The Best Casserole Dish for 2023

Prepare, cook and serve your heartiest meals in the loveliest casserole dishes available on the market right now!

With the festive season heading our way, it is the perfect time to make a tasty casserole for you and your loved ones! A good casserole dish will make all the difference. Serving a hearty casserole is about so much more than just having the perfect recipe and fresh ingredients. A good dish makes all of the difference to this cold season-winning meal.

There are many factors to take into account when selecting the best casserole dish, from determining the right size to making sure your casserole cooks properly. We are here to make your search easier so in addition to those factors, we’re also looking at the casserole dishes that are the easiest to clean and aren’t going to take too big of a bite out of your holiday shopping budget.

How We Picked

  • Size and Capacity

    The size and capacity of a casserole dish are important because they determine how many people you’ll be able to feed. They also determine how much space your casserole needs to cook thoroughly without the contents spilling over.

  • Material and Durability

    We’ll look at why having a casserole dish made of cast iron or ceramic is important for even heat distribution, whether the material is compatible with your oven, and how to test its durability to ensure it is flameproof.

  • Easy to Clean

    You’ll be using your casserole dish often and with all kinds of ingredients. Your dishes need to be easy to clean with basic cleaning agents. A casserole dish that does not need much maintenance won’t need to be replaced often, helping you save money.

  • Cost-Effectiveness

    A good quality casserole dish is worth every penny. That’s why helping you choose the best dish that is durable and comes at a decent price.

Our Top Picks

Our Top Pick

Emile Henry Large Rectangular Baker

Emile Henry Large Rectangular Baker

Emile Henry promises versatility, durability, and stunning aesthetics.

The Emile Henry is revered for not only doing the job but excelling at fitting into all of your household needs. It is large enough to fit a family-sized casserole, and its material ensures that it can be used in your oven, your microwave, freezer, and dishwasher. Its scratch-resistant glaze ensures a non-stick bottom. This casserole dish is perfect for lasting use with high customer reviews for its incredible depth. It is also super easy to clean.

Buy Now for $69.95

The best in durability and versatility at a reasonable price.

Our Runner-Up

Le Creuset’s Stoneware Rectangular Baker With Platter Lid

Le Creuset’s Stoneware Rectangular Baker With Platter Lid

Le Creuset delivers on usability and quality.

This casserole dish from the well-loved international brand is easy on the eye, scratch, chip, and stain resistant, and its lid can double as a platter. While it is on the more expensive side, Le Creuset’s baker can be safely used in all of your cooking and storing appliances. Its size makes it great for small families.

Buy Now for $124.95

It comes in a range of colors and cooks very well.

Most Cost-Effective

Lodge BW13C Inch Seasoned Cast Iron Casserole

Lodge BW13C Inch Seasoned Cast Iron Casserole

The Lodge presents a casserole dish that retains heat, bakes well, and is affordable.

Cost-effective and easy to clean, the Lodge Seasoned Cast Iron casserole dish is a favorite among other customers for being lightweight. Loaves seemingly pop out with ease from this dish and have excellent heat retention. It can be used in your oven and on the outside grill, so entertaining is made even easier. Its slim build allows for easy storage. Enjoy a well-made baking dish built for your convenience.

Buy Now for $39.90

Save those bucks with this low-cost option.

Everything We Recommend

Our Top Pick

Emile Henry Large Rectangular Baker

Emile Henry Large Rectangular Baker

Emile Henry promises versatility, durability, and stunning aesthetics.

$69.95

Buy Now

Our Runner-Up

Le Creuset’s Stoneware Rectangular Baker With Platter Lid

Le Creuset’s Stoneware Rectangular Baker With Platter Lid

Le Creuset delivers on usability and quality.

$124.95

Buy Now

Most Cost-Effective

Lodge BW13C Inch Seasoned Cast Iron Casserole

Lodge BW13C Inch Seasoned Cast Iron Casserole

The Lodge presents a casserole dish that retains heat, bakes well, and is affordable.

$39.90

Buy Now

Who This Is For

The products reviewed here are for all homemakers and professional chefs who enjoy baking a well-cooked casserole in a quality dish!

What is a casserole dish?
A casserole dish is typically a large and deep pan or bowl that we use to cook or bake a variety of dishes in an oven.

Can you make casseroles in a pasta dish?
Casseroles can include pasta, like lasagne. Casseroles can be made in a baking pan or an oven-safe sauté pan.

Can you use a casserole dish on an induction hob/stove?
You can use a casserole dish on an induction hob or stove as long as the size of your dish matches the diameter of the fire. This means you won’t use a 20cm casserole dish on a 28cm inductor. Be sure to not scratch your ceramic or glass dish on the induction hob/stove.

The ideal size of a casserole dish
The size of your casserole dish depends on the recipe you want to create. Ideally, a casserole dish should be deep enough to contain all of your ingredients without spilling over the top or rising too high that it dirtifys your oven. For all of those requirements, the ideal size is a 9-by-13 casserole dish.

Why You Should Trust Us

Many casserole dishes are marketed for chefs and home-based cooks who want a simple, easy-to-use dish that does the job in one fell swoop. We did our extensive research and ensured we reviewed the best casserole dishes with the best durability, the best material, the easiest to clean, and the least likely to bankrupt you. We scoured hundreds of customer reviews, held each product to the same standards, and selected the best choices for you.

How We Picked

It’s not easy to find the right casserole dish for you, especially with all of the competing and wide range of brands online. To make the process easier, we scoured over hundreds of previous customer reviews and compared their experiences with each dish. Their feedback ranged from glowing reviews about the usability of each dish to be equally vocal about what didn’t work for them.
We looked at why size matters when it comes to baking or cooking with a casserole dish. We explored why high sides, suitable depth, and how well the dish contains all of the ingredients have an impact on your choice of size and capacity.

We next looked at why the material and durability are important and how that affects the cost of the dish. Casserole dishes are available in cast iron, ceramic, and glass, and these materials will affect how heat-resistant and oven-proof each dish is. These are all important factors when you need to consider that cracks may affect your health too. For convenience’s sake, we’ve looked at how easy each dish is to clean and whether they are dishwasher safe too. If your casserole dish is coated with an anti-stick agent, this will help the cleaning process so much more. Handles and lids, which are suitably sized or can double as platters are key features we’ve considered too. As always, finding the best bargains on casserole dishes was top of mind for us too!

Our Picks For You

Our Top Pick - Emile Henry Large Rectangular Baker

Our Top Pick

Emile Henry Large Rectangular Baker

Emile Henry Large Rectangular Baker

Emile Henry promises versatility, durability, and stunning aesthetics.

The Emile Henry is revered for not only doing the job but excelling at fitting into all of your household needs. It is large enough to fit a family-sized casserole, and its material ensures that it can be used in your oven, your microwave, freezer, and dishwasher. Its scratch-resistant glaze ensures a non-stick bottom. This casserole dish is perfect for lasting use with high customer reviews for its incredible depth. It is also super easy to clean.

Buy Now for $69.95

Who It's For

The Emile Henry Large Rectangular Baker is the perfect choice for Mom or Dad wanting to make a hearty meal that is going to satisfy the whole family and perhaps leave leftovers for lunch the next day!

Why It's Great

Since it's chip resistant, you won't have to worry about replacing it often. A bonus is that no one has to fight over who's doing the dishes - this casserole dish is dishwasher safe. It's deep enough that you won't have to worry about spilling your ingredients or leaving any mess behind.

Potential Flaws

The bottom of the Emile Henry Large Rectangular Baker is not glazed. If you want that glazed finish, other dishes reviewed here have that feature. It does not come with a lid, so when storing your leftover casserole, you may want to transfer it to another container or use cling wrap.

Other Features

This casserole dish is sturdier, more lightweight, more versatile, and more durable than the others reviewed here. Yes, it's more expensive than some of the other dishes, but it is worth its weight in gold. It offers more depth and sports high sides to avoid spills and overcooked food. Its key attractive feature is being dishwasher friendly so that you don't spend hours soaking and scrubbing it. With its even heating distribution, it is effective for cooking or baking your favorite meal or treat. It is also freezer friendly so you can cook ahead if need be!

Our Runner-Up - Le Creuset’s Stoneware Rectangular Baker With Platter Lid

Our Runner-Up

Le Creuset’s Stoneware Rectangular Baker With Platter Lid

Le Creuset’s Stoneware Rectangular Baker With Platter Lid

Le Creuset delivers on usability and quality.

This casserole dish from the well-loved international brand is easy on the eye, scratch, chip, and stain resistant, and its lid can double as a platter. While it is on the more expensive side, Le Creuset’s baker can be safely used in all of your cooking and storing appliances. Its size makes it great for small families.

Buy Now for $124.95

Who It's For

The Le Creuset Stoneware Rectangular Dish with Platter is for the home baker and chef with more cash to spare.

Why It's Great

Easy to clean (but ensure that the dish is completely cooled down before washing it as cracks may appear), the Le Creuset Stoneware Rectangular Dish comes in a variety of colors to match your kitchenware. Its versatility is its greatest feature, with a lid that doubles as a platter!

Potential Flaws

As mentioned before, its tendency to take a while to cool down may impact your cleaning time. You'll need to be extra careful not to overheat this dish. Its handles need to be managed carefully too. Other than that, the only limitation on what you can bake or cook in this dish is your imagination!

Other Features

This delightful Le Creuset dish is worth every penny. With its lid that functions as a platter, it already offers more bang for your buck than other dishes reviewed here. The dish boasts even heat distribution which ensures your casserole or baked goods browns evenly and cooks thoroughly. Its glaze is resistant to scratching, stains, and flavor absorption, so you will get years of use out of it.

Most Cost-Effective - Lodge BW13C Inch Seasoned Cast Iron Casserole

Most Cost-Effective

Lodge BW13C Inch Seasoned Cast Iron Casserole

Lodge BW13C Inch Seasoned Cast Iron Casserole

The Lodge presents a casserole dish that retains heat, bakes well, and is affordable.

Cost-effective and easy to clean, the Lodge Seasoned Cast Iron casserole dish is a favorite among other customers for being lightweight. Loaves seemingly pop out with ease from this dish and have excellent heat retention. It can be used in your oven and on the outside grill, so entertaining is made even easier. Its slim build allows for easy storage. Enjoy a well-made baking dish built for your convenience.

Buy Now for $39.90

Who It's For

The Lodge Seasoned Cast Iron Casserole is for the new homeowner, baker, or cook working within a set budget.

Why It's Great

This casserole dish makes a great wedding gift that can be passed down from generation to generation because it, more than any of the others reviewed here, is built to last. It is finished with 100% natural vegetable oil for durability. Its cast iron material offers unparalleled heat distribution and retention.

Potential Flaws

This casserole dish can be prone to rust if not taken care of properly. It cannot be used over a wooden pizza fire, so please be aware of this. It isn’t much to look at, and it doesn’t have any color variants.

Other Features

This dish is a classic for a reason; it’s cheap, it lasts a long time, and it is super easy to use. Your grandmother used it, you’ll use it, and your grandchildren will use it too, so it is worth the price and maintenance required to keep it looking and working well. It matches all of the other products reviewed here in terms of even heat distribution, heat retention, usability, and effectiveness.

Almost Made The Cut - Dansk Kobenstyle Rectangular Baker

Almost Made The Cut

Dansk Kobenstyle Rectangular Baker

Dansk Kobenstyle Rectangular Baker

Dansk upholds its standard of luxury and style with this dish.

The Dansk Kobenstyle Rectangular Baker is fantastic to look at, great to use, and a source of pride to own. Its price tag, though, is something to deeply consider before making your purchase. For what it costs, this dish does not offer as many features as the rest reviewed here. It can only be hand washed and can only be heated up to 450°F, which makes cooking or baking difficult if you need more heat.

Buy Now for $289.99

Who It's For

The Dansk Kobenstyle Rectangular Baker is for the baker or chef who believes in spending more to get more.

Why It's Great

This deluxe casserole dish is more expensive than any of the others we've received and makes entertaining super easy. It releases food quite easily and looks beautiful on your stovetop or display in your kitchen. It is lighter than some of its counterparts, which helps with carrying around when you are entertaining.

Potential Flaws

This casserole dish is not dishwasher safe, so you may find yourself having to soak it for a day or two and then carefully wash it by hand. It doesn’t cook as evenly as its competitors. It is beautiful to look at and will impress your guests.

Other Features

There’s no denying the fact that the Dansk Kobenstyle Rectangular Baker is more expensive than all of the other casserole dishes we’ve reviewed. It does make up for that by being pleasing to the eye and offering some versatility with its lid, which can be used as a stand or platter. It is lighter than most dishes, so transportation is easier. It isn’t as easy to clean as its competitors, but it is easier to use and store.

Care and Maintenance

We know you don’t want to spend hours in your kitchen cleaning a casserole dish. That is why we’ve done our thorough research to find you the best dishes for cleaning, maintenance, and convenience.

Cleaning a casserole dish is simple. The first thing to know is that each different material requires a different method of cleaning. Secondly, most casserole dishes are glazed and therefore do not have to be maintained quite as vigorously. All casserole dishes are oven safe and will have different heat capacities based on their material and size. Their material and size will also determine if they are dishwasher safe. Be sure to check if there is a dishwasher symbol on your dish or its container before using that method of cleaning. Not all ceramic dishes are double-glazed and therefore cannot be placed in a dishwasher.

For the ceramic casserole dish, first, rinse the dish. Then, sprinkle a powdery cleaning agent like the Barkeepers’ Friend Cleanser across the surface. Let it settle for 30 seconds and wipe it clean with a damp sponge. One final rinse and you can leave it to dry.

A cast iron casserole dish will need to be hand-washed. All you’ll need for this is a minimal amount of soap and water. If your food has gotten stuck, you may use a scraper, but do so gently. You do not want to leave scratches on your pot or dish. Immediately dry it with a lint-free cloth or paper napkin. Keep your dish looking gorgeous by rubbing some cooking oil (very lightly) onto it.

Clean your casserole dish after every use. This is to help prevent getting food poisoning from moldy dishes. While modern ceramic dishes with fine cracks are OK to continue using, older models contain lead, and this will lead to fatal lead poisoning, so it’s best to avoid using them. Fine cracks on glass casserole dishes may lead to major leaks and spills in your oven, which will cause endless hours of cleaning – best to avoid using them too.

Your casserole dish’s size will affect its ability to cook thoroughly, so you will need to adjust the time accordingly. A dish left too long in the oven will cause food to overcook and stick to the dish, which in turn affects its ability to be cleaned. Bear this in mind when purchasing your casserole dish.