The Best Crib Mattress of 2023

You need a good crib mattress to guarantee your baby's maximum comfort and safety.

The Best Crib Mattress of 2022

Sleep is an essential part of our lives. Good quality sleep makes humans recharge their energy to continue doing their activities the next day. Everyone, from babies to adults, needs a good quality of sleep.

While the average adult needs at least eight hours of sleep, babies need more than 12 hours of sleep for their growth. Babies require a mattress that is not only comfortable but also sanitary. They require a mattress that is waterproof, dust-free, and allergen-free. You can find all these features in crib mattresses.

There are a lot of crib mattresses out there, but how do you know what the best crib mattress is for you? We will give you our recommendations for crib mattresses that you could get to make your baby sleep in maximum comfort.

How We Picked

  • Firm & comfortable

    The crib mattresses should provide a firm and secure layer of padding that is also comfortable for an infant. This allows infants to rest or sleep with maximum comfort while protecting them from potential harm.

  • Easy to Clean

    Cleaning the crib mattresses should be as simple as possible. Maintaining the cleanliness of your baby's crib mattresses may help keep allergen-causing microorganisms, dirt, and unwanted bacteria from adhering.

  • Durability

    A crib mattress is usually used for about three to four years. Even with this seemingly short period of usage, the crib mattress should be durable to withstand the ever-growing infant and its physical activities.

  • Cost-Effective

    A good crib mattress doesn’t come cheap. However, we gathered a few budget crib mattresses without compromising on quality.

Our Top Picks

Best Pick

Newton Baby Crib Mattress

Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed

All in one breathable and comfort-oriented crib mattress

A crib mattress that takes into account every little safety detail.

Buy Now for $299.99

The Newton Baby Crib Mattress provides you with a perfect set of crib mattresses. It's breathable, washable, environmentally friendly, and also provides firmness. The wovenaire material technology offers this crib mattress with incredible breathability that can prevent suffocation.

Runner Up

Naturepedic Organic Waterproof Baby Crib Mattress Pad

Naturepedic Organic Waterproof Baby Crib Mattress Pad

A crib mattress made from natural materials

A waterproof crib mattress made from 100% organic cotton.

Buy Now for $69.00

The Naturepedic is a 100% organic cotton crib mattress that has a waterproof protector pad and a dry sleep technology that blocks liquid, thus keeping the crib mattress dry and breathable for your infant.

Most Cost-Effective

Graco Ultra 2-in-1 Premium Dual-Sided Crib & Toddler Mattress

Graco Ultra 2-in-1 Premium Dual-Sided Crib & Toddler Mattress

The crib mattress can adapt to the growth phase of an infant

22-in-1 crib mattress comes with an adaptive comfort system for your ever-growing infant.

Buy Now for $113.75

The Graco Ultra 2-in-1 is a unique crib mattress with two different surfaces, each designed to accommodate the infant and toddler phases, giving adaptive features and comfort that adjusts with each stage of growth.

Everything We Recommend

Best Pick

Newton Baby Crib Mattress

Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed

All in one breathable and comfort-oriented crib mattress

$299.99

Buy Now

Runner Up

Naturepedic Organic Waterproof Baby Crib Mattress Pad

Naturepedic Organic Waterproof Baby Crib Mattress Pad

A crib mattress made from natural materials

$69.00

Buy Now

Most Cost-Effective

Graco Ultra 2-in-1 Premium Dual-Sided Crib & Toddler Mattress

Graco Ultra 2-in-1 Premium Dual-Sided Crib & Toddler Mattress

The crib mattress can adapt to the growth phase of an infant

$113.75

Buy Now

Who This Is For

This is for those who are looking for a crib mattress for their babies or infants that provides a great quality that will give their infants the comfort they need.

Foam vs. coil crib mattress
Two types of crib mattresses dominate the market; foam-based and coil-based crib mattresses.

The foam-based crib mattress is usually lighter than the coil-based. The materials used in this type of mattress are also more organic. However, they are less durable and provide less edge support than coiled ones.

On the other hand, coil-based crib mattresses are heavier in general. They also cost more than foam-based ones. But coil-based mattresses are more durable and provide better edge support than foam-based mattresses.

Is it worth splurging on?
Investing in a good crib mattress is an incredible idea. A high-quality crib mattress could provide your infant with a more comfortable, safe, and hygienic sleep environment.

If you have the extra funds, invest in comfortable and feature-rich crib mattresses that will enhance the sleep quality of your infant. Indeed, the long-term benefits of investing in a crib mattress will pay off years later.

Why You Should Trust Us

Many products are available for purchase right now, and finding the most suitable one is our part. We present you with good quality and price-conscious products. We have imposed specific criteria to ensure that you get the right crib mattress at the right price.

How We Picked

As mentioned before, we selected the crib mattress based on specific criteria. Only the ones that passed the requirements check that we will choose. Now, we will show you how we liked the mattress for you.

Firstly, we are looking for a crib mattress that gives your infant comfortable padding with a range of three to five inches or more of thickness, with firm body cushioning and padding support. This makes the infant using it feel comfortable while sleeping on it.

We also picked a crib mattress with a reasonable weight, not too heavy or too light but strong enough to sustain an infant.

We are also looking for a crib mattress with an environmentally friendly and natural base material. This is also becoming our concern as too many industrial materials in the mattress could negatively affect newborn infants and add more weight to the mattress.

When combined with technology, natural materials can give you an advanced feature that can improve the overall quality.

Next is an ease-of-use factor. Aside from providing the user with good features, the selected crib mattress should also be easy to clean. Cleaning the mattress offers an infant a more hygienic sleeping environment, making it safer for a child.

And they also provide excellent durability and longevity to be used for a total length of three to four years.

With all the advantages above, we also ensure that the recommended items are worth every penny. You can get a high-quality crib mattress with various features that are safe for your child and your pockets. And that’s a glimpse of how we evaluated the items for you. Now let’s get to know our picks for crib mattresses down below.

Our Picks For You

Best Pick - Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed

Best Pick

Newton Baby Crib Mattress

Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed

All in one breathable and comfort-oriented crib mattress

A crib mattress that takes into account every little safety detail.

Buy Now for $299.99

Who It's For

If you want a complete set of crib mattresses that gives you a lot of unique features and great ease of use, this is the one for you.


Why It's Great

The Newton Baby Crib Mattress becomes our first pick in this section for a good reason. This crib mattress uses double-layered cushioning with a removable cover. Their Breathe-Thru Technology is also there to make this mattress 100% breathable for your baby. Another great thing is that this crib mattress is washable from the cover to the core.

Potential Flaws

Although this crib mattress is washable from the cover to the core; only the cover is suitable for a machine wash. As for the core part, please wash it separately using a simple rinsing method.

Other Features

The Newton Baby Crib Mattress is a great crib mattress that could give your baby a good night's sleep. With 5.5 inches of thickness, this mattress provides both comfort and firmness. Made from wovenaire materials that consist of 90% air and only 10% polymer material, this mattress is easily breathable, minimizing the risk of suffocation. We also like the fact that this crib mattress is 100% washable. You need to rinse the core using a shower and let it dry afterward.

Runner Up - Naturepedic Organic Waterproof Baby Crib Mattress Pad

Runner Up

Naturepedic Organic Waterproof Baby Crib Mattress Pad

Naturepedic Organic Waterproof Baby Crib Mattress Pad

A crib mattress made from natural materials

A waterproof crib mattress made from 100% organic cotton.

Buy Now for $69.00

Who It's For

For those looking for a more specific crib mattress made from cotton, it won’t cost you a lot of money. This is the item that you've been looking for.

Why It's Great

Made from 100% organic cotton fabric, the Naturepedic Organic is an all-natural and organic mattress containing the minimum amount of toxic chemicals that could harm an infant. Going for an organic-based crib mattress is also a great way to minimize the risk of contracting microscopic organisms that can cause allergies. Even though it’s made from organic cotton, this mattress is waterproof.

Potential Flaws

Compared to the previous ones, this mattress only has a 4-inch thickness. It might concern those who want a thicker layer on their crib mattress. We also don’t recommend this crib mattress be washed using a machine. A manual wash should be enough.

Other Features

Naturepedic Organic is a lightweight crib mattress that is made from natural materials such as cotton and non-GMO sugarcane that creates a waterproof and easy-to-clean surface material for the mattress. Thanks to all organic materials and the fuse of technology, this mattress could also eliminate any flammable synthetics, making this mattress free from flame retardants.

Most Cost-Effective - Graco Ultra 2-in-1 Premium Dual-Sided Crib & Toddler Mattress

Most Cost-Effective

Graco Ultra 2-in-1 Premium Dual-Sided Crib & Toddler Mattress

Graco Ultra 2-in-1 Premium Dual-Sided Crib & Toddler Mattress

The crib mattress can adapt to the growth phase of an infant

22-in-1 crib mattress comes with an adaptive comfort system for your ever-growing infant.

Buy Now for $113.75

Who It's For

This mattress is a 2-in-1 mattress that could be used in two different stages of growth. Get this if you want a mattress that adapts to your infant's growth phases.

Why It's Great

The Graco Ultra 2-in-1 is a unique crib mattress that can adjust to the growing stages of a child. It accommodates the comfort and safety that an infant or a toddler needs to improve their sleep quality with its ultra-soft and water-resistant features. It also has a fast and easy unzipping system, which allows you to wash the mattress easily.

Potential Flaws

This crib mattress is not waterproof, only water resistant. And also similar to the previous one, this crib mattress is also not suitable for machine washing. Only the mattress cover is suitable for a machine wash.

Other Features

With a 6-inch thickness and water-resistant feature, this mattress gives your toddler a good and comfortable sleeping environment. Aside from the ease of usage and the comfort this crib mattress offers you, the Graco Ultra 2-in-1 was also certified with a GREENGUARD GOLD that has passed the screening of at least 10,000 chemicals that can cause pollution, especially in indoor areas. This mattress provides no harm to your infant that can cause allergies or any other health problems

Almost Made The Cut - Milliard 4.5 Inch Memory Foam Replacement Mattress

Almost Made The Cut

Milliard 4.5 Inch Memory Foam Replacement Mattress

Milliard 4.5 Inch Memory Foam Replacement Mattress

A foam-based comfort-oriented crib mattress

A memory foam crib mattress for extra comfort and durability.

Buy Now for $82.30

Who It's For

If you are specifically looking to get a memory foam-based crib mattress at a slightly lower price, this is our pick for you.

Why It's Great

This Milliard Premium Memory Foam is a crib mattress made from memory foam that will provide your infant with layer support that won’t flatten out when used from time to time. This provides a longer quality of comfort that helps your infant sleep well. This mattress also has an additional cover made from bamboo that is machine washable.

Potential Flaws

As a crib mattress is made from memory foam, there is a bit of concern about the firmness of the mattress. The 3-pound padding might not be strong enough for your infant as they grow into a toddler phase.

Other Features

This memory foam-based crib mattress is a soft and comfortable mattress with only 11 ounces of weight. The Milliard Premium Memory Foam is made from safe materials that have been tested with the result of low VOC (volatile organic compounds) and is free from mercury and other heavy metal components. This results in a free-flowing mattress that maximizes the airflow, making it a breathable mattress that can regulate the temperature.

Care and Maintenance

Having a great quality crib mattress that can improve the overall quality of your infant’s sleep is a great idea. But you must also pay attention to taking care of the crib mattress.

Even though your crib mattress has a superior quality that can remove dust and other particles, keeping it clean is needed. We will show you how to take care of your crib mattress.

Firstly, you have to clean your crib mattress. Having a periodic cleaning schedule is even better. Remove the mattress cover. Usually, the mattress cover can be used using a machine but not the mattress.

Before you can wash the mattress, it is ideal for cleaning the mattress using a vacuum. After that, you need to rinse the mattress with water, vinegar, or baby-friendly soap.

By using a baby-friendly soap, you could also get rid of odors or stains that adhere to the mattress.

When the time comes that your baby doesn’t need to use the crib mattress anymore, you could easily flip it and store it inside a cardboard box and put it in your attic.