The Best Cake Pans for 2023

Wondering what pan is best for baking a cake? This buying guide will help you decide.

Cakes are the quintessential part of any major celebration, and if you want to ensure that yours doesn’t fail, you’ll need to start by having the best cake pan at your disposal.

Baking is a very precise art form that requires the correct utensils, ingredients, measurements, and most importantly, the correct cake pan and size. The proper size ensures your cake will bake evenly, that it will have an exterior that lifts easily from the pan, and that it will have straight lines that are ready for frosting.

The type of material your cake pan is made of, as well as its thickness, will largely depend on what you intend to bake. It’s a good idea to have a variety of cake pans for all of your baking needs.

A well-made cake pan makes all of the difference in the baking process, so we’ve compiled a list of the best cake pans for 2022 for you to choose from!

How We Picked

  • Shape + Size

    The right shape and size of a cake pan ensure that the cake will bake evenly and at the right temperature. We’ve looked at a wide range of cake pans to see which ones suit the right cake.

  • Durability

    There’s nothing worse than having a cake fail because the batter leaked out of the cake pan. To avoid this, we’ve looked at the most durable and reliable cake pans for your baking needs.

  • Type of Edges

    Similar to the shape and size of a cake pan, the type of edges will help to determine the straight lines of your cake. The correct type will prevent your cake’s edges from hardening.

  • Cost-Effective

    Cake pans are made from all kinds of materials, and this affects their cost. We’ve looked at the most cost-effective ones to help make your baking process a valuable one.

Our Top Picks

Best Pick

All-Clad Pro-Release 9” Pan

All-Clad Pro-Release 9” Pan

This choice may take a big bite out of your pocket, but it is worth it.

A cake pan that is durable and able to withstand anything.

Buy Now for $27.99

The All-Clad Pro-Release 9” Pan’s proof is in the pudding, so to speak! From incredible durability to being made of aluminized steel, it’s the perfect solution to all of your baking needs.

The PFOA-free non-stick coating, along with its ceramic reinforcement, ensures this pan will withstand scratches and stains.

Its wide handles make it easy to carry around the kitchen and lift from the oven. High customer reviews and feedback applaud this pan for being sturdy and easy to clean.

Runner Up

Chicago Metallic Cake Pan Bakeware Set

Chicago Metallic Cake Pan Bakeware Set

Chicago Metallic’s 3 pan set boasts a non-stick coating and even heat distribution.

Thrice as nice and nearly half the price, this deal is a sweet one.

Buy Now for $19.65

The versatility of the Chicago Metallic Non-stick 3-Piece Set already makes it worth every dime. You can bake everything from tiered cakes to pies of various sizes and more.

The non-stick coating makes for cakes that slide out easily. All three pans are dishwasher-safe, and the heat distribution is consistent. Customer reviews rave about the pan’s great quality and cost-effectiveness.

Most Cost-Effective

T-fal Signature Nonstick Round Cake Pan

T-fal Signature Nonstick Round Cake Pan

Want to bake without breaking the bank? You’re in luck!

T-fal provides a cost-effective one-pan solution to your baking needs.

Buy Now for $6.99

This lightweight pan boasts hand holds for an easier grip, and its non-stick coating makes for easy cleaning. Made for the serious baker, the T-Fal Professional 9” Round Cake Pan is a great addition to your kitchen. Its lack of rolled edges ensures no rust will occur due to water hoarding. It’s cost-effective and gets the job done!

Everything We Recommend

Best Pick

All-Clad Pro-Release 9” Pan

All-Clad Pro-Release 9” Pan

This choice may take a big bite out of your pocket, but it is worth it.

$27.99

Buy Now

Runner Up

Chicago Metallic Cake Pan Bakeware Set

Chicago Metallic Cake Pan Bakeware Set

Chicago Metallic’s 3 pan set boasts a non-stick coating and even heat distribution.

$19.65

Buy Now

Most Cost-Effective

T-fal Signature Nonstick Round Cake Pan

T-fal Signature Nonstick Round Cake Pan

Want to bake without breaking the bank? You’re in luck!

$6.99

Buy Now

Who This Is For

The products advertised here are for all bakers, professional or amateur, who are looking for the best cake pans to realize their sweetest dreams!

Which type of cake pan should I buy?
To ensure that your cake is evenly baked, complete with a sweet browning, and can be lifted easily, you will need a sturdy cake pan.

You’d want to go with steel or aluminum cake pans with handles to carry them easily. They should also have a non-stick coating and be easy to clean.

Do I need a nonstick kind?
A non-stick cake pan isn’t crucial to your baking process because you can just as easily grease a pan for your needs.

However, to save time, speed up your baking, and save you the trouble of hours of scrubbing, a non-stick cake pan is the way to go.

Why You Should Trust Us

Many expensive cake pans are marketed toward professional bakers or large distribution baking companies. As such, we have found the easy-to-access, easy-to-buy, and most cost-effective cake pans for professionals and amateur bakers.

How We Picked

Choosing the best cake pan for you was as difficult as choosing which flavor we preferred between chocolate and red velvet! With so many great features and brands to choose from, the choices were tough ones.

We scoured over previous customers’ reviews of the cake pans they have used and what their baking experience with each product was like.

These experiences ranged from how well the cake pans endured high temperatures, to how easy it was to remove the baked cake, and how easily the pan could be cleaned after the baking process.

We searched through various products made from various materials, including aluminum and steel, to find the best size, shape, and durability for you! When making our picks, we looked for cake pans with extra features like the right types of edges and sufficient weight.

Across all of your choices, you’ll find an astute assessment of the pans’ capabilities, the level of easiness to help remove the cakes in one smooth move when they are baked, the virtues of anti-stick coating, and how the design or style of the pan best suits your needs.

We are mindful of making your purchase worthwhile. So we have searched for the best quality products at the best price.

Our Picks For You

Best Pick - All-Clad Pro-Release 9” Pan

Best Pick

All-Clad Pro-Release 9” Pan

All-Clad Pro-Release 9” Pan

This choice may take a big bite out of your pocket, but it is worth it.

A cake pan that is durable and able to withstand anything.

Buy Now for $27.99

Who It’s For:

The All-Clad Pro-Release 9” Pan is for the baker with a streak of experimentation. This is a versatile option. This cake pan can be used to make any baked goods. If you’re looking for a comfortable grip when lifting it in and out of the oven or from counter to counter, the pan’s oversized and integrated handles are made for that.

Why It’s Great:

Its commercial-grade aluminum steel material ensures that it is completely oven safe and will not warp at any point. The pan is coated in PFOA-free, ceramic-reinforced nonstick material. The pan is compatible with any baking utensil, so you’ll save on having to buy any special ones.

Potential Flaws:

The one major downside to this incredible pan is that it is not stackable, so you will need more cupboard space to store it. The non-stick coating is a bit on the thin side, so be careful when mixing or scraping batter from the pan.

Other Features:

This All-Clad pan may seem pricier than the other cake pans on our list, but it is undeniably durable. Other users have voted this product as being 5 out of 5 for its sturdiness and ease of cleaning. If you’d prefer to get two of these, we suggest buying the Amazon Basics Nonstick Round Baking Cake Pan, 9 Inch, Set of 2, which comes with an extra loaf pan, as seen below. Perfect for when you’re baking a two-layered cake, these pans have great durability, a non-stick coating, and are easy to clean.

Runner Up - Chicago Metallic Cake Pan Bakeware Set

Runner Up

Chicago Metallic Cake Pan Bakeware Set

Chicago Metallic Cake Pan Bakeware Set

Chicago Metallic’s 3 pan set boasts a non-stick coating and even heat distribution.

Thrice as nice and nearly half the price, this deal is a sweet one.

Buy Now for $19.65

Who It’s For:

This three-piece set is made for serious bakers with a desire to bake cakes and other goodies of all shapes and sizes.

Why It’s Great:

Forged from heavyweight aluminized steel, these pans are renowned for their superior heat distribution and easy release of baked goods. They are dishwasher safe, which makes your life easier, and they are a good value-for-money purchase.

Potential Flaws:

Amazon tends to not wrap this product efficiently and safely. Customer reviews have marked this unsafe packaging as the reason some of their pans arrived with a dent in them, thereby affecting the mold of the pan.

Other Features:

This product is a happy compromise between the other products reviewed here because it’s 3 pans, of various sizes, for the price of one! In one fell swoop, you can bake a three-tiered cake or different colored layers. The set’s durability has been hailed as one of its finest features, along with its versatility due to the various sizes of pans.

Most Cost-Effective - T-fal Signature Nonstick Round Cake Pan

Most Cost-Effective

T-fal Signature Nonstick Round Cake Pan

T-fal Signature Nonstick Round Cake Pan

Want to bake without breaking the bank? You’re in luck!

T-fal provides a cost-effective one-pan solution to your baking needs.

Buy Now for $6.99

Who It’s For:

Made from alloy steel, the T-fal cake pan is the helpmate of the baker looking to bake multiple layers of a cake.

Why It’s Great:

Its non-stick surface and its easy-to-grip handles make the process of taking it out and putting it into the oven super easy. Its lighter weight makes it easy to carry but no less durable. It will brown your cake beautifully without the danger of the pan warping.

Customer reviews are enthusiastic about how easy the T-fal cake pan is to clean and that its size is perfect for bakers with a small oven.

Potential Flaws:

When baking at 450 degrees, the T-fal pan has been known to warp, but it soon straightens itself out. Coating it in a degreaser may stain the pan. Putting it in the dishwasher may lead to its non-stick finish ending too soon.

Other Features:

This cake pan is definitely the cheapest on our list and the easiest to find. It’s incredibly easy to clean by hand and surprisingly sturdy for its weight. A good alternative is the Gorilla Grip Nonstick Round Baking Pans, which are just two dollars more, and made of durable carbon steel.

Available in various colors to match the rest of your baking supplies, its hand grips are made of silicone.

Almost Made The Cut - Nordic Ware Naturals Cake Set

Almost Made The Cut

Nordic Ware Naturals Cake Set

Nordic Ware Naturals Cake Set

Perfect sized to build the dream wedding cake

Evenly browned results every time you bake.

Buy Now for $51.97

Who It’s For:

A professional baker’s dream pan set, this Nordicware product is the ultimate necessity for baking the perfect wedding cake.

Why It’s Great:

Its key features are that it is made from natural aluminum and its consistent heating distribution. The various pans’ sizes ensure you’ll have perfectly sized layers with straight edges for frosting.

Being as expensive as it is, the set is best suited for professional bakers with some money at their disposal.

Potential Flaws:

These pans are dishwasher safe, so you will be spending a lot of time hand washing them after every spectacular wedding cake. You cannot cook or bake with acidic ingredients when using these pans, as it causes corrosion or discoloration of the pans.

Care and Maintenance

Since most of these cake pans are coated in a non-stick coating, which can vanish after too many washes, we do not recommend putting them in a dishwasher.

You would do well to wash these pans by hand and leave them to air dry or dry them thoroughly with a non-abrasive cloth.

Clean these cake pans immediately after baking with hot soapy water and a microfiber cloth to avoid crumbs sticking into the crevices of the pans.

Do not use any scratchy pads or steel wool for cleaning your non-stick cake pans. You can remove cooked-in grime with a mixture of baking soda and water or olive oil.

To keep your pans working smoothly, good oiling after every use and wash is a good idea. A teaspoon or half a tablespoon of oil should be enough.

For storage, you’ll need plenty of cupboard space for single cake pans. Avoid stacking pans that are not of the same size or shape to prevent scratches.

If you do need to stack your cake pans, do so by layering them with a dry, clean washcloth or reusable paper towel to avoid damage.