that is sturdy and durable.

Why It's Great

The pot is multipurpose and can make large batches of soup and seafood. Assembling the Bayou Classic 1118 32-qt Turkey Fryer Set is easy, and the instructions are easy to follow. It does come with a thermometer and a stainless steel perforated basket that you can use to steam vegetables. The material makes it perfect for holding and distributing heat evenly for a perfectly cooked turkey.

Potential Flaws

It is the priciest turkey fryer on this list and does not come with a burner. However, for the quality and size, it is worth it.


Other Features

Frying a turkey in the Bayou Classic 1118 32-qt Turkey Fryer is very easy. Cleaning is easier with the stainless steel material, and the heavy-duty handles make it easy to carry.

Product Specifications

Material: Stainless Steel
Color: Silver
Dimensions: 14" depth by 14” width by 18" height
Item Weight: 12.22 Pounds
Oil Capacity: 32 Quarts
Maximum Turkey Weight: 18 pounds

Runner Up - CreoleFeast TFS3010 Propane Turkey Fryer

Runner Up

CreoleFeast TFS3010 Propane Turkey Fryer

CreoleFeast TFS3010 Propane Turkey Fryer

Affordable and efficient.

A well-equipped propane deep fryer that can handle medium-sized birds.

Buy Now for $129.99

Who It's For

The CreoleFeast TFS3010 Propane Turkey Fryer is the perfect all-in-one turkey fryer for the holidays. Ideal for anyone wanting to fry a medium-sized bird outside with all the tools and additions.

Why It's Great

It comes with a frying pot and lid, a perforated steamer basket, a temperature thermometer, a marinade injector, a burner stand, an LP hose, a regulator, and a lifting hook. You can get a perfectly fried 20-pound turkey in just about 45 minutes. This aluminum propane fryer is quite safe with the extra features and detailed manual.

Potential Flaws

The Creole fryer does not have the best heat retention. Additionally, the pot is prone to dents. The added tools are a major bonus for the price.


Other Features

The CreoleFeast TFS3010 Propane Turkey Fryer is quite effective for cooking small to mid-sized birds. The components are more challenging to clean than the pot is quite large and deep. However, if you have an outdoor cleaning area or a deep sink, you should have no problems.

Product Specifications

Material: Aluminum
Color: Silver/Black
Oil Capacity: 9.5 liters
Power Source: Propane Burner
Item Weight: 16 pounds
Dimensions: 13.75” depth by 12” width by 27.50” height
Turkey Weight Limit: 20 pounds

Most Cost-Effective - Masterbuilt MB20012420 Electric Fryer

Most Cost-Effective

Masterbuilt MB20012420 Electric Fryer

Masterbuilt MB20012420 Electric Fryer

So easy to use.

A heavy-duty but affordable aluminum electric fryer.

Buy Now for $129.99

Who It's For

The Masterbuilt MB20012420 Electric Fryer is ideal for those looking for an electric turkey fryer that can handle a medium-sized bird. This fryer can also steam and boil and is very easy to clean.

Why It's Great

It is made of aluminum, which makes it durable and rust-proof. It requires 2 gallons of oil to fry. The Masterbuilt MB20012420 Electric Fryer is affordable, especially for an electric turkey fryer.

Potential Flaws

The temperature of this fryer can be quite inconsistent. This can make for some badly cooked birds. With the price point, this electric fryer is a steal.

Other Features

The manual for the Masterbuilt MB20012420 Electric Fryer is easy to follow. It is not a nuanced deep fryer and can be operated with minimal skill after skimming the manual. The drain valve makes it easy to drain the oil out, and the removable lid, pot, and cooking basket are easy to clean.

Product Specifications

Material: Aluminum, Metal
Color: Silver
Product Dimensions: 18.43" Depth by 16.46” Width by 14.8" Height
Item Weight: 20.48 Pounds
Wattage: 1650 watts
Oil Capacity: 10 Liters
Turkey Weight Limit: 20 pounds

Almost Made The Cut - Cuisinart CDF-500 Extra Large Electric Deep Fryer

Almost Made The Cut

Cuisinart CDF-500 Extra Large Electric Deep Fryer

Cuisinart CDF-500 Extra Large Electric Deep Fryer

Compact and cute.

Stainless steel electric turkey fryer ideal for smaller homes

Buy Now for $319.99

Who It's For

If you want an easy-to-use electric fryer, the Cuisinart CDF-500 Extra Large is for you. We found it perfect for those who want to cook 14-pound or lighter birds. It cooks thoroughly, leaving the skin crispy but the inside tender, moist, and oil-free.

Why It's Great

The setup for this turkey fryer is very easy, and cleaning is even easier. The only things that need washing are the fryer pot and the stainless steel mesh pocket. The rest of the fryer can be wiped down with a soapy cloth to remove oil residue.

The Cuisinart CDF-500 is extra-large and can fry up a 14-pound turkey in less than an hour. It can fry potatoes, donuts, seafood, and various other dishes. It can also steam. The Cuisinart CDF-500 Extra Large is also energy efficient, using less oil and electricity than most other fryers.

Potential Flaws

This fryer can only handle up to 14 pounds, which is quite low. It isn’t ideal for large families or large birds. The power cable often shortcircuits, and the power can go off after long periods of use.

Product Specifications

Size:5 LiterS
Material: Stainless Steel
Product Dimensions: 20.18” Depth by 15.96" Width by 16.44" height
Item Weight: 26.46 Pounds
Oil Capacity: 14 Pounds
Turkey Weight Limit: 14 pounds

Care and Maintenance

Risk associated with using a turkey fryer
Turkeys are large birds, and frying them whole comes with risk. The hot oil can boil over and cause a fire or burn you.

The fryer can also tip over if it is not placed correctly and cause severe burns.

Eye injuries from hot oil splashing are also a risk associated with using a turkey fryer. You can scald yourself on the hot surface of the turkey fryer and breathe in fumes from cleaning chemicals when you fry.

Proper instructions on how to use it safely

  1. To use a turkey fryer properly, follow these instructions:
  2. Thoroughly clean your turkey fryer to get off grease and oils
  3. Rinse any dishwashing soap and cleaning liquids you use thoroughly to avoid inhaling fumes
  4. Completely dry the turkey fryer before using it
  5. If using a propane fryer, remove it from the house, away from walls and alcoves
  6. Both propane and electric turkey fryers should be placed on a sturdy, level surface; ensure it is away from curious hands and cannot tip over or be caught on moving parts like clothes.
  7. Refrain from filling your turkey fryer. Follow the instructions to the letter
  8. Ensure your turkey is fully defrosted and thoroughly pat it dry
  9. Please wait for the ideal temperature and do not place the turkey when it is too hot
  10. Gently lower the turkey into the fryer. Please do not drop it or toss it into the hot oil.
  11. Watch the turkey and keep track of the timer. Immediately remove it once it is done cooking
  12. Turn off the fryer or the flame and let the oil cool down.

Where and how to store it when not used:

A turkey fryer can stay in any cool, dark, and dry place. Find a drawer or cabinet with space, ideally in your kitchen or garage, and store it there. Make sure it is clean and dry before storing it.

You can wrap it in bubble wrap before placing it in a box if you keep it away for more than a few months. Otherwise, you can put it in a cool, dry corner. Ensure it stays away from heat and moisture.

How to clean

  1. Ensure your turkey fryer is off and the oil has cooled down.
  2. Remove the fryer pot, drain out all the oil, and wipe down the inside with a paper towel to remove excess oil
  3. Drizzle some dish soap into the pot and add hot water. Allow the pot to soak for about an hour
  4. In the meantime, get a kitchen cloth, warm water, and dish soap. Put enough dish soap in the warm water bowl and lather
  5. Use the kitchen cloth to wipe down the rest of the turkey fryer. You can use a degreaser if allowed by the manufacturer
  6. Pour out the water once it gets dirty and gets new water. Repeat until the entire fryer is free of oil and greasy residue.
  7. Once clean, dip another cloth into warm water and wipe down the fryer to remove soap residue
  8. Pour out the soaking water from the fryer pot and use a scouring pad, dish soap, and warm water to scrub it thoroughly.
  9. Rinse and check for oil residue. Repeat if necessary.
  10. Once the pot is clean and grease-free, pat dries every component with a clean, dry towel.
  11. Store it safely.