13 min. read

The Best Lock Box for 2023

Place your valuables in a reliable and secure lock box for future and emergency access.

Lock Box

Showing off property is an easy thing to do, but once the prospective buyer leaves, with a promise to respond to the offer, the property manager is left with the job of storing the keys to the properties. Since not only properties are kept under lock and key, the world has recognized the necessity of having a unitary place to keep the keys and other items secure. Point blank, we came across the simple lock box, a gadget that is more than a solution.

Besides what banks love to provide to businesses for lockbox banking, these ingenious tools are meant to secure keys from burglary, hold them for emergencies, and, if size and capacity permit, store other items protected by a pin or code. We focused on the popular ones used to store keys that are simply called lock boxes, as they surprisingly emerged as the best locks.

 

 

 

How We Picked

  • Size and Capacity

    The larger the size and capacity, the lower the cost per item due to the economies of scale exhibited by the lock boxes. However, the choice of a lock box also depends on the user's needs.

  • Security

    Since lock boxes are designed to prevent break-ins, security features such as combination locks were looked at when identifying the best lockbox.

  • Type of Lock Box

    The type of lockbox affects the nature, design, and style of the gadget that is designated to house keys and other items and prevents unauthorized access. The influence of this factor didn’t affect ranking but was recognized if supported by customers.

  • Cost-Effectiveness

    Lockboxes that could store an item at the lowest cost possible were ranked highly, and these costs were included in the quality ratings of these gadgets to determine the most valuable lock box per unit cost.

Our Top Picks

Best Pick

Master Lock 5425D

Master Lock 5425D

A simple, wall-mounted, and easy-to-lock one-inch deep lockbox.

The Wall-Mounted Lock Box from Master Lock offers four amazing styles for flexible and safe key storage.

Buy Now for $39.90

Indoor areas can be locked up from the outside, and, with the help of this lockbox, you can store the keys on an external wall-mounted setup. The weather protection case prevents adverse weather conditions from weakening the lockbox. It is also easy to lock up keys in this lock box with its good combination dial that offers security. This beautiful lock box is surely our best, and we recommend its purchase.

Runner Up

Barska CB12484 Key Lock

Barska CB12484 Key Lock

A flat panel lockbox with a beautiful matte black finish.

The Barska CB12484 is a relatively inexpensive and large flat-panel door-style lock box that can store up to 48 keys!

Buy Now for $59.99

This lock box is large enough to fit 48 keys and is good for a property or location requiring a similar number of keys stored safely. The Barska CB12484 is a flat panel lock box that comes with the lock box’s mounting hardware for easy wall attachment. Its matte black coating brings some aesthetics to a dull operational area. Since the cost of storage per key is very low, this lock box works wonders in keeping a bunch of keys away cheaply.

Most Cost-Effective

Kidde AccessPoint Key Lock Box

Kidde AccessPoint Key Lock Box

It is durable and trusted by many to hold up to five keys in its safe box.

GE Security produced this lockbox for a market needing a durable and reliable lockbox.

Buy Now for $29.95

First made available in 2004, this lock box has been in production and has not yet been discontinued. It offers the space to store five keys, thus making it a reliable lockbox. The lock box comes with a one-year warranty to cover against the manufacturers' flaws. This vintage lockbox can protect keys, but it has a semi-antique look.

Everything We Recommend

Best Pick

Master Lock 5425D

Master Lock 5425D

A simple, wall-mounted, and easy-to-lock one-inch deep lockbox.

$39.90

Buy Now

Runner Up

Barska CB12484 Key Lock

Barska CB12484 Key Lock

A flat panel lockbox with a beautiful matte black finish.

$59.99

Buy Now

Most Cost-Effective

Kidde AccessPoint Key Lock Box

Kidde AccessPoint Key Lock Box

It is durable and trusted by many to hold up to five keys in its safe box.

$29.95

Buy Now

Who This Is For

This review is for people who require lock boxes in their homes, offices, or institutions to store, access and maintain keys and other items safely.

Different types of Lock Boxes and their usage

There are different types of lockboxes on the market, both online and offline. Some of these types are fireproof, combination, keypad, key-only, wall-mounted, biometric, and bulletproof lockboxes.

Bulletproof lock boxes

These are secure storage items that are built to withstand bullets. In the security world, such cases should pass certain certification standards, such as the UL 752 standards chart.

Fireproof lock boxes

UL fire-resistant ratings are also important in fireproof lock boxes. Fireproof lockboxes are safes that can keep out a fire, thus leading to little or no damage to stored items.

Combination lock boxes

These are lockboxes whose locking mechanisms are combination locks. The locks can be reset and changed to a combination of mostly four digits. This review had three combination lock boxes: Master Lock Wall-Mounted, Kidde AccessPoint Push-Button, and Barska CB12484.

Keypad lock boxes

Some lockboxes have a keypad that accepts a pin for them to open. These keypad lockboxes are a substitute for traditional combination locks.

Key-only lock boxes

Key-only lockboxes are lockboxes that require a key to open. These boxes depend on the safe storage of the key to secure their contents.

Biometric lockboxes

These types of lockboxes use modern technology to detect who is opening them. A person’s fingerprints, iris, facial features, voice, and palm or finger veins are used to identify them by matching the data collected with records.

Push-button lockboxes

These lock boxes are protected by a code that is entered before opening and closing the lock box. To open the lock boxes, a button has to be pushed after the correct code has been entered, hence their name, the push-button lockboxes. This button is also required to be pushed to close the lock boxes.

 

Why You Should Trust Us

Most lock boxes that reviewers have come across have been tagged as inferior and not satisfactory while overlooking good and reliable brands. We did our research to ensure that you will never miss out on a lockbox, especially an effective one!

 

How We Picked

Through trial and error, we first searched for the best lockbox. The subsequent step involved a compulsory feedback analysis of customer reviews on the manufacturer’s lockbox pages. This research was successful as we understood the customer better and encountered some of their experiences in using the lockbox, which included finding a goofy lock box that hinders stealing, owning a large key lock box that could fit a truck’s key, and getting to use a well-built lockbox. With the data at hand and the analysis we did, we believe that you will sincerely trust us to reveal the best lock box outline.

Some of the factors we took into consideration when choosing the best lock boxes included size, capacity, style, design, type, placement, and security mechanisms. We also looked at the superficial features of the usage, durability, and portability of the lockbox. These factors contributed greatly to the price of the product, so we searched for the best deal possible.

Size

The size of the lockbox may determine how easily the lockbox can be used. We discovered that some people prefer large lock boxes as they don’t fidget around with them, while smaller ones may suit people looking for smaller capacities, thus avoiding acquiring unwanted resources.

Capacity

Lockboxes vary in their capacity, with some lockboxes, such as the Barska CB12484, having a capacity of up to 48 keys! Our research found that the larger the capacity, the lower the cost per unit key stored.

Material

Metal was found to reign in the lock boxes, which is understandably reasonable due to the protection needed. Coatings that covered the lock boxes, such as in the Kingsley Guard-a-Key, helped in preventing damage to the lock box on an object and thus proved to be favorable.

Security

Multi-level

Lockboxes with multi-level security, such as requiring a combination code and a physical key, help to lower the risk of theft of the contents in a typical lockbox. Of the key lock boxes we reviewed, most tended to lack multi-level security but had effective single-level security.

Pin or Key

We searched for the locking mechanisms in lock boxes and checked if the lock boxes required the use of pins or a key. The products that emerged the best tended to be pin-based, but we would love to see lock boxes with pin-based security if consumers rank them highly.

Type of Lock Box

The types of lock boxes, including but not limited to bulletproof, fireproof, key-only, combination, keypad, and biometric lock boxes, were identified and used to classify the lock boxes in our review. This factor in our research was neutral to allow other significant aspects to come into play and point out the top lock box gadgets.

Style/Design

Different styles and designs that the manufacturer would recommend were revealed and helped to evaluate the lock boxes according to the customer’s preference. This attribute also influenced the features available, with good designs and styles having more important features.

Price vs Quality

The value for money was evaluated in lock boxes. The quality-price ratio greatly evaluated the lock boxes, revealing the best lock boxes per unit price. For the key lock boxes, we ensured that the attribute of the number of keys was considered.

Usage

The place of use, manner of utilization, and the respective users helped in selecting the best lock boxes. These lock boxes had their respective ratings on their ease of use provided by the buyers, thus informing our research.

Portability

Since storage may imply stationary, we wondered if it was possible to move a lock box. Some were permanent, while others were portable, and the users of the lock boxes helped to decide on the appropriate level of portability for these gadgets.

Durability

Durability was observed in weather-protected lock boxes, while bulletproof and fireproof lock boxes tended to withstand fire and gun attacks. This factor played an important role in analyzing the length of the warranty against the expected product life.

Placement of Lock Box

Some lock boxes are purely wall-mounted, while others don’t need attachments for support. This factor influenced the desirability of the lockboxes in a manner that favored the typical lockbox user.

 

Our Picks For You

Best Pick - Master Lock 5425D

Best Pick

Master Lock 5425D

Master Lock 5425D

A simple, wall-mounted, and easy-to-lock one-inch deep lockbox.

The Wall-Mounted Lock Box from Master Lock offers four amazing styles for flexible and safe key storage.

Buy Now for $39.90

Who It's For

This lock box is good for people willing to store their keys on objects in contact with the unshielded world.

Why It's Great

Each wall-mounted lock box from Master Lock has a weather protection cover that serves as an adequate shield for the parts securing the lockbox from extremely severe weather conditions. The lock boxes can be accessed in heavy-duty, push-button, standard dial, and light-up dial styles that are easy to use.

Potential Flaws

Aged people were happy with these effective lock boxes. However, they aired their concerns about the operability of the lockbox, as the lockbox required a very strong and flexible hand or two hands to open. We thought that this attribute was evidence of its strength, and we could recommend its purchase if the lock box is needed on an outer wall or in a place that would experience direct sunlight.

Other Options/Features

The combination dial is made up of four resettable digits that serve as the primary protectors for up to five 2-inch house keys.

Runner Up - Barska CB12484 Key Lock

Runner Up

Barska CB12484 Key Lock

Barska CB12484 Key Lock

A flat panel lockbox with a beautiful matte black finish.

The Barska CB12484 is a relatively inexpensive and large flat-panel door-style lock box that can store up to 48 keys!

Buy Now for $59.99

Who It's For

The Barska CB12484 is suitable for managers of small-to-medium-sized buildings that need to store up to 48 keys while saving money.

Why It's Great

This lock box has a flat panel door that is lockable, which shuts the opening of a sturdy body with a black matte finish to keep the keys securely in an ingenious fashion. The 48-key hanging positions are in a numbered hook style to make the process of arranging and accessing keys easy and very convenient.

Potential Flaws

Customers complained that this lock box is not fashionable. The poor design may contribute to it being a low-profile object in a home, thus helping in the prevention of unnecessary burglary.

Other Features

This lock box is a cheap option due to the lower cost of acquisition per key stored, ceteris paribus, thus favoring people willing to act frugal.

Most Cost-Effective - Kidde AccessPoint Key Lock Box

Most Cost-Effective

Kidde AccessPoint Key Lock Box

Kidde AccessPoint Key Lock Box

It is durable and trusted by many to hold up to five keys in its safe box.

GE Security produced this lockbox for a market needing a durable and reliable lockbox.

Buy Now for $29.95

Who It's For

This lock box is ideal for those who believe that tradition is the way to go!

Why It's Great

The lock box from GE Security, manufactured in China, may look old, but it can hold up to five keys. It offers a semi-ancient combination lock to its users to provide basic lock box features. The immovable lock box comes with a one-year limited warranty, which many people believe is sufficient to verify the durability of this device. To our surprise, it proved to be amazingly easy to use, sturdy, and waterproof.

Potential Flaws

The numbers not being clear to the customers led to several negative reviews from customers. A customer who could set the code easily found it hard to reenter it due to its perceived lower visibility. We suggest that codes be entered in well-lit conditions, as semi-darkness or total darkness may hamper the opening of the Kidde AccessPoint lockbox.

Other Features

This product has a push button, which the product description on Amazon calls "original," which is a commendable attribute from GE Security to promote intentional security.

Almost Made The Cut - Kingsley Guard-a-Key Black Realtor’s Lockbox

Almost Made The Cut

Kingsley Guard-a-Key Black Realtor's Lockbox

Kingsley Guard-a-Key Black Realtor’s Lockbox

This lock box resembles a traditional padlock, which is an ingenious and good way to conceal the storage of keys.

This contemporary style helps to ensure the user's peace of mind. Besides that, its all-metal construction is painted black for camouflage to prevent theft. This lock box is a good alternative if you don’t prefer a wall-mounted gadget.

Buy Now for $16.72

Who It's For

This lock box is best used for contractors, real estate agents, and other household users that would want to access up to 10 keys.

Why It's Great

The contemporary lock box is black to blend in with the darkness of night, while its vinyl coating protects the doors it hangs on from scratch. It’s allegedly easier to set up than the push button lock boxes, and for placement, it can go over fences, gates, and any possible point that can handle the Kingsley Guard-a-Key.

Potential Flaws

Although Kingsley is a brand that seems trustworthy, and many would recommend their products without trying them out, the prestigious manufacturer fell short in providing adequate instructions on how to use their guard-a-key. A customer even had to go to YouTube to get good directions. This issue, despite its other advantages, made it the fourth-best lockbox.

Other Features

The lock box’s hanging shackle helps its users enjoy the gadget's utilitarian functionality in an alternative manner. This gadget is an outstanding tool in the field of security.

Care and Maintenance

The contents of a lock box are only known to the lock box’s owner, who stores items in the lockbox. Therefore, no one can and should inspect the lock box to determine the value without the owner’s authorization. If in doubt, the owner can review such contents to gauge their value.

Due to the variety of lock boxes that are available in terms of size and capacity, we advise you to get the right box that matches what you feel you need, saves money, and prevents space and resource wastage. Place a lock box in the place where the manufacturer recommends. Please follow the necessary instructions if it should be wall-mounted.

It’s very safe to have a backup of the key, pin, or opening mechanism since most retail outlets may not have a mechanism for opening faulty lock boxes and would liaise with the manufacturer for help. Until help comes, the backup should allow the lockbox owner to access their items without delay.