12 min. read

The Best Toaster Oven for 2023

Prepare or reheat your favorite meals with absolute ease.

Toaster Oven

For a living organism to function, they need food in whichever form for the purpose of obtaining nutrients. When you think of what identifies as culture, food comes top of the list regardless of the side of the world you choose to examine this from. The average human spends 67 minutes per day eating.

Our generation has spent years coming up with appliances or simply improving on those that existed before our time. The toaster oven, which is a hybrid toaster and oven, is such an appliance. It has evolved with time from a stone dig-out that was fuelled by firewood to bake bread to a unit found in very many modern kitchens.

This device is built for efficiency and effectiveness. Whether you are looking to bake, thaw, defrost, toast, or grill, the toaster oven serves almost all of your kitchen needs! Come along as we discover some great options.

 

How We Picked

  • Slot Size

    The size of your toaster oven will always determine what you want to cook and in what quantities. A larger slot size means that more food can go in at a time but this also means that the equipment is bulkier, and takes up more countertop space.

  • Consistency of Cooking

    We looked at which toaster ovens offer the best results when cooking by maintaining heat while using less time. We also looked at the cooking methods employed in the equipment and how they would best serve you.

  • Variety of Settings

    Toaster ovens come with a variety of preset menus that allow the user to pick the perfect setting for whatever food they want without worrying about the precision of the time and heat needed.

  • Cost-Effectiveness

    The toaster cooker costs less to purchase as compared to regular ovens. Another save is the electric bills which will be lower as compared to the regular sized one.

Our Top Picks

Best Pick

Cuisinart TOA-95

Cuisinart TOA-95

The Cuisinart is worth every penny, given its multiple functions and spacious interior.

This is not only a toaster oven but also an air fryer offering up to 18 different functions.

Buy Now for $329.95

This is not only a toaster oven but also an air fryer offering up to 18 different functions. The Cuisinart is worth every penny, given its multiple functions and spacious interior.

Runner Up

Calphalon Air Fryer Oven

Calphalon Air Fryer Oven

A quality piece of equipment perfect for smaller countertops.

As a mid-priced toaster oven, it performs very well while still saving a few coins in home energy consumption.

Buy Now for $219.99

A quality piece of equipment perfect for smaller countertops. As a mid-priced toaster oven, it performs very well while still saving a few coins in home energy consumption.

Most Cost-Effective

Black+Decker T01313SBD

BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Convection Oven

When you need the job done but on a budget, this is the toaster oven for you.

Cleaning this versatile toaster is a breeze and the stainless steel finish with a touch of black looks great in any kitchen.

Buy Now for $58.90

When you need the job done but on a budget, this is the toaster oven for you. Cleaning this versatile toaster is a breeze and the stainless steel finish with a touch of black looks great in any kitchen.

Everything We Recommend

Best Pick

Cuisinart TOA-95

Cuisinart TOA-95

The Cuisinart is worth every penny, given its multiple functions and spacious interior.

$329.95

Buy Now

Runner Up

Calphalon Air Fryer Oven

Calphalon Air Fryer Oven

A quality piece of equipment perfect for smaller countertops.

$219.99

Buy Now

Most Cost-Effective

Black+Decker T01313SBD

BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Convection Oven

When you need the job done but on a budget, this is the toaster oven for you.

$58.90

Buy Now

Who This Is For

Do you like to move about in your kitchen freely? Are you looking for combined equipment to minimize your countertop space usage? Do you fix or warm up your own meals? Then this article is for you.

Toasters Vs Toaster Ovens

Toaster ovens are very different from toasters given that they have more functions such as baking, defrosting, and broiling, just to name a few. It then follows that toaster ovens are larger in design and take up more countertop space as opposed to toasters. However, they both use relatively similar amounts of electricity despite their differences in size.

The toaster oven takes longer to heat up as compared to the toaster but this heat can be regulated unlike that of most toasters which will turn off automatically at some point.

A toaster is prone to overheating and thus can be hazardous. At the same time, toaster ovens have many functions and if not used well, they may cause accidents

Are Convection Ovens and Toaster Ovens The Same?

Convection ovens and toaster ovens use the same cooking method which is convection. This is the method in which heat is equally distributed in the oven by means of a fan.

Having established this, the main difference between these two is their sizes where a convection oven is larger than a toaster oven. This further means that the toaster oven will heat up faster, and the convection oven will retain heat longer. The toaster also comes with a preset menu which eases your cooking experience. If you are looking to cut down on your energy consumption, then the toaster oven is the way to go. It will also reduce your electricity bill as compared to when using the convection oven.

Is A Toaster Oven Worth it?

A toaster oven takes up less space in your kitchen, uses less electricity, and heats up faster than the oven. It has more functions than the toaster, and it’s a worthy investment.

Why You Should Trust Us

We embarked on a mission to look into toaster ovens. We then did a lot of research and further looked into user reviews on all the products that we recommend. We took the time so that you don’t have to.

How We Picked

For us to reach our recommendation, we looked at various factors such as the size of the slot. The bigger the slot the larger it’s capacity to cook more food at a go. How many 12-inch pizzas can you defrost or bake at once? Can it fit a whole chicken? This then determined how we ranked them.

Most toaster ovens are portable but others are fixed. We examined the size of the machine against what it had to offer in performance. Did it have a large interior that then translated to the exterior or was it bulky? Thanks to the convection cooking style, food doesn’t need to be turned when in the toaster oven. The equipment needs to offer even and concise cooking.

We looked at the precision of the timer and if it was well displayed. Other factors such as ease of use of the controls, how many different meals can be cooked in the machine, the number of preset options on the menu, and even the speed at which the toaster oven cooked the said meals.

As much as this equipment is a definite kitchen upgrade, the money spent during purchase is also a determinant. So, we looked through different price ranges and picked the best-performing machines, giving you value for your money.

Our Picks For You

Best Pick - Cuisinart TOA-95

Best Pick

Cuisinart TOA-95

Cuisinart TOA-95

The Cuisinart is worth every penny, given its multiple functions and spacious interior.

This is not only a toaster oven but also an air fryer offering up to 18 different functions.

Buy Now for $329.95

Who It Is For/ Why It Is Great

This is the perfect equipment for anyone who has a big number of people to prepare food for or they generally cook large amounts of food. It has a spacious slot and can perform up to 18 functions.

Potential Flaws

A potential downside to this product is that it has a limited three-year warranty. This is a considerably short time for such high-end equipment.

Other Options/Price/Product Features/Easy Usage/Effectiveness

This is a premium toaster oven with an 1800-watt convection bake setting that has both high and low functions and allows for a wide range of usage from defrosting to baking. This equipment also doubles up as an air fryer hence saving you money and kitchen space. Its design produces minimal noise while still delivering perfect results.

We like this product specifically because it can accommodate a large 13-inch pizza or roast a whole four-pound chicken. Its convection cooking style ensures that whatever you place in the oven comes out perfectly cooked without needing to turn it. For its price range, it is a sure value for your money.

Our Runner Up - Calphalon Air Fryer Oven

Runner Up

Calphalon Air Fryer Oven

Calphalon Air Fryer Oven

A quality piece of equipment perfect for smaller countertops.

As a mid-priced toaster oven, it performs very well while still saving a few coins in home energy consumption.

Buy Now for $219.99

Who It Is For/ Why It Is Great

This is a perfect fit for you if you’re a moderate toaster looking for dependable equipment at a budget. At its retail price, this is a great machine. It is pretty spacious and also occupies moderate countertop space.

Potential Flaws

This equipment is considerably bulky in order to accommodate its interior and so it just might take up alot of your countertop space. It is therefore ideal for large and spacious kitchens.

Other Options/Price/Product Features/Easy Usage/Effectiveness

This toaster oven uses a combination of quartz heat technology and the turbo convection method in order to obtain the best results while cooking. This technology also allows for faster heating and helps to save on energy.

It can comfortably fit a 12-inch pizza thanks to its spacious interior. It also is easy to clean and comes with a removable tray to make this process easier.

Some add-ons that this machine boasts of include an LCD screen that makes the controls easier to manipulate. Its light makes it easier to monitor the cooking process.

We love that this toaster oven can host up to 11 functions and its metallic appearance improves kitchen aesthetic.

Most Cost-Effective - BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Convection Oven

Most Cost-Effective

Black+Decker T01313SBD

BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Convection Oven

When you need the job done but on a budget, this is the toaster oven for you.

Cleaning this versatile toaster is a breeze and the stainless steel finish with a touch of black looks great in any kitchen.

Buy Now for $58.90

Who Is It For/ Why Is It Great

This is the perfect toaster oven for an individual who uses this equipment sparingly and only when preparing food for one or two people. We love its price range as well.

Potential Flaws

Because of its size, this toaster oven can only prepare small food quantities at a time. It is ideal for very small families or for persons living by themselves.

Other Options/Price/Product Features/Easy Usage/Effectiveness

We love the very affordable price that this toaster oven is sold at. This is because this equipment is smaller in size as compared to its counterparts in the market. It can only fit four slices of bread at a go or a 9-inch Pizza.

This small size however does not mean that it is inferior. In fact, it fits perfectly on kitchen countertops and has precise settings for the four functions it performs. It also can be easily cleaned as it has a removable tray.

Almost Made The Cut - Oster Digital French Door Oven

Almost Made The Cut

Oster Digital French Door Oven

Oster Digital French Door Oven

If you value aesthetics over efficiency, this is for you.

We love this toaster oven for its easy-to-open door. This allows for freehand movements during the cooking process. It has an equally elegant look that is bound to spice up any kitchen.

Buy Now for $269.99

Who Is It For/Why Is It Great

If you value aesthetics over efficiency, this is for you. We love this toaster oven for its easy-to-open door. This allows for freehand movements during the cooking process. It has an equally elegant look that is bound to spice up any kitchen.

Potential Flaws

As with all equipment made of glass, this toaster oven needs to be handled with care. The doors are also quite delicate.

Other Options/Price/Product Features/Easy Usage/Effectiveness

The french doors which are the highlight of this toaster oven open up with ease, making the removal or insertion of meals equally easy. It also has a large interior with three racks so this means that different meals can be cooked at a go. It supports 10 functions and saves up on energy by reducing the preheating time as it heats up fast because of its cooking method. It is also easy to clean and comes with digital controls so that you can monitor the temperature and cooking time of the meals. The glass doors help to also look in on your food as it cooks.

This didn't make the cut because it is slightly smaller than other toaster ovens within its market price range.

Care and Maintenance

How to Clean a Toaster Oven

The first step while cleaning a toaster oven is to ensure that the device is unplugged from the power outlet so as to avoid any electricity-related accidents.

Next, remove the movable crumb trays and put them in the sink to soak. Use dish soap and water on the trays and once clean, air them to dry. If the stains are stubborn, soak them for longer and then try to clean them later.

While the trays dry out, take a dump cloth or sponge and use it to take off loose dirt from the oven. Using a homemade cleaner that consists of vinegar and bicarbonate, soak the sponge into the mixture then clean out the interior of the oven.

Some ovens have a non-stick interior. If the dirt is stubborn, use elbow grease. Do not use abrasives as they will scratch the surface of the oven.

How Often Should I Clean and Clear Out My Toaster Oven

To prevent dirt accumulation, use a plate cover where possible to prevent spillage. Clean out your toaster oven with a damp cloth after every use. However, we recommend that you carry out intensive cleaning at least twice a month.

Electronic Care

Ensure that your toaster oven wires are not tangled up. Make sure that the device is plugged into the power supply properly. While doing your general machine cleaning, be careful not to get water into the vents and wires.

We recommend that when not in use, keep your sockets turned off and your power button as well. This will conserve energy and save on your electricity bills. Make sure that you follow your manufacturer’s advice on how to place the equipment to avoid overheating due to incorrect surface placement. We recommend that you follow your manufacturer’s manual to avoid electrical faults.