9 min. read

The Best Pizza Stone for 2023

Unleash your inner pizza chef with these pizza stones and baking steels!

Would you believe us if we said that pizza, aka everyone’s favorite food around the globe, is only one tool away from you? Both pizza stones and pizza steels are solid kitchen tools that enable you to prepare delicious pizza at home with the perfect crispiness.

There are a few distinct differences between these two excellent pizza-making tools that should be taken into consideration when choosing which one to buy. The criteria for this decision depend on what is most essential to you for your pizza-making adventure.

Depending on your budget, frequency of use, storage and durability requirements, and more, one of these tools can help you get the pizza of your dreams through simple steps in the comfort of your own home!

 

How We Picked

  • Thickness

    The thickness of your pizza stones and baking steels plays an important role in determining the pizza’s cooking time and ensuring an even distribution of heat throughout the pie.

  • Material

    The material of the pizza stone and baking steel is a determinant of the time required to fully cook the pizza. The material can also influence the texture of the crust.

  • Reliable and Durable

    Is one pizza session ever really enough? Or starting your pizza process only for your tool to give out midway? The answer is no, and that’s why it’s important to find a reliable and durable tool that will last the test of time.

  • Cost-Effectiveness

    No one wants to break the bank when it comes to a pizza stone or baking steel. The search needs to be for one that gives value for money.

Our Top Picks

Best Pick

Unicook Pizza Stone

Affordable and durable, this choice is the secret behind crispy pizza crusts.

This 15" round pizza stone from Unicook is constructed entirely of cordierite. Superior strength, endurance, heat retention, great thermal shock resistance, and heat resistance up to 1,450°F are features that make it the ideal choice. It contains unnoticeable micropores that absorb moisture from the dough, evenly distributing heat for the best cooking results. ideal for baking bread, cookies, and pizza at home.

Buy Now for $45.89

Affordable and durable, this choice is the secret behind crispy pizza crusts.

Runner Up

Lodge Pre-Seasoned Baking Pan

Made of cast iron, this choice gives you high quality at a decent price.

Pizza baked at home tastes great in the Lodge Cast Iron Baking Pan. This 14” pre-seasoned pan provides excellent and even heat conduction. It has been pre-seasoned for a natural, easy-release finish that gets better with use and is brutally tough for decades of cooking. This baking pan retains heat better than any other and works well in the oven, on the grill, or even over a campfire. Large handles are also included with this particular pan for comfort in handling.

Buy Now for $128.78

Made of cast iron, this choice gives you high quality at a decent price.

Most cost-effective

Cuisinart CPS-445, 3-Piece Pizza Grilling Set

If you’re looking for a good deal and a complete package, this choice is for you.

The Cuisinart 3-Piece Pizza Grilling Set provides all the essential pizza tools at a super affordable price. The set includes a 13" pizza stone, a folding pizza peel, and a pizza cutter. The 13" cordierite pizza stone retains heat extremely well, helping to create an evenly cooked and perfectly crispy crust. The folding handle pizza peel and pizza cutter make pizza cooking both simple and efficient.

Buy Now for $29.66

If you’re looking for a good deal and a complete package, this choice is for you.

Almost made the cut

Made In Cookware Pizza Steel

Hailing from France, this choice is a good pick for basic homemade pizza cooking.

With the Made In Cookware Pizza Steel's exceptional heat retention, you can make restaurant-quality pizza at home. It has 86 perforations that let the heat envelop your dough and provide the crispiest crust possible. The Made In Pizza Steel can be used on the grill outside or in your home oven. To ensure that you receive top-notch, professional-grade cookware, it has been handcrafted by French artisans using only premium metals.

Buy Now for $49.00

Hailing from France, this choice is a good pick for basic homemade pizza cooking.

Everything We Recommend

Best Pick

Unicook Pizza Stone

Affordable and durable, this choice is the secret behind crispy pizza crusts.

$45.89

Buy Now

Runner Up

Lodge Pre-Seasoned Baking Pan

Made of cast iron, this choice gives you high quality at a decent price.

$128.78

Buy Now

Most cost-effective

Cuisinart CPS-445, 3-Piece Pizza Grilling Set

If you’re looking for a good deal and a complete package, this choice is for you.

$29.66

Buy Now

Almost made the cut

Made In Cookware Pizza Steel

Hailing from France, this choice is a good pick for basic homemade pizza cooking.

$49.00

Buy Now

Who This Is For

The tools mentioned here are for anyone looking to make delicious homemade pizzas in the comfort of their own home.
What is baking steel?
A steel plate that is used particularly to cook in a home oven or broiler is known as baking steel or pizza steel. It is built out of a thin coating of steel that is non-stick and highly conductive, absorbing high heat to swiftly cook your pizza and give it a crunchy bottom. Hot steel conducts heat to the pizza dough, resulting in the ideal pizza with a delectable crispy base.
Pizza stone vs. baking steel
They are both pizza tools with different pros and cons. A pizza stone is created from porous materials like ceramic or cordierite, but a pizza steel is, as its name suggests, made of highly conductive steel. Due to its greater heat conductivity than a pizza stone, pizza steel may reach higher temperatures. Therefore, a pizza steel will often cook your pizza more quickly than a pizza stone. For home cooks who occasionally make pizza at home, pizza stones are an excellent alternative to pizza steels because they are typically less expensive.
Different materials used to make pizza stones
Pizza stones are made of ceramic, clay, cordierite, or another composite material. The different materials give the pizza stones different heat conductivity and other characteristics.

Why You Should Trust Us

You can essentially use any kind of baking pan or tray to cook homemade pizza, but it will never match up to the ones you get at restaurants. That’s why we set out on the search for effective pizza stones and steels that bring you restaurant-level quality at home equipped with the best features and value for money.

How We Picked

There is an endless array of options out there when it comes to pizza stones and steels. To find the best of the best, we ensured that our hunt was based on specific important factors. We picked options based on different sizes and thicknesses. The material they are made of and their levels of heat resistance and absorption held a high weight in the selection. Reliability and durability were also key factors in our checklist while putting this list together. Additionally, we had an eye out for the most effective and sleek designs and styles.

To back up our choices, we did a deep dive into past customer experiences and reviews for these products. While experiences may differ from person to person and item to item, we filtered out those with excessively negative reviews to eliminate any shocks after purchase.

Our Picks For You

Best Pick - Unicook Pizza Stone

Best Pick

Unicook Pizza Stone

Affordable and durable, this choice is the secret behind crispy pizza crusts.

This 15" round pizza stone from Unicook is constructed entirely of cordierite. Superior strength, endurance, heat retention, great thermal shock resistance, and heat resistance up to 1,450°F are features that make it the ideal choice. It contains unnoticeable micropores that absorb moisture from the dough, evenly distributing heat for the best cooking results. ideal for baking bread, cookies, and pizza at home.

Buy Now for $45.89

Who it is for

This pick is perfect for someone on the lookout for a durable pizza stone that is not only affordable but also reliable.

Why it is great

You'll have a lot of fun while saving money and calories with the Unicook Pizza Stone! Both a home oven and an outdoor grill are compatible with them. It is practical for baking bread, cookies, biscuits, baguettes, rolls, and more, in addition to homemade and frozen pizzas. It has superior strength, durability, heat retention, and thermal shock capabilities. This stone will serve all of your baking needs at once and is a wonderful addition to your kitchen.

Potential flaws

A challenge that comes with owning a pizza stone is that it needs to be handled with care. It may break if bumped or dropped due to its design and composition. Also, it might lead to a bad odor if seasoned before baking.

Other features

A bonus is a plastic scraper that can also be used to cut dough and remove residue from the pizza stone. This stone in particular is also designed specially to give super-crispy crusts. While good for personal use, this item also scores a high 4.2 out of 5 on the gift scale!

Runner Up - Lodge Pre-Seasoned Baking Pan

Runner Up

Lodge Pre-Seasoned Baking Pan

Made of cast iron, this choice gives you high quality at a decent price.

Pizza baked at home tastes great in the Lodge Cast Iron Baking Pan. This 14” pre-seasoned pan provides excellent and even heat conduction. It has been pre-seasoned for a natural, easy-release finish that gets better with use and is brutally tough for decades of cooking. This baking pan retains heat better than any other and works well in the oven, on the grill, or even over a campfire. Large handles are also included with this particular pan for comfort in handling.

Buy Now for $128.78

Who it is for

This option is ideal for someone looking for high-quality pizza steel who is willing to spend a little more than usual.

Why it is great

Pizza baked at home tastes great in the Lodge Cast Iron Baking Pan. This is a fantastic option because it's seasoned for a natural, easy-release finish that gets better with use. The quality of Lodge cookware has been unsurpassed for more than a century, and it is the only complete line of cast iron cookware created in America. Its adaptability and durability also explain why this pan has a higher price tag than the others.

Potential flaws

While this product and brand promise unparalleled quality, some users have reported low levels of stickiness. Being a pizza pan is an important factor that, if true, could harm your pizzas.

Other features

In addition to being great for making pizza, this pan can also be used to sear, bake, broil, fry, or grill other dishes. This cast iron pan has great overall customer reviews and has enhanced innumerable family gatherings. It is a heavy-duty tool, but the large handles on it make it very easy to manage and carry.

Most cost-effective - Cuisinart CPS-445, 3-Piece Pizza Grilling Set

Most cost-effective

Cuisinart CPS-445, 3-Piece Pizza Grilling Set

If you’re looking for a good deal and a complete package, this choice is for you.

The Cuisinart 3-Piece Pizza Grilling Set provides all the essential pizza tools at a super affordable price. The set includes a 13" pizza stone, a folding pizza peel, and a pizza cutter. The 13" cordierite pizza stone retains heat extremely well, helping to create an evenly cooked and perfectly crispy crust. The folding handle pizza peel and pizza cutter make pizza cooking both simple and efficient.

Buy Now for $29.66

Who it is for

This is the ideal setting for someone looking for a pocket-friendly package deal. It’s also a great choice for beginners.

Why it is great

This is a well-rounded set with all the tools you could need for homemade pizzas. The ceramic pizza stone in this set is heat-resistant up to 800° and evenly disperses heat without hot spots, simulating the conditions of a conventional brick pizza oven and baking a crisp and delectable crust. The aluminum pizza peel with the long handles has an incredibly smooth finish that prevents sticking. In order to prevent hands from coming into contact with the razor-sharp blade, the stainless steel pizza cutter incorporates a round cutting wheel with finger guards. It's a fantastic tool that can also be used to cut dessert bars, brownies, and flatbread as well.

Potential flaws

Several customers have experienced their pizzas sticking to the stone. While this could be attributed to the dough consistency or stone maintenance, there is a chance that it is due to the product itself. That would be a flaw to keep an eye out for.

Other features

Cuisinart is a renowned name in the kitchen appliance space. This adds a level of reliability to the product. The price is also incredibly low and can be justified with just a few uses. It serves as a good starter set to practice with before investing in a long-term, higher-quality pizza-making tool.

Almost made the cut - Made In Cookware Pizza Steel

Almost made the cut

Made In Cookware Pizza Steel

Hailing from France, this choice is a good pick for basic homemade pizza cooking.

With the Made In Cookware Pizza Steel's exceptional heat retention, you can make restaurant-quality pizza at home. It has 86 perforations that let the heat envelop your dough and provide the crispiest crust possible. The Made In Pizza Steel can be used on the grill outside or in your home oven. To ensure that you receive top-notch, professional-grade cookware, it has been handcrafted by French artisans using only premium metals.

Buy Now for $49.00

Who it is for

This is the pick for someone looking for a good and lightweight pan for homemade pizzas.

Why it is great

Made up of special blue carbon steel, this pizza steel is perfect for homemade pizza. Made to maneuver, this is significantly lighter than traditional cast iron. With heat safety up to 1200F, this can be used in many different circumstances. This pizza steel has a slick surface, and its natural seasoning gives it a nonstick surface over time. It also comes with an 86-hole design, which is the secret behind a crisp crust.

Potential flaws

Given that the design includes holes, the types of dishes you can cook in it other than pizzas may be limited. Also, this does not come with a handle, so it could be difficult to move around and carry properly.

Other features

French artisans conceptualized this product, keeping all important factors in mind and providing professional-grade design and quality. The reviews for this are great, and even the negative ones are considered isolated instances.

Care and maintenance

There are certain things to keep in mind for the care and maintenance of pizza stones and steels. Pizza stones should not be soaked in water for a long time, and they are not dishwasher safe. They should be cooled to room temperature before hand-washing with warm water. The same should be done for pizza sandwiches. Do not use harsh detergents or soaps.

It is also important to ensure that the tool material is oven-suitable. Do not eat food if the stone or steel has broken. Do not handle hot stones directly; always do so by using heat-protective gloves.