11 min. read

The Best Compost Bins for 2023

Choose the best compost bins from this list, and make your composting experience worthwhile and eco-friendly

Compost is used in gardening to give plants nutrients from decomposed organic matter. It can be used independently or as a soil amendment. Composting involves breaking down organic matter by microorganisms, fungi, and bacteria.

You can easily make compost at home from kitchen scraps and yard waste. Getting a compost bin is the best way to compost if you don’t have the space for a compost pile. A typical compost bin is an enclosed structure with a lid and bottom designed to allow air and moisture to flow through the waste while keeping out pests.

Compost bins come in various shapes and sizes, ranging from countertop bins to large tumblers. Countertop compost bins are small and compact, making them ideal for small kitchens or limited counter space. Large tumblers are ideal for those who compost frequently or have a lot of kitchen waste.

How We Picked

  • Size and Capacity

    Depending on how much kitchen scraps and yard waste you generate, you’ll need to choose a bin that’s the appropriate size. Smaller bins are better for occasional composting, while larger bins are better for frequent composting.

  • Open-Lid or Closed

    Open compost bins allow air to circulate, speeding up the composting process. On the other hand, closed compost bins keep out pests and odors, but composting will take a little longer.

  • Ease of Compost Removal

    Some compost bins have a removable bottom or lid which makes emptying a whole lot easy. Other compost bins require you to dump the entire bin, which can be messy.

  • Cost-Effectiveness

    Compost bins can range in price from $20 to $200. If you’re on a budget, choose a bin made of recycled materials. If cost is not an issue, get a bin with all the bells and whistles such as a built-in thermometer or aeration system.

Our Top Picks

Our Top Pick

Algreen Soil Saver Composter

Algreen Soil Saver Composter

Made from UV-resistant polyethylene, its robust thickness and construction help trap heat enabling microorganisms to break down waste faster.

The award-winning SoilSaver compost bin has been in production for more than 25 years, longer than all other major compost bins combined. It is constructed of structural foam, and black recycled plastic, and is developed to withstand the elements. It doesn't have snaps or plastic tabs to break or clog, just sturdy insulated side panels that bolt together.

Buy Now

This is a no-fuss bin made from UV-resistant polyethylene, so it will stand up to the elements.

Our Runner-Up

Epica Stainless Steel Compost Bin

Epica Stainless Steel Compost Bin

Made from high-quality stainless steel, this product with its single-piece molding ensures strength and durability that will not crack, chip, or scratch.

As opposed to other bins that are welded and prone to rust and leakage overtime at the weld points, this stylish stainless steel bin is molded in one piece and resists rust and leaks. A convenient eco-friendly lifestyle is always at your fingertips. With its airtight lid and replaceable activated-charcoal filter, this kitchen compost bin effectively traps and controls odors naturally. In addition to being chic and modern, the design works well with any decor.

Buy Now for $21.95

This bin is composed of high-quality stainless steel and will not rust. It is also extremely simple to clean.

Most Cost-Effective

OXO Easy Clean Plastic Compost Bin

OXO Easy Clean Plastic Compost Bin

Coming with a lid to keep odors at bay, the inside is smooth to reduce trash adhering to the walls and food or liquid accumulation.

Designed with the home cook in mind, the OXO Good Grips Easy-Clean Compost Bin takes composting to a whole new level. A flip-up lid allows you to open and close the container with one hand, and it prevents odors from spreading. The easy-to-carry handle makes carrying the filled Bin easy, and smooth interior walls facilitate easy cleanups.

Buy Now for $22.92

This bin is a great buy for the price because it's larger than others and has a handy cover that keeps odor from spreading.

Everything We Recommend

Our Top Pick

Algreen Soil Saver Composter

Algreen Soil Saver Composter

Made from UV-resistant polyethylene, its robust thickness and construction help trap heat enabling microorganisms to break down waste faster.

Buy Now

Our Runner-Up

Epica Stainless Steel Compost Bin

Epica Stainless Steel Compost Bin

Made from high-quality stainless steel, this product with its single-piece molding ensures strength and durability that will not crack, chip, or scratch.

$21.95

Buy Now

Most Cost-Effective

OXO Easy Clean Plastic Compost Bin

OXO Easy Clean Plastic Compost Bin

Coming with a lid to keep odors at bay, the inside is smooth to reduce trash adhering to the walls and food or liquid accumulation.

$22.92

Buy Now

Who This Is For

This research is for gardeners who want to add nutrients to the soil and for environmentalists passionate about reducing methane emissions from landfills to offset their carbon footprint.

Different Types Of Compost Bins
There are various compost bins available on the market. Some bins are designed for indoor use, while others are meant for outdoor use. Indoor compost bins are typically small and can be placed on a countertop or under the sink. Some indoor compost bins come with filters to reduce odors. Outdoor compost bins are larger and can be placed in the yard or garden. Some outdoor compost bins have lids to keep animals out.

What Should Go In A Compost Bin?
Organic matter such as fruits, vegetables, egg shells, coffee grounds, and leaves, because these items break down quickly and turn into compost relatively easily.
Inorganic matter such as cardboard, wood chips, and paper can also be added to a compost bin. However, these items take much longer to break down and may not decompose fully if the conditions in the bin are not ideal.

Why You Should Trust Us

We consulted with experts in horticulture and gardening to find the best compost bins. Our team also reviewed customer reviews to see which products were the most popular and well-reviewed. We then narrowed our focus to five compost bins that we felt were the best on the market. We tested these products for durability, ease of use, and effectiveness.

How We Picked

Size
We looked for compost bins that were large enough to accommodate a fair amount of organic matter but not so large that they would be difficult to move.

Height
The height allows air to circulate through the compost, which is important for composting. We looked for compost bins that were tall enough to allow for adequate air circulation.

Open/closed lid
Some compost bins come with a lid to keep animals out, while others do not. We considered both types of bins and determined that a bin with a lid is the best option for most people because it helps to keep pests out of the bin.

Style/Bin type
We considered this to ensure that there was a bin on our list that would suit every gardener’s needs. Some people prefer bins placed on the ground, while others prefer countertop bins.

Ease Of Compost Removal
We looked for bins with a removable bottom or a built-in fixture for easy compost removal. We also considered the ease of adding organic matter to the bin.

Price vs. Quality
We looked for well-made bins that would last for years, but we also considered the price to ensure that the bins were affordable.

Placement
During our research, we realized some compost bins could be placed in the ground, others on a countertop or under the sink. We considered the placement options of each bin to ensure that there was a bin on our list that would suit the needs of every person looking forward to composting this year.

Our Picks For You

Our Top Pick - Algreen Soil Saver Composter

Our Top Pick

Algreen Soil Saver Composter

Algreen Soil Saver Composter

Made from UV-resistant polyethylene, its robust thickness and construction help trap heat enabling microorganisms to break down waste faster.

The award-winning SoilSaver compost bin has been in production for more than 25 years, longer than all other major compost bins combined. It is constructed of structural foam, and black recycled plastic, and is developed to withstand the elements. It doesn't have snaps or plastic tabs to break or clog, just sturdy insulated side panels that bolt together.

Buy Now

Who It's For

The Algreen Soil Saver is best for gardeners who want an attractive, durable, stationery, and easy-to-use outdoor compost bin.

Why It's Great

The compost bin is huge and easy to assemble. It is made from UV-resistant polyethylene, so it will stand up to weather elements like the sun without cracking or fading. The bin has an aeration hole in the bottom and a removable lid for easy access.

Potential Flaws

However, some customers have complained that the compost bin is difficult to move once it is full. The bin is expensive, but it is one of the largest bins available. Therefore, it is a good value for money.

Other Features

The compost bin contains two twist locks on the top and a small door at the base. The twist locks are easy to remove when you need to add your scraps. On the other hand, the small door at the base is for accessing the fully composted soil at the bottom of the bin. Therefore, this bin is easy to use and holds tons of remains giving the microbes enough to compost.

Our Runner-Up - Epica Stainless Steel Compost Bin

Our Runner-Up

Epica Stainless Steel Compost Bin

Epica Stainless Steel Compost Bin

Made from high-quality stainless steel, this product with its single-piece molding ensures strength and durability that will not crack, chip, or scratch.

As opposed to other bins that are welded and prone to rust and leakage overtime at the weld points, this stylish stainless steel bin is molded in one piece and resists rust and leaks. A convenient eco-friendly lifestyle is always at your fingertips. With its airtight lid and replaceable activated-charcoal filter, this kitchen compost bin effectively traps and controls odors naturally. In addition to being chic and modern, the design works well with any decor.

Buy Now for $21.95

Who It's For

The Epica Compost Bin is the best pick for eco-friendly gardeners who want an elegant, durable, and easy-to-clean bin for their kitchen.

Why It's Great

This compost bin is made from high-quality stainless steel and sits unobtrusively on the kitchen countertop, yet keeping messes and smells contained.

Potential Flaws

On the downside, the bin does not have a way to aerate the compost, so it will need to be turned more frequently. The Epica Stainless Steel Compost is also more expensive than some of the other bins on our list.

Other Features

The indoor compost bin is fitted with an airtight lid and a replaceable activated-charcoal filter. The two control and trap odors naturally make it perfect for kitchen use. The Epica Stainless Steel Compost Bin has a chic modern design that complements any decor. The bin is molded for durability. It is built from high-grade stainless steel that won't rust, scratch, crack, or chip.

The Epica Stainless Steel Compost Bin contains all the kitchen scraps until it is full. It has a carrying handle for conveniently carrying it to the outdoor compost pile or bin. The activated-charcoal filter is simple to pull out and pop in a new one every few months, but other than that, this bin is easy to use and low maintenance.

Most Cost-Effective - OXO Easy Clean Plastic Compost Bin

Most Cost-Effective

OXO Easy Clean Plastic Compost Bin

OXO Easy Clean Plastic Compost Bin

Coming with a lid to keep odors at bay, the inside is smooth to reduce trash adhering to the walls and food or liquid accumulation.

Designed with the home cook in mind, the OXO Good Grips Easy-Clean Compost Bin takes composting to a whole new level. A flip-up lid allows you to open and close the container with one hand, and it prevents odors from spreading. The easy-to-carry handle makes carrying the filled Bin easy, and smooth interior walls facilitate easy cleanups.

Buy Now for $22.92

Who It's For

The OXO Compost Bin is the best pick for budget-conscious, minimalist gardeners.

Why It's Great

The bin can fit a 3-gallon bag decently on a kitchen countertop. It is also easy to clean, and it is leak-proof. The plastic bin is designed to keep bags inside for a neat look. It has a large capacity of up to 203 ounces, making it ideal for a busy kitchen or frequent composting.

Potential Flaws

In some cases, customers complained that there were no holes for air to enter or exit, which leads to excessive moisture inside the bags, causing a terrible smell and rips in the compost bags.

Other Features

The bin's interior is smooth, making it easy to clean, and has a soft-open and close lid that enhances the tossing in of scraps while still working. The soft-close lid also enhances oxygen flow containing odors and keeps off pests. This minimalist bin's lid is removable, making emptying convenient. Hence, it is an effective compost bin that is user-friendly.

Almost Made The Cut - Redmon Compost Bin, 65 Gallon

Almost Made The Cut

Redmon Compost Bin, 65 Gallon

Redmon Compost Bin, 65 Gallon

The bin has a roomy interior, secure closures, and multiple openings that make composting easy.

With Redmon's Green Culture Compost bin, you will be able to produce compost for many years to come. In addition to the compost bin, a comprehensive composting reference guide is included. Slide doors are included on each side panel for easy access to the bottom of the compost batch while the top cooks. In addition to using recycled plastic, the Redmon Green Culture Compost Bin is BPA and Phthalate free, as well as UV stabilized for long-lasting durability.

Buy Now for $72.99

Who It's For

The Redmon Compost Bin is the best pick for gardeners who want an attractive, durable, and easy-to-use outdoor compost bin.

Why It's Great

This compost bin is durable and has a capacity of up to 65 gallons, making it one of the largest on our list. It also has an aeration hole in the lid to help with composting.

Potential Flaws

Several reviewers complain that it lets too much air through, which prevents anything from actually composting.

Other Features

The Redmon Compost Bin is easy to set up and use. It also comes with a helpful user guide.

This compost bin is made to collect and store compost within the home and garden. It can accommodate a lot of organic waste with its large capacity. This sturdy bin has four built-in doors around its sides for easy access and a top snap-on lid to retrieve composted material.

It is made of UV stable material (post-consumer PP) for long-lasting all-weather durability. Above all, the bin is easy to assemble and convenient for composting.

Care and Maintenance

It is important to keep the bin clean, so it does not attract pests. Once you remove organic matter that has not yet been composted, rinse the bin with a hose. You can also add bleach to the water to kill bacteria or mold and let the bin dry completely before adding new organic matter.

The best place for a compost bin is in a shady location and out of the way. It should also be close to a water source so that you can easily add water to the bin when needed. Water softens and breaks down the organic matter in the bin, which speeds up the composting process.

The composting speed depends on several factors, including the size of the bin, the type of organic matter being added to the bin, and the amount of water and air present. Generally, it takes about two to four weeks for food scraps and other organic matter to break down into compost.

Ready-to-use compost is dark brown and has a crumbly texture. To remove the compost from the bin, open the door, lift the lid, and scoop out the compost with a shovel. Ensure to only remove as much compost as you need, as leaving too much in the bin can slow down the composting process.

You can add new organic matter to the bin at any time. However, it is best to mix it with the existing compost to break down more quickly. If you are adding a lot of new organic matter to the bin, you may need to add more water so that the compost does not become too dry.