9 min. read

The Best Toaster for 2023

If you like your bread crispy, a toaster is a must-have.

Best Toaster

Bread tastes good, but toasting it improves its taste and appearance. For you to have your bread toasted to your desired taste, there’s a need for you to make use of the best toaster that will serve you better.

Toasters are made to toast bread or bagels, grill, brown bread, or muffins. They are also used to defrost foods. The toaster is an important kitchen appliance as it helps to keep bread hot and tasty before consumption. Read our review to have the best experience with your toaster and equally tasty toast.

How We Picked

  • Capacity/Width of Slots

    Bread comes in different sizes, which means different-sized slices. The width of the slots and the capacity of the toaster should also differ. Therefore, it is crucial to buy a toaster that is compatible with the size of the bread slice you prefer.

  • Shade Settings/Control

    Kitchen appliances like toasters are fun to use when their controls are easy to operate. It is also very important to consider the range of the shade. You may like brownish bread toast, while a member of your family may love it dark.

  • High Lift - to check to brown

    Lifting your toast high out of the toaster is very important, so as not to hurt your fingers on the hot surface of the toaster. It is also considered acceptable to lift your toast to see how it is browning without stopping the toasting.

  • Standard Settings

    The settings for the regulation of how the bread is being toasted should be standardized and easy to use, such as; preheat and defrost.

Our Top Picks

Best Pick

Breville Die-Cast 4-Slice Toaster

Breville Die-Cast 4-Slice Toaster

This toaster may appear to be overpriced in comparison to other toasters, but it is well worth the money.

The Breville Die-Cast is simple to use and has a smart auto lift and countdown indicator.

Buy Now

This brand with 4-slice slots is so great because it accommodates most bread sizes and has advanced toasting technology. The bread can be automatically inserted into the toaster, lifted during the toasting cycle to check on progress, and lifted at the end to provide toasting perfection using the touch button on this particular toaster.

Runner Up

BUYDEEM DT640 4-Slice Toaster

BUYDEEM DT640 4-Slice Toaster

With extra-wide 1.4-inch slots and seven toast shade settings, it's ideal for a variety of slice sizes.

If the warm greenish and mellow yellow finishes are a little too much for you, this toaster is also available in a stainless finish.

Buy Now for $78.99

The BUYDEEM DT640 is designed with style to help manage space on your countertop neatly. This toaster has four independent control panels with four separate slots for making different toasts at the same time. It also has a bagel feature that initially heats the bagel on both sides before toasting only the side closest to the blade.

Most Cost-Effective

Cuisinart CPT-180WP1 4-Slice Metal Toaster

Cuisinart CPT-180WP1 4-Slice Metal Toaster

This toaster has six browning settings and comes in a range of colors.

This Cuisinart toaster is perfect for anyone who is concerned with kitchen aesthetics because of its polished chrome housing and black accents.

Buy Now for $69.95

Two different sets of toast can be simultaneously toasted thanks to this brand's twin independent toasting controls. In addition to toast, it contains a range of other toasting features, like bagel buttons with LED indicators, dual reheat, and browning knobs, all of which make toasting quick and simple.

Everything We Recommend

Best Pick

Breville Die-Cast 4-Slice Toaster

Breville Die-Cast 4-Slice Toaster

This toaster may appear to be overpriced in comparison to other toasters, but it is well worth the money.

Buy Now

Runner Up

BUYDEEM DT640 4-Slice Toaster

BUYDEEM DT640 4-Slice Toaster

With extra-wide 1.4-inch slots and seven toast shade settings, it's ideal for a variety of slice sizes.

$78.99

Buy Now

Most Cost-Effective

Cuisinart CPT-180WP1 4-Slice Metal Toaster

Cuisinart CPT-180WP1 4-Slice Metal Toaster

This toaster has six browning settings and comes in a range of colors.

$69.95

Buy Now

Who This Is For

This article is for individuals or families who take their breakfast seriously and also helps them choose the best toaster.

Energy Efficiency of toasters and why it’s important

It is wise to consider the energy efficiency of a toaster before buying, because of power consumption in the home. To manage energy efficiently, you have to make use of the number of slots needed. This sorely depends on the number of people to serve.

Why You Should Trust Us

Many people acquire toasters indiscriminately/ignorantly, hence the regrets. Toasters are supposed to be easy-to-use kitchen appliances, so we have carefully selected the best brands for you.

How We Picked

Capacity (2 or 4 slots)

We are concerned about the capacity of toasters as they have a huge impact when they are put to use. If you want to serve your family (at least 4 people) breakfast and don’t want to keep anyone waiting, we have selected brands with 4-slice slots for you to choose from. But, if you intend to serve yourself breakfast only or a maximum of 4 persons, then we recommend you go to brands with 2-slice slots.

Width of slots

It is important to also consider the size of the slots because every slice differs in size. You may be a fan of large or small-sized slices. To that effect, you’ll need a toaster compatible with your preferred choice of slice size.

Shade/Browning setting and control

We also paid attention to the type of material from which the slots are made, which is also a determinant of browning. Everyone has a preferred taste, especially when it comes to food. Toasts shouldn’t be exempted. We sort for toasters with at least four shade or browning settings because of the variation in individual tastes for food (in this case, toast).

High lift

It would be a very awful situation for you to hurt your fingers while trying to take out your toast. For this reason, we conducted extensive research on the best and most appropriate level at which a toast should be lifted to avoid your fingers being burned by the hot surface of the toaster.

Crumb tray

The crumb tray is also something we couldn’t neglect while making our selections. It helps to catch the excess crumbs that fall off your bread when it’s toasted. Therefore, your crumb tray should be stable and provide enough space to harbor the crumbs.

Material

We also paid attention to the materials used in the construction of toasters. Toasters emit a lot of heat while in use. So, a toaster made of good heat-withstanding material is preferable.

Style/Design

Aesthetics are also an important feature of a machine, not just a toaster. To match the modern kitchen styles, we looked for toasters with modern designs. Also, colors that will fit with other kitchen utensils, such as; frying pans, spoons, etc.

Standard settings

Preheat

The preheat option is necessary if you do not want to spend any longer time waiting for your bread to toast. This is accomplished by turning on your toaster and then inserting your slices after a few minutes. Your toasts seem to get ready quickly because the slots have been preheated.

Defrost

There is every reason for your toaster to have a defrost option. Sometimes, you preserve your slices in the refrigerator and may want to toast them without waiting any longer for them to defrost normally.

Our Picks For You

Best Pick - Breville Die-Cast 4-Slice Toaster

Best Pick

Breville Die-Cast 4-Slice Toaster

Breville Die-Cast 4-Slice Toaster

This toaster may appear to be overpriced in comparison to other toasters, but it is well worth the money.

The Breville Die-Cast is simple to use and has a smart auto lift and countdown indicator.

Buy Now

Who It's For

If you love luxury items or you want to toast your bread without paying too much attention to your toaster while in use, then this brand is what you should go for. This may also be referred to as "classy toasting."

Why It’s Great

This toaster is so spectacular because of its automation. It contains a lift button that automatically lifts the toast high for you to quickly check before it drops. Furthermore, there are LED features in front to see your toasting progress and help eject your toasts at the right time.

Potential Flaws

The Breville Die-Cast 4-Slice Toaster is a great choice, considering all its features, but the major con of this toaster is that it's way too expensive to acquire and repair.

Other Features

This toaster features two sets of slice slots that are wide enough to accommodate any size slice. It also has two crumb trays provided for the two sets of slice slots

Runner Up - BUYDEEM DT640 4-Slice Toaster

Runner Up

BUYDEEM DT640 4-Slice Toaster

BUYDEEM DT640 4-Slice Toaster

With extra-wide 1.4-inch slots and seven toast shade settings, it's ideal for a variety of slice sizes.

If the warm greenish and mellow yellow finishes are a little too much for you, this toaster is also available in a stainless finish.

Buy Now for $78.99

Who It's For

If you are a lover of large-sized slices and you want to get them all toasted, this brand does it.

Why It's For

The BUYDEEM DT640 4-Slice Toaster has extra-wide slots of 1.4", which is capable of containing different sizes of slices. Also, it has a self-centering guide and a high-lift lever, which is perfect for short slices.

Potential Flaws

This toaster is so great, but the high-lift option is not automated for quick checking of your toasts.

Other Features

Overall, it is well designed so that it saves space on your countertop. It is also extremely light.

Most Cost-Effective - Cuisinart CPT-180WP1 4-Slice Metal Toaster

Most Cost-Effective

Cuisinart CPT-180WP1 4-Slice Metal Toaster

Cuisinart CPT-180WP1 4-Slice Metal Toaster

This toaster has six browning settings and comes in a range of colors.

This Cuisinart toaster is perfect for anyone who is concerned with kitchen aesthetics because of its polished chrome housing and black accents.

Buy Now for $69.95

Who It’s For

This toaster is recommended for families or those who do not want to spend too much on toasting or expect much from toasters but still have a great breakfast.

Why It’s Great

The Cuisinart CPT 180WP1 4-SLICE toaster has 1.5" extra-wide slots that can hold a wide variety of toasted items. Another great thing about this brand is that the high-lift lever pops up whenever the toast is finished. Also, the two crumb trays can be ejected independently to remove dirt or extra crumbs that may fall on them while toasting.

Potential Flaws

This toaster is cost-efficient, but it is not recommended for large sizes of slices due to the lack of added lift, unlike some brands.

Other Features

However, it is not as expensive as other brands with more advanced technology and automation. Therefore, it is affordable for average families or individuals.

Almost Made The Cut - Zwilling Enfinigy Cool Touch Toaster

Almost Made The Cut

Zwilling Enfinigy Cool Touch Toaster

Zwilling Enfinigy Cool Touch Toaster

Thanks to the balanced heat distribution from the four different heating sources, every piece of bread is evenly toasted on both sides.

If you value simplicity in appliances, this choice has everything you need, including easy-to-use toasting controls and slots that are both wide and long enough to toast two slices of regular bread or one slice of artisanal bread.

Buy Now for $69.95

Who It's For

We recommend this toaster for people who want to make toast for themselves only or for very small consumption.

Why It's Great

This toaster can keep a cool temperature on the outside even when it's toasting. There's also a built-in slot lift and an extra lift to raise the toast safely. It is also capable of containing two standard bread slices or one long artisanal-style bread slice in each slot.

Potential Flaws

Though this toaster is great, it cannot be used by a large number of families as it has only two slots.

Price

This brand seems too expensive because it doesn't have four slots and lacks some functions other toasters have.

Care and Maintenance

Always switch off the toaster when not in use, as it may heat unnecessarily and result in damage or consume energy. Do not allow liquids near the surface of the toaster or the slots, as it may result in rust or electrical shocks. The cord and wire should not be twisted or wet, whether in use or not. They should also be unplugged when not in use.

The crumb tray should be removed at least once a week and brushed clean of dirt and excess crumbs. When crumbs are not removed from the crumb tray, a fire can start if the toaster encounters electrical issues while toasting and doesn’t turn off.
However, always clean the crumbs regularly and keep a fire extinguisher on standby for your safety.

To clean your toaster, you have to unplug your toaster from the switch. Next, you remove the crumb tray, sweep it off, and clean the burnt crumbs on it. You may also have to turn the toaster upside down to shake off some crumbs that may have been stuck in there or use a brush to clean the inner part of the toaster (around the slots). Use a damp cloth to clean the body of the toaster with some mild soap. Afterward, reinsert the crumb tray.
However, we recommend you clean your toaster once a week, as you use it every day, to keep it in good working condition and ensure its durability.